Magical Girls UPick - Heart of Shadow (Game Over)

[Lady Eventide]

Spoiler:

Would you care to use actual arguments instead of projectile vomit?

Hey eventide I think my reaction is easy to explain if you actually read my 714 and 721.
And the thread exploding is a product of 1)A 6+ page long fight 2)Personal insults.
So try again Eventide, this time with less "thread exploding" nonsense and more quoting/actual arguments

"A 6+ page long fight full of personal insults" = "The Thread Exploding". Little of use got done; the thread was an AtE storm and it's only just now starting to settle. Your own deeply disgusted reaction says that it's annoying everyone and harming Town morale. That is bad. That is the kind of posting the scum want to happen.

Also, wow, I missed two of your posts from literally one page ago. What a horrible oversight. I don't see why you should

puke

over that.

You're looking scummy and overdefensive right now. "I

think

my reaction is

easy to explain

" - not "my reaction is

because

." And then you dig into me for not posting while I was asleep. Lovely.

(And no, Lilliare did not make the early mechanical posts you ascribe to her. Her only posts are the ones she's signed. -E)

Since I already responded to 755 and you are waiting for my response I suppose you are talking about this one.
1. I do agree that scum would ideally want to bring town morale down but as I already said I do not think that this was intentional here.
2. I didn't really atack you for not reading my posts. Tho you voting one page after my posts did bring me to the idea that you were caught up and thus had read my posts.
3. Dunno about overdefensive, frustrated by titus more likely. I explained my problem with her posting but she just keeps on doing more of the same so yea. That's what it might seem like rn. And my choice of words might not be the best, yes, maybe it can be explained with me not being a native english speaker or maybe because I have a chaotic mind sometimes. Idk.

Cool.

VOTE: Lady Lambdadelta

I'm noticing that despite acknowledging my arguments, you haven't actually

done

anything about them.

-E

[Titus]

Alright not sitting on gamplay alone.

VOTE: Sailor

[gameplay506]

Cool.

VOTE: Lady Lambdadelta

I'm noticing that despite acknowledging my arguments, you haven't actually done anything about them.

-E

Why LLD over Sailor?

[Tana and Ephraim]

Hey Titus, what's your read on pops.
-Tana

Town based on his posting and him popping up as a counter to my SRs. Open to reevaluating. Not locktown.

What do you think of this?:

also I lowkey think pops is the real scum here who slipped in an unvote so she could vote on the Senshi wagon later in a more natural / less noticeable way

-Tana

[Lady Eventide]

Cool.

VOTE: Lady Lambdadelta

I'm noticing that despite acknowledging my arguments, you haven't actually done anything about them.

-E

Why LLD over Sailor?

Sailor hasn't responded and seems inactive. LLD did in fact respond to my earlier post. -E

[Gamma Emerald]

Wow, like six pages of useless flaming overnight. Mafia must be laughing and laughing right now.

And it all started with pressure being put on Sailor Senshi, so guess where my vote's going?

VOTE: Sailor Senshi

If the thread explodes when someone gets pressured, >rand they're scum.

This vote sucks real bad
I don't think you actually read those pages

[Titus]

Hey Titus, what's your read on pops.
-Tana

Town based on his posting and him popping up as a counter to my SRs. Open to reevaluating. Not locktown.

What do you think of this?:

also I lowkey think pops is the real scum here who slipped in an unvote so she could vote on the Senshi wagon later in a more natural / less noticeable way

-Tana

That's the type of thing I tend to be more confident in VCA but it's possible.

[Gamma Emerald]

FPSing

Why would you need to get a hold of False Peek Stating?

[Katsuki]

[Sailor Senshi]

Sailor hasn't responded and seems inactive.

Excuse me.....what? We went from 2 posts to 2nd top poster what part of that is.....inactive. We litteraly didnt post for 1 day and we got called a lurker. 1 day. You vote was the worse thing ever and chaning vote now wont salvage that. Not only had you read you would have known what exactly went on and why was anythng taking as a personal attack. How me,nancy and sakrua were trying to calm things down because it wasnt lol herp derp I am scum let me personal attack people. You read nothing saw tractiong and voted there based on general knowledge of what happened.

Vote: Lady Eventide

@Titus
D: cookies I was out a party alright, I that why my first day was doing nothing. Also let's be honest since when were my caughts up informative or anything other than most of the time a gif and a I caught up.

Sailor Venus

[Sailor Senshi]

hmm

Eventide's vote on SS is pretty shoddy. being pressured leading to spat is a terribly weak reason to scum read people... what do you want, that after being pressured you just lay down and die?

I don't think gameplay is scum, but please don't use personal RL stuff as a point of attack.

If Eventide would flip scum, Titus's (hello titus!) attack on gameplay is very much chainsaw.

Pressure leading to

personal attacks and threats of reporting

is very much a scumtell. Pressure leading to

debate and defense

is

not;

it's the fact that it got personal very quickly that's pinging me. Personal arguments don't say shit about the gamestate, and therefore mafia want to cast any disagreement with them as a personal issue, not a legitimate argument based on real evidence. I've straight up called a townie a bitch and an asshole to cover for a scumslip I made. I'm not

proud

of that, but it's a thing that I did.

-Evenstar

Like come on, did you even read what happened.

[Tana and Ephraim]

Like, okay this wasn't irt my slot and it wasn't specifically "stop playing the game" but given this game was half a year ago and that's basically the last time I remember you being scum outside of memey minis, that basically sounds like a philosophy of "as scum, be annoying and obnoxious" -- so sorry, but not sorry, I felt like I was just characterizing what you have said about your own scum play. If I was wrong I was wrong but making it seem that I was deliberately trying to attack you--I was just paraphrasing this post while half-remembering it.

Personally being obnoxious and annoying to an extent to one player is not the same as actively being okay with ruining the game for people and my unhappiness with Pintu replacing out and the fact that I offered to replace out in his stead should clearly indicate that this was not my endgame

.

[Lady Eventide]

FPSing

Why would you need to get a hold of False Peek Stating?

Fancy Play Syndrome.

[Lady Eventide]

Sailor hasn't responded and seems inactive.

Excuse me.....what? We went from 2 posts to 2nd top poster what part of that is.....inactive. We litteraly didnt post for 1 day and we got called a lurker. 1 day. You vote was the worse thing ever and chaning vote now wont salvage that. Not only had you read you would have known what exactly went on and why was anythng taking as a personal attack. How me,nancy and sakrua were trying to calm things down because it wasnt lol herp derp I am scum let me personal attack people. You read nothing saw tractiong and voted there based on general knowledge of what happened.

Vote: Lady Eventide

@Titus
D: cookies I was out a party alright, I that why my first day was doing nothing. Also let's be honest since when were my caughts up informative or anything other than most of the time a gif and a I caught up.

Sailor Venus

... *facepalm*

Thanks for at least responding. Also, "traction"? Really? Sure doesn't seem to be a whole lot of that.

Given that apparently whatever I do gets me scumread by somebody, might as well just carry on carrying on.

VOTE: Sailor Senshi

@Gamma Emerald:
Nope I didn't. Why should I? It looks like a mess of AtE at a skim. What useful information do you expect me to extract from it?

[Titus]

@Shiro

[Lady Eventide]

@Shiro

oh come on I don't need to be playing hungry too

- E

[Sailor Senshi]

@Shiro

Titus I am town this game join me on Lady Event, I am certain I got scum that wanted an easy place to park a vote got called out, gave atrocious reasoning, tried to bail and now forced to commit.

[Tana and Ephraim]

This attack from LE onto Senshi is making me think LE scum and Senshi town.
It speaks more volumes than anything Senshi's done this game so far, feels opportunistic.
UNVOTE:
Gonna talk with RC and see what he thinks about it.
-Tana

[Lady Eventide]

It's time I got serious about this shit so let's do a readslist. All this is based on ISOs 'cause I'm lazy tbqh.

Gameplay:
Probably town. Off-timezone due to euro and constantly behind, which explains a lot of their cluelessness. Does actually seem to be trying to contribute. I see why people leapt on their early post, but entrances are hard and Vanity got killed in WC1 for that kind of thing, so I think that's cool. Their defense of it feels towny to me.

Titus:
Leaps on the early gameplay comment as scummy. Until then is kinda fluffposting and I don't like their tone. I don't think Gameplay is over-defensive here. Calls Gameplay asking "Where have I been overdefensive" a "mild gaslight." If there's a scum in this pair I'm really feeling like it's Titus right now. Continuing the ISO... Ugh, I wish I had the multi-iso tool from mafiauniverse here. Seeing just the titus/gameplay fight would be nice. Interesting that he deflects away from pops early, does he continue that?

..."go visit my Goddaughter."

... is that literally a godfather claim???? Ugh. I don't like this. Original leader of the Sailor vote, ok... Tana hops on... Accuses Gameplay of doing nothing but needling... There is at least one Townie in this fight, and if someone is scum it's Titus but this is looking more T/T just for the tunneling happening here. Maintains his sus of Gameplay even when he's voting Sailor. That says he's actually using his vote as a weapon, which is towny. Tries to link Sailor and Gameplay together, that's a worse look but also possibly town-motivated, so NAI - seeing ghosts, trying to make everything fit the current theory. I don't like their hop off the Sailor wagon for it 'organically dying' - evaluating current state of wagons has scummy mindset. And then he flipflops back to Sailor.

...Sailor and Titus are never scum together, so sorting Titus/Sailor is looking v important. Annnnd cookie ok.

Overall... I feel really unsure about Titus now.

... and now I'm being sent to mow the lawn, so. Gonna go do that. Yay. -E

[Titus]

Lmao. The Goddaughter comment is about my literal Goddaughter.

Evaluating wagon states is scummy. Lmfao.

[Dannflor]

Given that apparently whatever I do gets me scumread by somebody, might as well just carry on carrying on.

yikes

[Lady Eventide]

Given that apparently whatever I do gets me scumread by somebody, might as well just carry on carrying on.

yikes

SEE WHAT I MEAN

[Lady Eventide]

lol
-E

[Dannflor]

I had to

[Dannflor]

No. I'm hoping we get even more developments and information by the time I'm revoting anywhere, and it might not be Senshi. I'm still possibly a sucker for the (fake?) townslip.

If you scumread me I hope I at least get to be town IRL, though.

Of course you're town IRL <3

What town slip did you see?

Also, where are the rest of your reads right now?