o, fuck, while this wagon was forming on me I wuz working on this post
I challenge any of you to find a single fucking reason for finding me scummy. I think TAM is the way to go here.
ArcAngel
- I don't buy the derpynewb act-- she has tons of games under her belt, even though she's new to the forum. I see more of her scum meta playing out here with the derpiness than her town play which was derpy but showed better issue selection.
Bitmap
- im likening to 1-shot bp jester. goes in yesterday with Miller claim to…no…i take that back. bitmap is all sorts of trouble. If he is a jester he would never have claimed, he would have stayed strong on miller to get lynched (though that would have risked his being vigged i guess, idk) I'll get back to him I'm more interested in lesser discussed players. Aren't Jesters in Open games sometimes? I never considered them bastard before. UPDATE after catching up i agree with matt on this one. We can't vote a claimed 3-rd party who is self-voting. R there any jester-esq roles where the player wins only if they are shot?
chkflip
-
#309 is weird. As Matt pointed out before, this
heavily
implies he knows that L-1 is gonna cause the lynch. I think town but that one post is bugging me. I assume neighborizer does not generally imply alignment right?
elmo
- dont know elmo's scum-meta, but this looks like the Town-elmo i've played with before.
GNR
- could definitely use more activity from GNR. Leaning town based on similarities I see between his play here and in some of his recent town games.
JacobSavage
- I just caught up this is all very confusing. Let me see if i got things straight. You were at first going to be given ur own special role, then ppl complained, Monkey gave u the same role as SA, and then I'm confused about why you would claim in #823 unless that is now no longer going to be ur role….or wait ok. So that was your JacobSavage role but then you were changed back to SAs role. Is that correct?
lurker
- gotta fucking be kidding me with that activity. Conftown b/c of the Maestro claim.
maenara
-
#563 is very bad. one of her big things she keeps bringing up is "we already know trollie is scum" but then she goes back in this post to say that she doesn't really know why, but because I'm confirmed scum so she knows she will find something. She is riding on the wave of trollie-scum, trying to gain towncred by agreeing with a scum read. I also really dislike her assumptions on the chk stuff but i think thats due to derpyness not to alignment.
UPDATE: checked some of Mae's meta. in
this game she is a VT. Her play is similar to her play here in that her posts are pretty fluffy and unfocused. However, a notable difference between her play there and here is that she is much more aggressive and, at movements, very pointed in her posting.
Maestro
- Oracle claim = town
MattP
- pain-in-my-ass town. Honestly going into this game if i had to guess what his meta-role would be, Trollie-lyncher would be high up on the list of possibilities. That being said I don't think thats what his role actually is cause I believe the lightning rod claim, also maestro's result. So yeah He'z town as shit.
Nacho
- I don't see any glaring issues with nacho's play like others seem to. I wish this ongoing game was fucking not ongoing. I will sheep other people's reads of him if I can't get behind one of the other wagons.
Nero Cain
- I actually really like Nero Cain's play. His scumhunting is sorta the opposite style as matt's int hat NC follows up rather than setting up. I like the combination of the two.
Om
- yeah he's very town. I didn't love his early D1 play but since then he's become a strong town read. He's like a version of Venmar who at least seems to be thinking for himself and believes in his reads.
PeregrineV
- about 90% of his posts are clarification questions. Getting scum vibes from him for trying to keep up the impression of active scum hunting. PVs play reminds me a lot of another player's scum-play that i've seen recently.
rofl
- I don't think the post restriction is necessarily faked. I've seen just as limiting post restrictions in other large theme games (I'm thinking mainly 90s cartoon mafia). Hard to get any read on him because of the supposed post restriction. Might be able to by re-reading the thread but the ISO alone is uninformative. I would guess rofl is town just because of the nature of his restriction.
TAM
- All of his posts are about catching up/his activity or parroting general sentiment or role fishing. I don't know how i didn't see this earlier.
Toog
- conftown.
venmar
- you already know my opinion of him. I don't think he's generated a single unique/independent thought all game. I fucking hate it when I have strong reads like this that no one listens to. Sometimes I'm wrong about them, but sometimes I'm right….just sayin' Anyway I still think he's scum.
Voidedmafia
- I am tired from all this ISOing and it just so happens that the most annoying player to have to ISO is also the last lol. I'm not gonna read through all of it but I don't think I really have to because VM is a strong town read for me. This is especially clear reading his non-picture posts. His stance on his own role restriction and the way he is using his content posts/the content he is giving all read town.
UNVOTE: venmar
VOTE: TAM