Mafiascum.net

Trapped in a nightmare universe where Dann keeps going down and Val keeps going up.

holy shit val think about your posts if you're town

what possible reason could speculating about the setup be bad considering scum know what world we're in?

it actually might just be ythan here but I'll deal with that tomorrow

In post 776, Dannflor wrote:
what possible reason could speculating about the setup be bad considering scum know what world we're in?

Exactly my point; and yet you are telling us to shut up, because we will give information away that scum already know...

no...

there's an answer

that was not a rhetorical question

Morning friends.

Good morning.

Just want to confirm something, Leaven what did you get for your results?

Actually who am I kidding, it's probably A1 and they RBed Leaven and went to try to get rid of the Doctor.

Speaking of which, wouldn't claiming PR at this point of the game be better than staying silent?

Explain yourself.

I read the count wrong, but here's what I thought.

With Leaven being confirmed, scum would be down to me, Ythan, Dann, and Val84. If there is a second PR, that would leave 3 out of the 5 people left. Another point is that it's a 1v4 at this point of the game. We can mess up once, and can use that to our advantage. To me this would make claiming PRs as scum basically impossible if the PRs are competent enough to know fake claims. And if they call out a fakeclaim from scum, we can theoretically just vote both of them out if both claim. Also, from my perspective, the game would be solved already since the last two remaining has scum and town in it.

That's wrong. No claim.

If there is a doctor and they claim then we'll eliminate among the remaining three and the doctor will be killed tonight leaving Leaven and two unconfirmed players.

I'd rather have a chance to win in 1/3 with two conf and later 1/2 with one confirmed right now than just a 1/4 to get it right and a 1/2 to get this right.

In post 792, Ythan wrote:If there is a doctor and they claim then we'll eliminate among the remaining three and the doctor will be killed tonight leaving Leaven and two unconfirmed players.

Also, can you give me a good reason as to why not claiming is better and why I'm wrong?

In post 793, StrangeMatter wrote:I'd rather have a chance to win in 1/3 with two conf and later 1/2 with one confirmed right now than just a 1/4 to get it right and a 1/2 to get this right.

If a doctor gets run up today they claim then just like Leaven did. Only scum is advantaged by claiming before that.

In post 794, StrangeMatter wrote:

In post 792, Ythan wrote:If there is a doctor and they claim then we'll eliminate among the remaining three and the doctor will be killed tonight leaving Leaven and two unconfirmed players.

Also, can you give me a good reason as to why not claiming is better and why I'm wrong?

For the first, what I said above and also what I said previously that you have not successfully refuted at all. For the second, because everything you're saying is foolishness or intentional deceit that offers nothing of benefit to the town.

In post 750, Dannflor wrote:no I'll wait until tomorrow

if I die I die

Not forgetting this.

I did get blocked last night.

In post 795, Ythan wrote: For the first, what I said above and also what I said previously that you have not successfully refuted at all. For the second, because everything you're saying is foolishness or intentional deceit that

offers nothing of benefit to the town.

I'm not going to refute what you've said about scum killing doctor if they claim. However, offering nothing to the benefit of the town is not correct. The point of this was Process of Elimination, which in turn means VTs would have only two people to eliminate. Scum obviously has to get the blame onto the other two slots in a row as well.

So if you just don't agree and say it's foolish or decitful, then fine. I'll just bite my tongue and never share ideas like this again.

In post 795, Ythan wrote:If a doctor gets run up today they claim then just like Leaven did. Only scum is advantaged by claiming before that.

^This!!!^

Why claim before that?