Mafiascum.net

In post 770, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 682, Ydrasse wrote:pooky, what's different between this game and nancy vs titus, by the way?

it feels like, generally, when you're town and someone you Like is town, you sort of don't immediately jump to thinking they're scum and start pushing them and trying to case; it feels like you call them silly, go "oh you're town haha and all your reads are good but not that one!" and you're not... doing that this game? there's a lack of silliness when it comes to the /content/ (because even when you were getting pushed there i feel you had a sense of levity in how you responded) and here it's just like you are more down to business, "he is scum he is not town with a bad read" and i want to understand what you think the difference is? because from what i can tell, you shouldn't be reacting like this to his read on you (at least, fmpov beacuse i think he's town) :<

i also have a tinfoil i will keep to myself that makes me think you are leaning more into scum

Well you can read in the mason discord, I said I thought Hectic's probly town because all of his scumreads except for me are the same as all of my scumreads so he's got the same approach to the game as me.

That's not possible to do here because there's no multiple other scumreads for me to use as a baseline to read him.

In post 771, Ydrasse wrote:he doesn't need it to survive but it's still nice nonetheless

i think another issue i have with him is that he has this really cool obvious plan, he is the number 1 fan for it, but i haven't seen him do a lot to like... see it to fruition to actually catch scum, which maybe im hypocritical bc lord knows i don't always do things, but idk, just feels like there's no passion there

In post 773, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 764, Ydrasse wrote:i will never be convinced to kill no face btw idc idc idc im doubling down on the townread and i am going to look like a fool if hes scum afte r this game but i've cracked the code where i know how to read him now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

you have literally never played a game with scum!him so how would you know what scum!him looks like?

In post 776, Menalque wrote:

In post 771, Ydrasse wrote:he doesn't need it to survive but it's still nice nonetheless

i think another issue i have with him is that he has this really cool obvious plan, he is the number 1 fan for it, but i haven't seen him do a lot to like... see it to fruition to actually catch scum, which maybe im hypocritical bc lord knows i don't always do things, but idk, just feels like there's no passion there

yeh it’s nice but not worth just... not getting the cred and seeing if town successfully shoot themselves in the foot

again, when has pooky traditionally done that much to actually see his plans through? I think I’ve seen pooky kind of effort when pushing someone but mostly I feel like I only see him effort when he’s under pressure to not die

In post 777, Ydrasse wrote:

In post 773, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 764, Ydrasse wrote:i will never be convinced to kill no face btw idc idc idc im doubling down on the townread and i am going to look like a fool if hes scum afte r this game but i've cracked the code where i know how to read him now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

you have literally never played a game with scum!him so how would you know what scum!him looks like?

i don't but as it stands right now i feel assured in that, i understand how he approaches reading things, and yes maybe he can replicate it, but in this specific game i was able to identify his like... the way he reads things as town, that i have seen him do over and over, DESPITE the fact that there was a gimmick that i had to read past, which makes me feel especially good about townreading him right now

In post 781, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 777, Ydrasse wrote:

In post 773, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 764, Ydrasse wrote:i will never be convinced to kill no face btw idc idc idc im doubling down on the townread and i am going to look like a fool if hes scum afte r this game but i've cracked the code where i know how to read him now!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

you have literally never played a game with scum!him so how would you know what scum!him looks like?

i don't but as it stands right now i feel assured in that, i understand how he approaches reading things, and yes maybe he can replicate it, but in this specific game i was able to identify his like... the way he reads things as town, that i have seen him do over and over, DESPITE the fact that there was a gimmick that i had to read past, which makes me feel especially good about townreading him right now

do you think his scum game is noticeably different from his town game?

In post 775, Ydrasse wrote:pooky

what are your reads right now? if youve given them can u quote them

In post 782, Menalque wrote:Infinity justify ur SR on me

In post 540, Infinity 324 wrote:In the future if someone doesn't like a PoE vote that I make, questioning my TRs is much more useful than questioning the vote itself

In post 783, Ydrasse wrote:i know you're going to think this is like, an insane person's rambling but yes, i don't expect anyone else to understand what i'm seeing when i go like, there's a way he thinks about games that i can identify from over time that very much clicks for me as town/not town, and i'm going to feel dumb the day that comes that he's scum against me sure maybe, but like. i feel even then i'll probably have some pings that make me go ? from him and i literally have no pings right now, zero, he's town and he's town beyond the gimmick

In post 792, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 783, Ydrasse wrote:i know you're going to think this is like, an insane person's rambling but yes, i don't expect anyone else to understand what i'm seeing when i go like, there's a way he thinks about games that i can identify from over time that very much clicks for me as town/not town, and i'm going to feel dumb the day that comes that he's scum against me sure maybe, but like. i feel even then i'll probably have some pings that make me go ? from him and i literally have no pings right now, zero, he's town and he's town beyond the gimmick

The way he thinks about how to push an elimination as town is the same as how he thinks about how to push an elimination as scum. They are two sides of the same coin.

If it was different he would be caught as scum... The thought process doesn't change.

In post 752, Menalque wrote:

In post 747, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:

In post 743, Menalque wrote:

In post 741, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:the scum in the 3pool can't bus

This isn’t true and is a bad assumption and lends itself to gambiting

i mean sure they could go very gambitty but I wanna push the scum to take risks in this kind of setup

Let’s just lim vanders and win automatically

In post 791, Infinity 324 wrote:

In post 540, Infinity 324 wrote:In the future if someone doesn't like a PoE vote that I make, questioning my TRs is much more useful than questioning the vote itself

In post 790, No Face wrote:Menalque I don't remember the last time you townread me D:

actually it was that time I was scum in nightmare :<

In post 793, Menalque wrote:I literally couldnt care less about the soul circle stuff, I’m just in a slightly peppery mood and seeing pooky reach E-1 for no reason was a provocation

Spoiler: