Mafiascum.net

↑ Xtoxm wrote:did you somehow interpret that comment to mean i'm townreading you?

What?
Stop inferring shit.

↑ Xtoxm wrote:if you're town and you don't want to play: replace out.

otherwise i'll assume you're doing nothing because you're scum

I am playing.
Stop asking me to replace out, you are pissing me off.

↑ Firebringer wrote:I read like 1-5 then was like "this is boring" stopped

this does not constitute playing the game

↑ Xtoxm wrote:

↑ Firebringer wrote:I read like 1-5 then was like "this is boring" stopped

this does not constitute playing the game

I am actually reading whole thread right now.
Its a shit storm the whole lot of it.

And since this game is about posting and finding reads, the fact that I am posting and engaging with ANYONE means. That I am playing the game.

You have to redefine "not playing" to constitute my actions to fit your stupid definition.

↑ Xtoxm wrote:

↑ Firebringer wrote:I am sorry about being lazy this game, is there anyone specifically you guys want me to look at and ISO and give an analysis off of?

Yes, everyone.

I need to see this analysis before i'd consider unvoting

2 things:
I am not providing an analysis of everyone.

I will give you my thoughts. On everyone.
That means it could be simply "This guy is scum. End of story" or "This person is town for X, Y, Z"

I read up to Day 2.

Thoughts:
Sound of Silence is scummy. Not aligned with Knuckles, their interactions seemed very unaligned.
I think Knuckles could be scum though if SoS is not.
Randommidget I have no opinion on. Someone says they could be scum, I could see it. But honestly think SoS has higher chance of flipping scum.
Starbucks also looks bad based on voting behavior and just posts from Day 1. one of the posts struck me as espcially scummy, the one where asked if it was okay to do something without looking opportunistic.

Anyways, everyone else is town.

Except Aj. That guy is null to me.
But Town Leaning.

Starbuck's role sounds very likely town. Do you agree?

We think Dong targeted Knuckles last night, meaning he was the NK and therefore town.

Would this info have an effect on your top 3 scum?

↑ Xtoxm wrote:Starbuck's role sounds very likely town. Do you agree?

We think Dong targeted Knuckles last night, meaning he was the NK and therefore town.

Would this info have an effect on your top 3 scum?

I am not willing to strike out anyone as scum or town based on role due to the what I know so far of this game.

It seems quasi bastard complete role madness. I wouldn't put any stock into the roles.

It would only change my slight doubt of SoS to be more affirmed if this is true about Knuckles.

you're still voting Dav - Why? You just called him town with 'everyone else is town' comment.

Sounds like SOS is your top scum read?

VOTE: Sound of Silence
There put my money where my mouth is.

Not like anyone will follow me though.

I could go for that, tbh. Is there anyone in this game that's not scumreading SOS rn?

i have to admit your latest series of posts feels more town than scum

↑ Xtoxm wrote:We think Dong targeted Knuckles last night, meaning he was the NK and therefore town.

Unless they just targeted Dong, then it doesn't matter who he visited.

I'm not town reading SoS, if that helps.

UNVOTE: Dav
VOTE: SoS

one thing that's been kinda bothering me is how broken random midgets claim sounds and im not sure taking it at face value is such a smart idea - like he's basically scum by play

i still think fire's scum but i dunno, spitting out content directly before death is making me rethink a bit

starbucks role does make a bit more sense as town i guess

like i said i could compromise on SOS

VOTE: SOS

let's do this

↑ Vedith wrote:

↑ Xtoxm wrote:We think Dong targeted Knuckles last night, meaning he was the NK and therefore town.

Unless they just targeted Dong, then it doesn't matter who he visited.

doesn't seem like a high priority kill, though

whereas knuckles kinda was

↑ Vedith wrote:

↑ Xtoxm wrote:We think Dong targeted Knuckles last night, meaning he was the NK and therefore town.

Unless they just targeted Dong, then it doesn't matter who he visited.

this is possible yes.

↑ grapes wrote:

↑ Vedith wrote:

↑ Xtoxm wrote:We think Dong targeted Knuckles last night, meaning he was the NK and therefore town.

Unless they just targeted Dong, then it doesn't matter who he visited.

doesn't seem like a high priority kill, though

whereas knuckles kinda was

yeah i feel this way too. he was a town RB though and i hate those as scum so it's possible they wanted rid.

VOTE: SoS

honk honk

↑ grapes wrote:whereas knuckles kinda was

Knuckles killed a town, not scum.
Dong could prevent them killing an important town.

Knuckles could be scum - So in that sense, why would killing Knuckles be more important?

What's Grapes role again?
What's everyone's view on him?

I'm fine with SoS too, although I'd rather vig them - if SoS is scum, then Fire is probably town for double voting them since scum... wouldn't do that to a partner with little pressure on them, and my other notable scumread is randomidget and there's no way in hell I'm vigging a claimed reflector. I'd like to prove my vigness, and I'm really unconfident in my ability to scumhunt.

VOTE: Sound of Silence Not sure how far this is away from lynch though.

If knuckles is a scum dayvig then fuck this game, is basically my thought on the matter.

That's L1