Mafiascum.net

In post 799, DixC wrote:who else you got?

Ranger

In post 798, MURDERCAT wrote:Calling it now for post game gloating:

{DixC, Penguin, Shotty}

I too think Shotty's scum.
Conflicted on Podoboq. Because of his lame claim and the whole Smith/Podoboq situation. (In case of one town, one scum there, there would have been a lynch by now.)

I'm not sure whether we're doing the right thing but a NoLynch would definitely be worse.

This is it, I'm finally going to get night killed night 1 for having sick reads.

In post 801, Aneninen wrote:

In post 798, MURDERCAT wrote:Calling it now for post game gloating:

{DixC, Penguin, Shotty}

I too think Shotty's scum.
Conflicted on Podoboq. Because of his lame claim and the whole Smith/Podoboq situation. (In case of one town, one scum there, there would have been a lynch by now.)

I'm not sure whether we're doing the right thing but a NoLynch would definitely be worse.

MC and Anen: If you think Shotty is scum, how come you wouldn't vote him with me, but jumped on the Penguin wagon right away?

I still think Murdercat's town.
Even if I look like an idiot but I hope there will be a couple of players reading this game in the right way...................................

I have voted Shotty today

In post 803, Chip Butty wrote:MC and Anen: If you think Shotty is scum, how come you wouldn't vote him with me, but jumped on the Penguin wagon right away?

I was reading the game on mobile and I saw the Penguin wagon moving.
Would there be time for Shotty?

i think shotty's a ml over pp

No penguin > Shotty by far IMO

That was at Anen, I agree with Transcend.

I don't think the Shotty case is all that super-strong, but I have been voting him for a long time and no-one joined me (and stayed). Then as soon as the Penguin wagon started it moved really fast. It just strikes me as a little odd. @Anen: The Penguin wagon started from nothing and moved really fast, so I guess it could happen with Shotty too. BUT, it's well less than 24 hours now, and there's nothing in Penguin's ISO that screams Town, so we might as well continue with it, I guess.

I think the main reason Penguin is happening is that it's close to deadline and podo pointed out how many people don't like penguin.

In post 767, Chip Butty wrote:

In post 762, Smithereens wrote: Oi, you're not reading. Podo asked me to pretend for a moment that my reads were irrelevant, and while I don't believe that to be the case, for that conversation I told him 'let's pretend my reads don't mean anything.'

Of course I don't subscribe to this position. You could read that clearly from the posts. So why did you create this? ^^

No, I AM reading. You say you are dropping the assumption your reads are accurate, but then - based on the input of podo, Maru, Trans - you read them as scummy, IN THE VERY SAME POST. That is what is confusing me.

I said that for the sake of argument I'll assume my reads have nothing to do with it. In that case all of Podo Maru and Trans have dropped objective scum tells. It's really not hard to see.

In post 768, Chip Butty wrote:How can you say those three have dug themselves into a pit, unless it is on the basis of you reading them? Which means you have not dropped the assumption your reads are correct, at all.

They have dug themselves into pits meaning they have performed actions that condemn them, irrespective of my reads.

Jesus. I get back from the lake and things have done a complete 180. I'm with family tonight so I can't spend a lot of time fighting against this. Suffice to say, I am town and I apologize that my newbieness at a non-blitz game, and my first on this site, hurt you. I don't have strong reads on anyone except podo as scum, but I don't like Transcend or Murdercat. Feel better about Ranger. Still iffy on Smithereens. Like Anen and Karnos. Iffy on DixC. I'll try to check in over the next hour to see how things go, but then I'm off for the night.

Ok

I retract my intent to hammer

claim please

In post 816, MURDERCAT wrote:claim please

What difference does his claim make?

Why not get as much information as possible? What he says is useful even if he is scum.

In post 816, MURDERCAT wrote:claim please

Not for you. Nothing for you or podo.

In post 819, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 816, MURDERCAT wrote:claim please

Not for you. Nothing for you or podo.

What does it matter who asks? Everyone will read what you say, regardless...

Chip, ask for a claim please.

In post 820, Chip Butty wrote:

In post 819, PenguinPower wrote:

In post 816, MURDERCAT wrote:claim please

Not for you. Nothing for you or podo.

What does it matter who asks? Everyone will read what you say, regardless...

Fully understand that, but we're 12 hours out from a lynch and twice switched wagons with no other strong wagon in sight. I don't want a no lynch, and honestly, having me in the game is worse for the town if they are going to a scumread my newbieness. So, I'm resigned to being lynched and feel like being a little juvenile on my way out. Let me have it.

(didn't post yesterday because of it), , depending on how long it takes to recover.

Sorry.