Mafiascum.net

In post 646, Sakura Hana wrote:Why does it always have to take me getting mad and frustrated to townread my towngames.

If it means anything to you, I haven't been considering your early pairing as a scum move for a while now, just one that I couldn't understand.

---

In post 749, RadiantCowbells wrote:i rly like brian skies

Really? I've actually been getting the feeling that he's scum here. At least, he doesn't seem similar at all to any of the games I've played with him where over time it just became apparent that he was town and was never really a question at all.

---

In post 752, Sakura Hana wrote:

In post 750, MariaR wrote:I feel moments play here is night and day from BBtag

Well that game he was a traitor. That role is pretty demoralizing.
OTOH I dunno what to think of him, he's been focusing so much on the "lack" of town motivation for my opening move than whether it had any actual scum motivation.

I don't think I've been focusing on that specifically over discussing other things, just commenting on it when it's come up.

---
Let me just go through things here.

I think Dunnstral, SirCakez, Karmeleon, and shotaru are town. If other people are confident in their ability to read Kokichi and say that he's town then I'll accept that (while also looking bitterly back at the people who said something similar about Maria in Forgotten Hourglass).
That leaves Gamma and Brian from the Gentlemen.

I don't have reasons to think Maria is town but I haven't noticed her being scum yet. For now I'll take that as her just being town rather than my not reading closely enough to have noticed her being scum. Sakura Hana is town, and ChibiBear seems town to me. Actually, that leaves me with a lot more left over Ladies than I thought. I seem to be the minority opinion when it comes to not townreading DVa (and perhaps LLD?).

In post 750, MariaR wrote:I want Sakura Kokichi and Dunn to tell me how they feel about moment because I feel moments play here is night and day from BBtag

I didn't exactly have much "play" there in the first place - sorry about that, by the way.

In post 554, DVa wrote:Yeah, I can see why you dislike those posts, but I feel like scum Sakura would have written them differently.

Instead of quoting the post and responding with her different take, she'd say, "LLD townreads [these four people], but that's wrong."

Like it's how she engages for me. When she was scum in BoR, she was 'this person said this, this person said that, this is how I feel about this thing that happened.'

Here she's, "You're wrong" and "I'm fosing here" and "but why?"

Like the style and structure of engagement seems really different to me and that's one of the things that always stands out to me in how certain people play scum vs town. it's why I was scumreading her in BoR and why I'm not here

Not sure about the real difference there?

In post 570, SirCakez wrote:Yo I have been following along today but obviously I took the L on actually commenting. Will try to write up some thoughts and reread.

To ngl this looks like someone in the scum PT reminded him to post

In post 591, Sakura Hana wrote:I've had enough of this.

@Kokichi: If you accept im going to suicide as soon as first dance starts, so dont accept.

Just leave me to die if you guys are going to hung over my head all my past scum wins.

People are arguing the opposite?

In post 774, SirCakez wrote:I don't like short's 770. Felt too hop-on-y, if that makes sense.

Considering I said it first in 747, it doesn't make sense at all.

In post 591, Sakura Hana wrote:I've had enough of this.

@Kokichi: If you accept im going to suicide as soon as first dance starts, so dont accept.

Just leave me to die if you guys are going to hung over my head all my past scum wins.

Ok. I'll accept you ONLY if you promise not to suicide

In post 781, Kokichi Oma wrote:

In post 591, Sakura Hana wrote:I've had enough of this.

@Kokichi: If you accept im going to suicide as soon as first dance starts, so dont accept.

Just leave me to die if you guys are going to hung over my head all my past scum wins.

Ok. I'll accept you ONLY if you promise not to suicide

Too late

In post 661, Brian Skies wrote:Town loses.

Mmmm tasty shade
I think Brian is the person I suspect most rn
Sakura, do you agree Brian is shady?

In post 783, Gamma Emerald wrote:Sakura, do you agree Brian is shady?

He is not a townread.

I do admit that i find him kinda different than what im used to tho?

Although that touhou game he was scum at was pretty similar to what i know of town him, so i dont think im that good at finding any meta differences. But I find him kinda underwhelming this game.

In post 580, ChibiBear wrote:

In post 575, shortaru wrote:

In post 573, ChibiBear wrote:I mean you specified different from old dances but then you go on to describe non-dance games.

No. Why don't you ask for clarification instead of jump to conclusions?

I've been looking over some of the old dances

(to familiarize myself with the format)

since my /in, and wow, this game is different

(from what I'm used to playing)

. Cool, though!

Make sense?

In post 573, ChibiBear wrote:I'm genuinely just not sure what to make of you yet.

No jumping here m8, thanks for the clarification.

English is my first language now but it hasn't always been

and I have run into trouble in past games with misunderstanding things/being misunderstood because my grammar is still a bit iffy.

Then english isn't your first language.

In post 749, RadiantCowbells wrote:i rly like brian skies

Why
I feel relatively confident in my read on him rn

In post 761, DVa wrote:odd thought but the scum is randomized right?

it's not guaranteed that there is at least 1 male?

Yeah it’s pure random

In post 787, Karmeleon wrote:Then english isn't your first language.

Hah, you're funny.

In post 786, Sakura Hana wrote:Although that touhou game he was scum at was pretty similar to what i know of town him, so i dont think im that good at finding any meta differences. But I find him kinda underwhelming this game.

Excellent, you got the direction I was going with my question. Brian definitely feels similar to touhou this game in how flat his posts feel.
Now can someone address my Cakez concern?

I spectated the Touhou game, so im not sure how it felt to actually interact with him, one thing that crossed my mind was that his stance towards claims was the same back in Midnight scummer's dream, it's something easy to continue to do as scum tho. My main concern is that he feels different from Phantom Hourglass and Minuet's Trio. It feels like he has no aim and is just commenting.

Coulda sworn you were in that touhou game

In post 700, Brian Skies wrote:Wow, I'm actually a lot higher than I thought I'd be.

This however, feels like he's aware that he's not doing anything to be hardly townread for and is surprised that someone is townreading him that high.
Mental Note: If either LLD or Brian is scum, they arent scum together.

In post 793, Gamma Emerald wrote:Coulda sworn you were in that touhou game

Nah I didnt play touhou upick 5, i played the previous 4 tho.

I think I mistook you for someone else then

In post 794, Sakura Hana wrote:

In post 700, Brian Skies wrote:Wow, I'm actually a lot higher than I thought I'd be.

This however, feels like he's aware that he's not doing anything to be hardly townread for and is surprised that someone is townreading him that high.
Mental Note: If either LLD or Brian is scum, they arent scum together.

Addenum that I forgot: This could possibly mean Brian town.

In post 652, MariaR wrote:God I wish I played on an alt so there wouldn't be paranoia and I could dance with Cakez

Hi

Missed that from Maria
The thing is shed alt slip at some point and blow her cover