Also i am kinda interested in what Ankamius thinks of lufan's claim.
~Sakura
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:03 am
by Taly
Just when I said I was going to catch-up and pump more reads...
This thread explodes. The second thread that has exploded today. Why. Priorities... where are you?
Also, in skimming the thread, I can already see a few Lufan slips... About his knowledge, being a noobie, and overall him sacrificing himself for a lynch... Which I'm not entirely understanding. If anything, I think a lufan PL soon my be beneficial for all of our darkness levels... And if
Lufans
PR is remotely truthful, then it may be likely a scum role.
Lufan
, can you at least explain your scum read on
ZZZX
?
By The Wrath of Taly: lufan131
P-Edit
...This may not have enough conviction since Pvotes are becoming extinct for this day.
By the Wrath of Seiko:
VOTE: lufan131
As for the reads part:
Shadowcat an ZZZX:
Have not looked at her/him that much, but I haven't found anything to raise alarms, their responses seem normal for a town perspective.
Slight Town Lean
Zymf:
Liked his breakdown in 608, hasn't said anything that seemed unreasonable for today. Even with the possible crumb.
Slight Town Read
Thor/Loki:
I've been a bit uncertain of him, I find his posts to be a bit genuine. Just in skimming, and how he has accessed things that have happened.
Slight Town Lean
Skold:
What are your opinions of Lufan? Who are your suspects?
I'll have some better formulated reads come D2, a lot is going around right now.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:06 am
by lufan131
... Because he was inactive, and I wanted someone else to direct attention to, since we were both lurkers, but I was the chosen one.
And aliens don't wear hats.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:07 am
by White Narcissus
↑Taly wrote:Also, in skimming the thread, I can already see a few Lufan slips... About his knowledge, being a noobie, and overall him sacrificing himself for a lynch... Which I'm not entirely understanding. If anything, I think a lufan PL soon my be beneficial for all of our darkness levels... And if Lufans PR is remotely truthful, then it may be likely a scum role.
What, i'm trying to understand what you're going with here, but i don't understand. Also what do you mean with the last part?
~Sakura
↑Taly wrote:Also, in skimming the thread, I can already see a few Lufan slips... About his knowledge, being a noobie, and overall him sacrificing himself for a lynch... Which I'm not entirely understanding. If anything, I think a lufan PL soon my be beneficial for all of our darkness levels... And if Lufans PR is remotely truthful, then it may be likely a scum role.
What, i'm trying to understand what you're going with here, but i don't understand. Also what do you mean with the last part?
~Sakura
Basically:
>
I skimmed the thread and found Lufan slipping: Mostly about the idea of him being a noob and his overall knowledge, and also with him sacrificing himself for a lynch. Via, voting himself.
>
I said I didn't understand his motives, and with his PR claim not really sounding convincing...
>
I concluded that a Lufan lynch would be beneficial soon for the town, whether it is off people thinking he is scum, or whether he is worthy of being lynched on Policy terms. Either seems applicable depending on how you see the situation.
>
I also said that his PR claim, seemed to more likely be scum to me. It just didn't sound very realistic for town to be able to lower their darkness if they decided to lynch their own alignment person.
In all
, Lufan is a worthy candidate, and we are nearing the announced deadline as we put. This paragraph was just to sum up my thoughts on Lufan, in dignifying a vote onto him. I'm not fond of voting without disclosed reasoning, it just gives too much room for town to confuse motives, and hurts them in return.
↑Taly wrote:>I also said that his PR claim, seemed to more likely be scum to me. It just didn't sound very realistic for town to be able to lower their darkness if they decided to lynch their own alignment person.
Huh, he never stated votes on him would lower people's darkening, he stated that targeting him would, i assumed that'd be night actions
~Sakura
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:22 am
by White Narcissus
tbh i also got cold feet, but not due to anything lufan has posted. Due to 803 - it seems like Zelink knows lufan is flipping town and is setting up a discredit on me so that people dont listen to me and lynch him (I'm one of the very few people who think he is scum)
Regardless, with all those votes on lufan it would be stupid to lynch anyone else now because of the darkening mechanic, so it's him we're lynching.
Just don't fucking let zelink live tomorrow, especially if lufan is town.
↑Taly wrote:>I also said that his PR claim, seemed to more likely be scum to me. It just didn't sound very realistic for town to be able to lower their darkness if they decided to lynch their own alignment person.
Huh, he never stated votes on him would lower people's darkening, he stated that targeting him would, i assumed that'd be night actions
~Sakura
Hidden in one of my earlier nonsense posts mentioned targeting with only night actions. No-one read it, though.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:30 am
by pieguyn
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:32 am
by Ankamius
↑White Narcissus wrote:Also i am kinda interested in what Ankamius thinks of lufan's claim.
~Sakura
I think it's non-indicative. It can easily be a scum ability that is there to 'look' town or a scum fakeclaim that can be imitated by what they have.
So ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:32 am
by Ankamius
Consider this intent to hammer as well barring last minute thoughts.
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:34 am
by lufan131
Nooo... How'd I get so voted by following instructions? lol....
↑White Narcissus wrote:Also i am kinda interested in what Ankamius thinks of lufan's claim.
~Sakura
I think it's non-indicative. It can easily be a scum ability that is there to 'look' town or a scum fakeclaim that can be imitated by what they have.
So ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
Do you remember sephibro's role in Higurashi.
~Sakura
I do. How is it relevant, exactly?
Posted: Tue Mar 31, 2015 11:39 am
by White Narcissus
↑Ankamius wrote:I do. How is it relevant, exactly?
Eh i've been comparing Higurashi roles with here since it has a similar mechanic, since his role was similar to lufan's (or at least his passive), I was wondering if you thought it'd be possible for him to have that kind of role here
~Sakura
