Page 32 of 59
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:05 pm
by Star Shape
These are gut reads so far but I'll elaborate when I fully get what I'm feeling
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:07 pm
by Color Purple
In post 762, Star Shape wrote: In post 734, Color Purple wrote:I feel so betrayed by Heart. If we don't eliminate them, please delay them. I would like Heart to explain everything at once. Then, I might vote them.
Is this a vote for me to delay heart?
If Heart is not eliminated and the others want to.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:10 pm
by Star Shape
Arrow feels rather stagnant, if you will?
His reads come across the same since the beginning of the game regarding green, pent, and orange. It doesn't feel like he's evolving that much throughout the game.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:11 pm
by Color Purple
I hope that you are right on Heart. If you want, you can delay your own scumreads/scumleans.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:13 pm
by Star Shape
In post 580, Heart Shape wrote: In post 579, Circle Shape wrote: In post 577, Heart Shape wrote: In post 575, Circle Shape wrote:what are your actual reads heart
the only opinions i can seem to find from you is that you think purple and arrow are town
I don't have a whole lot yet. I think this preliminary stage isn't necessarily the best way to locktown or lockscum anyone.
i did not ask you to locktown or lockscum anyone
this seems a curious exaggeration on your part
Take it any way you want. Doesn't make my thinking on this any less valid. I don't know how anyone can have anything but tentative positions until we actually know what's what. Right now people, including myself, are developing reads based on what exactly. We don't even really know what's going on yet.
I feel Heart is getting scumread based off playstyle n not content, if that makes sense
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:13 pm
by Color Purple
You know. I am going to take a plunge and believe that Heart is Town.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:14 pm
by Star Shape
In post 778, Color Purple wrote:
I hope that you are right on Heart. If you want, you can delay your own scumreads/scumleans.
The irony lol
I don't have much as far as reads but I hold the positions I've already given
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:14 pm
by Color Purple
In post 779, Star Shape wrote: In post 580, Heart Shape wrote: In post 579, Circle Shape wrote: In post 577, Heart Shape wrote: In post 575, Circle Shape wrote:what are your actual reads heart
the only opinions i can seem to find from you is that you think purple and arrow are town
I don't have a whole lot yet. I think this preliminary stage isn't necessarily the best way to locktown or lockscum anyone.
i did not ask you to locktown or lockscum anyone
this seems a curious exaggeration on your part
Take it any way you want. Doesn't make my thinking on this any less valid. I don't know how anyone can have anything but tentative positions until we actually know what's what. Right now people, including myself, are developing reads based on what exactly. We don't even really know what's going on yet.
I feel Heart is getting scumread based off playstyle n not content, if that makes sense
It makes sense.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:33 pm
by Color Green
In post 777, Star Shape wrote:Arrow feels rather stagnant, if you will?
His reads come across the same since the beginning of the game regarding green, pent, and orange. It doesn't feel like he's evolving that much throughout the game.
I still don't think willingly shoving his head into the obtuse sands time and time again while also admitting fault comes from scum, like, ever, though.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 5:35 pm
by Color Green
In post 782, Color Purple wrote: In post 779, Star Shape wrote: In post 580, Heart Shape wrote: In post 579, Circle Shape wrote: In post 577, Heart Shape wrote: In post 575, Circle Shape wrote:what are your actual reads heart
the only opinions i can seem to find from you is that you think purple and arrow are town
I don't have a whole lot yet. I think this preliminary stage isn't necessarily the best way to locktown or lockscum anyone.
i did not ask you to locktown or lockscum anyone
this seems a curious exaggeration on your part
Take it any way you want. Doesn't make my thinking on this any less valid. I don't know how anyone can have anything but tentative positions until we actually know what's what. Right now people, including myself, are developing reads based on what exactly. We don't even really know what's going on yet.
I feel Heart is getting scumread based off playstyle n not content, if that makes sense
It makes sense.
Please let heart answer the questions on their own, and stop trampling on the pressure and lines of questioning. You are literally harming the game state no matter heart's alignment here.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:01 pm
by Arrow Shape
I feel it's kind of typical for people to hold unto first impressions way longer than they should.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:04 pm
by Arrow Shape
In post 777, Star Shape wrote:Arrow feels rather stagnant, if you will?
His reads come across the same since the beginning of the game regarding green, pent, and orange. It doesn't feel like he's evolving that much throughout the game.
I'm not really seeing anything to change my mind on Orange.
And my read of Pentagon has been up and down but I just haven't been commenting on it.
As for Green I'm tunneled, but I'll just get out of soon I hope.
Rather, I probably wanna shoot a reset there.
I'm kind of paranoid about replace ins in general though. You're both better than the previous iterations, but that doesn't make me feel better, it just makes me more suspicious.
Hopefully, I won't be too tiresome to deal with.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:14 pm
by Arrow Shape
Should I shoot a reset there. I sort of feel like, well there's a lot to unpack with Green's current play. They're talking about sort of nebulous concepts that don't really have an objectively correct answer other than on the extremes ends which are probably bad for town. I also don't think, based on what Green's play is like so far, that they don't see the value in having a good neighbor.
I feel like they might just come across as dishonest sometimes though, but not for the reasons I may think.
Well, I can always just change my mind.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:38 pm
by Color Orange
Are we meant to have our private threads yet?
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:40 pm
by Color Orange
In post 1, penguin_alien wrote:6) Pairing PTs will open at the start of Night One and remain open for the remainder of the game so long as both players are alive. All Night Phases will be two days/48 hours. Each paired player will be sent a PM informing them of their partner's Power or Modifier. The player will not be informed of their own Power or Modifier.
I guess not. I feel rather upset as I was hoping to get a chance to talk shop with Triangle a bit in my limited availability I have tonight.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:43 pm
by Color Orange
In post 704, Color Green wrote:Reading is clearly too hard for some of you.
Everyone else
Literal ocean trench
Red
Smaller gap
Heart
I'm at least a little shocked nobody else sees the glaring perspective slip from heart....
I saw what you called a perspective slip and that should have been noticed before your initial reads list. So why did Heart only get bumped down after some prodding?
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:47 pm
by Color Orange
In post 710, Triangle Shape wrote: In post 503, Circle Shape wrote:also power + modifier corresponding to color + shape was incredibly obvious based on the rules and signup and didnt take asking the mod
the fact that triangle is continuing to push that argument is way way worse than using the info from a mainslip post and has me raising an eyebrow
a nw chllngr apprchs.
Not impressed with you shading my town read over your failure to practice basic processing of context clues. I also think it was painfully evident pairings were meant to be color + shape. So the most charitable view I can give your little attempt at speculation is you are just painfully daft. But I feel like that contradicts some of the personality you exhibit in your explanation of the textspeak gimmick.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:50 pm
by Pentagon Shape
In post 789, Color Orange wrote: In post 1, penguin_alien wrote:6) Pairing PTs will open at the start of Night One and remain open for the remainder of the game so long as both players are alive. All Night Phases will be two days/48 hours. Each paired player will be sent a PM informing them of their partner's Power or Modifier. The player will not be informed of their own Power or Modifier.
I guess not. I feel rather upset as I was hoping to get a chance to talk shop with Triangle a bit in my limited availability I have tonight.
Yeah because considering we’re now voting, having pts would probably make this a lot easier to make reads except of course with Star.
@Star what is you think about Heart’s playstyle is getting misread?
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:50 pm
by Color Orange
In post 734, Color Purple wrote:I feel so betrayed by Heart. If we don't eliminate them, please delay them. I would like Heart to explain everything at once. Then, I might vote them.
I don’t get this? This feels very overdramatic.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:53 pm
by Color Orange
In post 756, Color Green wrote:
Are you going for the "I read the least actual posts this game" award, or?
In post 704, Color Green wrote:Reading is clearly too hard for some of you.
Everyone else
Literal ocean trench
Red
Smaller gap
Heart
In post 652, Color Green wrote:
Probably because there's a gap the size of the marinas trench between red and everyone above them!
The sooner we pair up the sooner I can murder heart and then red!
In post 611, Color Green wrote:I have been sitting outside the fog of war, following along since the beginning.
Here are my reads prior to replacing in. (Obviously, this ignores my own role PM, but I was fairly confident it was a town slot)
Extremely Town:
Color Blue
Color Purple
Circle Shape
Town:
Color Green
Triangle Shape
Color Orange
Arrow Shape
Pentagon Shape
Could Go Either Way:
Color Yellow
Diamond Shape
Star Shape
Please Deny Endgame:
Heart Shape
Kill As Soon As Able:
Color Red
I do believe all remaining unpaired folks are town, and that the delayer is going to be town as such. Damn the torpedo(s), we eliminate scum, not drag our heels at what could have been with all PR pairings being intact.
I explicitly chose not to replace into the red slot as I felt the posts that caused it to be replaced were extremely scum indicative, even in a vacuum of a general unnamed player.
Oh how woefully you contradict yourself!
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:56 pm
by Color Purple
In post 793, Color Orange wrote: In post 734, Color Purple wrote:I feel so betrayed by Heart. If we don't eliminate them, please delay them. I would like Heart to explain everything at once. Then, I might vote them.
I don’t get this? This feels very overdramatic.
Oh. I meant that if Heart is scum. Wasn't thinking properly when writing
that post. I guess you're right. I overreacted overdramatically. Sorry.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:56 pm
by Pentagon Shape
In post 611, Color Green wrote:I have been sitting outside the fog of war, following along since the beginning.
Here are my reads prior to replacing in. (Obviously, this ignores my own role PM, but I was fairly confident it was a town slot)
Extremely Town:
Color Blue
Color Purple
Circle Shape
Town:
Color Green
Triangle Shape
Color Orange
Arrow Shape
Pentagon Shape
Could Go Either Way:
Color Yellow
Diamond Shape
Star Shape
Please Deny Endgame:
Heart Shape
Kill As Soon As Able:
Color Red
I do believe all remaining unpaired folks are town, and that the delayer is going to be town as such. Damn the torpedo(s), we eliminate scum, not drag our heels at what could have been with all PR pairings being intact.
I explicitly chose not to replace into the red slot as
I felt the posts that caused it to be replaced were extremely scum indicative
, even in a vacuum of a general unnamed player.
You do realize that the reason for red replace out was the main slipping, don’t you?
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 6:57 pm
by Color Orange
In post 777, Star Shape wrote:Arrow feels rather stagnant, if you will?
His reads come across the same since the beginning of the game regarding green, pent, and orange. It doesn't feel like he's evolving that much throughout the game.
Why is consistency scummy for you? I’ll give you that some flexibility on the replaced slots might be more prudent but except for Red, the newcomers have not felt great so I think playing hardball on those is valid.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 7:02 pm
by Color Orange
In post 795, Color Purple wrote: In post 793, Color Orange wrote: In post 734, Color Purple wrote:I feel so betrayed by Heart. If we don't eliminate them, please delay them. I would like Heart to explain everything at once. Then, I might vote them.
I don’t get this? This feels very overdramatic.
Oh. I meant that if Heart is scum. Wasn't thinking properly when writing
that post. I guess you're right. I overreacted overdramatically. Sorry.
I’m going to take my own plunge and say that you are likely town (more than you already have been). It’s such a visceral reaction to the situation, I struggle to see it as anything other than genuine distress at being swindled.
Posted: Tue Nov 23, 2021 7:04 pm
by Color Orange
In post 787, Arrow Shape wrote:Should I shoot a reset there. I sort of feel like, well there's a lot to unpack with Green's current play. They're talking about sort of nebulous concepts that don't really have an objectively correct answer other than on the extremes ends which are probably bad for town. I also don't think, based on what Green's play is like so far, that they don't see the value in having a good neighbor.
I feel like they might just come across as dishonest sometimes though, but not for the reasons I may think.
Well, I can always just change my mind.
What are you trying to get at with this? It reads a bit like gibberish.