Newbie 1433 - Game Over

[TheFuzzylogic99]

@ Satan- well two three possibilities

1) One is he read 2Pac as possible the cop and sat on him all game- which means he is diffenitely scum
2) He sat on 2pac not realizing he was the cop - this means that he is possible scum


I dont think scum would sit on a cop all day and than he flip town cop. This would make him too suspicious . So the question is wheather Nom sitting on the cop is a happy accident. my gut feeling is that was thus I am reading him as most likely a townie.Also the fact he seems to be trying to contribute more. He just feel like he prob town.

According to my POE I have Regs and Skelda as scum. I might be wrong about Skelda( i doubt it) but I am very confident in my Regs read.

Also ran has hit 3 days as well. i think he might have to be replaced as well/... we shall see

[TheFuzzylogic99]

@ Satan- well two possibilities

1) One is he read 2Pac as possible the cop and sat on him all game- which means he is diffenitely scum
2) He sat on 2pac not realizing he was the cop - this means that he is possible scum


I dont think scum would sit on a cop all day and than have his kill flip town cop. This would make him too suspicious . So the question is wheather Nom sitting on the cop is a happy accident or not. . my gut feeling is that it was thus I am reading him as most likely a townie.Also the fact he seems to be trying to contribute more. He just feel like he is prob town.
I repect Ree reads but rereading a few his 12 reason to lynch Nom , they seem a bit bloated and self righteous . Despite that I reading Ree as town as well

According to my POE I have Regs and Skelda as scum. I might be wrong about Skelda( i doubt it) but I am very confident in my Regs read.

Also ran has hit 3 days as well. i think he might have to be replaced as well/... we shall see

[SatanHellYeah]

You keep double posting.

But that's nice. Thanks. Let's see if Ran can make it.

[Nominull]

One nice thing about a 48-hour prod deadline for newbie games is you can start replacing newbies sooner when they inevitably flake.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

sorry about the 2x posts...... im having an off day today. Im not very focused today. Trying to get my head in the game but personal life kept slipping in.

Supposing Ran goes MIA , will we wait for his replacement also before we lynch.....If so how long before both will be replaced. Just worried we will be left to make a last minute lynch like we did day 1. Wondering if we will have time to make good and carefully thought out cases so we can we make a good lynch. Maybe Im making a bad assumption but it seem like last minutes lynches are bad for town since they will likely be panic lynches.

[Skelda]

I'm here! Anyway, I'm at L-1 which I totally saw coming. I'm a Vanilla Townie, yuppers. I wish I had something better but I don't.

So, my town reads are Reg/replacement, Nom, and Satan. Ree is null. Fuzzy and Ran are scum. Fuzzy's recent post about recognizing 2Pac as Cop is ridiculous, none of us had any idea about 2Pac's role, and there is no way any of us could have predicted his flip.

Nom, would you prefer Fuzzy or Ran? I'm hoping we can sway Reg's replacement and maybe Satan. Or we can just settle for my death, as long as you lynch Fuzzy or Ran tomorrow.

[Nominull]

I'm interested to hear what Ranawey or his replacement has to say before choosing between him and Fuzzy and Mr. Ree.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Skelda- I find it funny that you are totally denying( and totally dismissing ) that it is possible to guess 2Pac was the cop. Yes its usually not a likely event but it still possible especially if the players acts in a certain manners. Also in smaller games where there are less choices.

if Reg is town please explain why
1) contradicting himself at the end of day 1 in order to get a lynch is townie move
2) why a townie would through fits., insult people and try to manipulate people in order to vote his way is townie.
3) Why he disappeared after 2pac flipped cop.
4) He came in at the last moment , broke two wagon and forced a force lynch on 2Pac at the very end of day 1

Do you really believe a townie would do these things.

[SafetyDance]

Ranawey has been prodded, still searching for a replacement for Regfan

[Nominull]

Skelda- I find it funny that you are totally denying( and totally dismissing ) that it is possible to guess 2Pac was the cop. Yes its usually not a likely event but it still possible especially if the players acts in a certain manners. Also in smaller games where there are less choices.

if Reg is town please explain why
1) contradicting himself at the end of day 1 in order to get a lynch is townie move
2) why a townie would through fits., insult people and try to manipulate people in order to vote his way is townie.
3) Why he disappeared after 2pac flipped cop.
4) He came in at the last moment , broke two wagon and forced a force lynch on 2Pac at the very end of day 1

Do you really believe a townie would do these things.

A townie is more likely to disappear after pushing a lynch on the cop than scum is. If he were scum, he would have known he was pushing a townie, at least, he would have been prepared to defend himself today. On the other hand, a townie would be faced with the painful revelation that he had substantially trashed our chances.

[SatanHellYeah]

Him disappearing does not prove a single thing. He could perfectly be scum knowing he is going to be lynched. Same if townie. Anyway, he is a coward.

[Skelda]

Skelda- I find it funny that you are totally denying( and totally dismissing ) that it is possible to guess 2Pac was the cop. Yes its usually not a likely event but it still possible especially if the players acts in a certain manners. Also in smaller games where there are less choices.

if Reg is town please explain why
1) contradicting himself at the end of day 1 in order to get a lynch is townie move
2) why a townie would through fits., insult people and try to manipulate people in order to vote his way is townie.
3) Why he disappeared after 2pac flipped cop.
4) He came in at the last moment , broke two wagon and forced a force lynch on 2Pac at the very end of day 1

Do you really believe a townie would do these things.

Playstyle? Cowardice?

I can't answer for Reg, unfortunately, but I do not think it is a viable possibility that anyone could have guessed that 2Pac was a Cop. That just isn't the sort of thing we could have figured out.

[Skelda]

Skelda- I find it funny that you are totally denying( and totally dismissing ) that it is possible to guess 2Pac was the cop. Yes its usually not a likely event but it still possible especially if the players acts in a certain manners. Also in smaller games where there are less choices.

if Reg is town please explain why
1) contradicting himself at the end of day 1 in order to get a lynch is townie move
2) why a townie would through fits., insult people and try to manipulate people in order to vote his way is townie.
3) Why he disappeared after 2pac flipped cop.
4) He came in at the last moment , broke two wagon and forced a force lynch on 2Pac at the very end of day 1

Do you really believe a townie would do these things.

Playstyle? Cowardice?

I can't answer for Reg, unfortunately, but I do not think it is a viable possibility that anyone could have guessed that 2Pac was a Cop. That just isn't the sort of thing we could have figured out.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

MY point being that he did a bunch of scummy things that makes him suspect to me and should at least make people take a look and see if he is scum. Disappearing is just one in the list.....where on its own it might be null or maybe even townie put together with other behaviors it adds to his scumminess. The fact is that I could take away him disappearing and he would still look scummy.I still have not seen anyone make a case for regs being a townie/

Skelda keeps saying Im scum but I have done just an opposite scum would do..I had several good chance to lynch or help lynch someone on day 1 but did not bc I saw them as possible townies and did not want to mislynch them . Same thing with Skelda. I could of slam the hammer on him a while back. Yes I might been lynched on day 3 but I would most likely set up my team to win. I waiting to see what Regs replacement has to say as well as the possible Ran replacement( if he does not show). I have done everything I could to help the townies. So I Skelda is scum trying to lynch me bc he knows I have him nailed or he's a townie who has bad reads. I like to think its the latter rather than the latter but I feel he is most likely scum.

[Skelda]

Fuzzy, I think you are doing the opposite of what scum would do (i.e. not hammering me) so that when I flip town, you will have some defense and be able to get Nom or Reg dead and win.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Right, I going to avoid lynching you and 1) take the chance that you wont get lynch 2) take the chance that I or my scum partner would get lynch. Your rationale for my being scum seem seems flimsy at best. Seems like you are grasping at straws.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Plus theres the fact i was ready to slam the hammer on you till I think it was Nom suggested we should wait.....so your case pretty much has fallen apart.

[SafetyDance]

Peabody replaces Regfan. Welcome him!

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Hey Peabody ..welcome

[Skelda]

Plus theres the fact i was ready to slam the hammer on you till I think it was Nom suggested we should wait.....so your case pretty much has fallen apart.

Look, if you hammered, you'd seem scummy, especially after my flip. That is why you didn't lynch me. You care about your image so you can send Nom or Pea packing tomorrow and end the game.

[Peabody]

Hey everyone,

I'm your new friendly neighborhood SE replacement. I will be staying with you until the end of the game.

Thanks for the welcome.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

@ Skelda - right bc everyone who hammer is automatically scummy. Even if they are genuine and are acting in the best interest of the town. if that was the case the person who always hammer would get lynched the next day. Supposing you are right and I am scum.....how do you know I wont make a plausible reason for the lynch and get away with it. In other words it is it is not really a gamble to lynch you if i was scum. You rationale does not make sense.

Also how do you know I wont hammer you after all. Your assumption is that I am scum and wont hammering you bc it will make me look scummy. Its possible that I will lynch you anyways . But according to you I am scummy if I lynch you but scummy if I dont lynch you. So no matter what I do i am scummy. Sorry but your theory is not good and is full of holes and contradictions.

[Mr_Ree]

Hey Peabody. Welcome to the game

While you catch up, please list your reads along with the page number you have read up to. If you do that every 10ish pages, we should be able to follow your reads and compare them to what was happening at that time.

Cheers,
Ree

[Mr_Ree]

Hey Peabody. Welcome to the game

While you catch up, please list your reads along with the page number you have read up to. If you do that every 10ish pages, we should be able to follow your reads and compare them to what was happening at that time.

Cheers,
Ree

[Nominull]

Mr. Ree, what do you think about Fuzzy's recent posts?