Mafiascum.net

The Fonz wrote:

DrippingGoofball wrote:

ac1983fan wrote:A tracker doesn't get "guilty" or "innocent"...

"home" or "not home" or some such equivalent then.

Haaaaaaaaaaaaang on... wait a second, you're supposed to BE a tracker in this game. Surely you know what format results are in?

Vote: DGB

Hammah Time!

I will be RBing CTD.

I meant in general, not in particular to this game, turkey.

You're so scum.

But thanks for putting me one YET one more game closer to retirement!

Not voting (2): DrippingGoofball, Nightfall

With players alive, it takes votes to lynch.

Well, regardless of the reason for no kill, that puts us out of LyLo, I'm pretty sure.

I'm more inclined to believe Fonz's role also. The possibility still exists that he doesn't have roleblocking powers, but because he delcared to block CTD, Nightfall didn't submit a night action in order to convict CTD even though Fonz didn't submit a roleblock of his own. I STRONGLY suspect nightfall as the last mafia, and I'm surprised at the lack of kill if Fonz actually blocked CTD.

However, if our theories on number of scum is correct, we can afford a mislynch today.

There should only be one scum, therefore, we should have a mislynch. After all, why would there be a no kill if there were two scum; they could've won the game had they killed last night.

So, even though I'm definitely not cleared, FMPOV, the last scum is amoungst CTD and Nightfall, and we have a mislynch. I'm inclined to think CTD is the scummiest, although I have flexibility.

I'd like to hear Fonz' confirmation on who he blocked last night.

I didn't block. I doc-protected CTD. (My theory was, having declared a block on CTD, the scum would have to try to kill him, or risk clearing him if they killed anyone else. I was deliberately trying to WIFOM them onto a doc-protected target, whilst keeping my block in hand. Whether that happened, or they no-killed to frame, is beside the point- the action bought us a mislynch).

Now of course, it's possible a scum-CTD believing he was going to be blocked didn't bother putting in a kill. I don't, to be honest, think that's likely though. I am starting to feel a little paranoid about a possible Zilla-Godmother though, given how she protected DGB yesterday.

There isn't much I can say about that other than I turned around at a crucial moment due to a case by CTD. I also stand by the asterisks thing being a huge slip.

Which would, of course, implicate Nightfall...

Ed: Who was pretty damn high on my scumdar to begin with, to be fair.

Maybe we'll get some discussion going.

...What can I say?

It's your move, scumboy.

I'm still leaning towards ac1983fan. Didn't like his first post of the day (and while Nightfall's wasn't exactly inspiring either, it doesn't strike me as particularly scummy).

A cursory glance over Braeden's and DGB's posts unfortunately doesn't reveal much. Will do more reading and analysis after work.

Do you, or do you not, think the asterisks are a slip, CTD?

I'm not ruling it out, but I would be somewhat surprised if they were. DGB may not be the most rational of players, but for her to basically breadcrumb her own scum buddies would be bizarre even by her standards.

I don't think it was intentional.

CrashTextDummie wrote:I'm not ruling it out, but I would be somewhat surprised if they were. DGB may not be the most rational of players, but for her to basically breadcrumb her own scum buddies would be bizarre even by her standards.

But to make a set of notes, mark her scumbuddies, then forget to remove them before publishing seems a more rational idea than 'she was scum, and asterisked one buddy, and one townie for no reason whatsoever.'

Seems cut and dried to me.

Nightfall wrote:...What can I say?

This post really bothers me. It makes me almost want to vote nightfall. If he wasn't at L-1, I would vote him now.

He's clearly scum, realising DGB completely gave the game away, and has reasonably enough given up.

The Fonz wrote:But to make a set of notes, mark her scumbuddies, then forget to remove them before publishing seems a more rational idea than 'she was scum, and asterisked one buddy, and one townie for no reason whatsoever.'

Oh, I misremembered. I thought she explained the asterixes in the same post where she published the asterixed list, but that's not actually the case.

A slip does seem more likely. I'll at least give the game another read before hammering. Paranoia is nagging at me.

This isn't going anywhere... I'm satisfied with Nightfall being lynched. Someone who isn't satisfied, make some moves to get more information!

I think everyone except for nightfall has expressed support for the nightfall lynch. Assuming the mod isn't crazy and didn't give the scum four members, we have a mislynch, and nightfall's only post today is really scummy as hell; although I found him town for most of the game, hes been getting scummier lately, so I'm willing to do this:

Not voting (2): CrashTextDummie, Nightfall

With players alive, it takes votes to lynch.