Newbie 1924 - Game Over

[ClearlyClarity]

Actually...

Hypothetically, would scum!Nav claim to be RB'd to sow confusion about the setup? Would B2 or C2 be potential options?

[ClearlyClarity]

Now I don't know what to think.

[TTTT]

why are you ignoring that three players all think you are scum with Nav?
who's Nav's partner?

[Datisi]

@MJL, I'm fairly certain I get the roles chart. I understand my and Nav's claims are incompatible, but I'm not actually voting him rn because I don't want him to self-hammer early

[Datisi]

One thing strikes me as suspicious here.

Addendum to previous post: Column A isn't guaranteed, if I'm reading this right, but it's the highest possibility rn.

Here, Clarity says that Column A is probable, but it's not yet certain. Alright.

Actually, I feel like the game's solved now.

- Datisi's 95% town because of this.
- Based on the above, Nav is scum.
- Nav's falseclaim implies Column A, and Datisi's CC implies Row 2. That means there's a doc.
- One of me, TTTT, or MJL is doc. The other two would be VT and scum.

Yeah, I got it.

Here, she goes in with the assumption that Column A is definitely what we're playing. Town!Clarity wouldn't know that, but Scum!Clarity would.

Actually...

Hypothetically, would scum!Nav claim to be RB'd to sow confusion about the setup? Would B2 or C2 be potential options?

Then she goes on to "correct" herself.

Also, can you please give your reads? Who do you think is second scum?

[TTTT]

I think I'm ready
but I'll give it a couple hours before voting in case anybody else has anything to say

[TTTT]

this is Nav/Clarity 99/100 times
don't hesitate to lynch Clarity day4 if I'm dead

[Datisi]

I've got nothing else to add. Ready when yall are

[MaryJoLisa]

We'll be sure to vote Clarity.

[TTTT]

you are scaring me with that "we" MJL

[TTTT]

MJL-Datisi makes sense if MJL is RBer
Datisi would have to jump in and CC Nav
but Nav coming out claiming cop with a guilty is so obvscum as he was the lynch today anyway

[TTTT]

@Datisi
why'd you JK me last night?

[MaryJoLisa]

I'm pretty sure Datisi and I are on the same page here. If she's telling the truth, she knows Naveet is lying. If you're NKed, that can only leave Clarity.

So "we" is appropriate.

[MaryJoLisa]

MJL-Datisi makes sense if MJL is RBer
Datisi would have to jump in and CC Nav
but Nav coming out claiming cop with a guilty is so obvscum as he was the lynch today anyway

Datisi cannot put our vote anywhere else other than Naveet.

[MaryJoLisa]

Wait. TTTT help me understand this.

If Datisi is the jailkeeper, the safest move is to jail Clarity tonight, right?

[TTTT]

I'm voting Nav if he doesn't get in here and start pushing a Datisi lynch
countdown:

(expired on 2019-04-19 18:00:00)

[TTTT]

Wait. TTTT help me understand this.

If Datisi is the jailkeeper, the safest move is to jail Clarity tonight, right?

that works unless there is a RBer alive

[MaryJoLisa]

TTTT did you claim a role yet?

[Datisi]

I suspected you were Town, but I wasn't 100%, so this was my thought process:
If TTTT is Town, there's a chance he'll get attacked. Jailing him stops that.
If TTTT is scum, he's less on the radar than his partner, whoever that might be, so it's more likely he'll be the one doing the kill.
And if there is a NK after all, the chance of TTTT being scum goes down by a lot.

[Datisi]

Yes, I eas planning on jailing Clarity, but if a RBer is present, not much use of that.

[Datisi]

I'll still do it obv

[TTTT]

TTTT did you claim a role yet?

nope
I've implied I'm VT
but it's better to leave that open for interpretation
and if you are PR you shouldn't change your claim from VT

[TTTT]

I suspected you were Town, but I wasn't 100%, so this was my thought process:
If TTTT is Town, there's a chance he'll get attacked. Jailing him stops that.
If TTTT is scum, he's less on the radar than his partner, whoever that might be, so it's more likely he'll be the one doing the kill.
And if there is a NK after all, the chance of TTTT being scum goes down by a lot.

that makes sense

[TTTT]

if MJL and Datisi are scum you've played a hell of a game

[Datisi]

I'm voting Nav if he doesn't get in here and start pushing a Datisi lynch
countdown:

(expired on 2019-04-19 18:00:00)

Also I'll hammer this