Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[BROseidon]

Given the playerlist, scum are probably 2/3 in the group with fewer posts than me.

[borkjerfkin]

Votecount 1.16

[4] Jake From State Farm (HighShroomish, Hello Kitty Creampuff, Mac, Aegor)
[2] Hello Kitty Creampuff (PhDScar, Jake From State Farm)
[2] HighShroomish (Kdub, SMP)
[2] PhDScar (ActionDan, ???)
[1] Aj The Epic (Antihero)
[1] Antihero (Aj The Epic)
[1] Kdub (sangres)
[1] SMP (BROseidon)

With 13 alive, it is 7 to lynch.

Let me know if you see any problems.

Deadline is in (expired on 2014-04-25 23:00:00)

[sangres]

I think Aegor is the scum on Jake's wagon.

[Jake from State Farm]

Hkc is definitely scum on my wagon

[PhDScar]

VOTE: Aegor

[Aj The Epic]

Pardon me, I am slowly becomging drunk but jjake is so fucking sucm it isn't even funny anymore

This is garbage... Both jake and HKC need to stop posting towards each other, but Jake doesn't seem to be any bit more likely to be scum than HKC, although I'd take an HKC lynch due to that drunk post streak apparently being Mara... I expect better from mara tbh.

The other players I'd consider lynching are kdub, Aegor and AJ. Which is part of why I liked your catch-up. SMP is a maybe, which could firm up tonight, but I doubt it.

Had you mentioned any of these before the Anti replace-in?

That shouldn't be to hard to figure out on your own.

I'm pretty sure I've mentioned my concerns about Aegor. I think Nacho did too, but I'm not going to go back and check it. Aegor was pinging from quite early with his voting pattern. Nacho questioned kdub in his last visit to the thread. I don't think either of us have mentioned AJ, and Antihero did influence that read somewhat, mostly because his other comments have been very much in line with what I've thought about the game during those moments when I can hear myself think in here.

You mentioned me before Anti-hero posted, ignored my questioning of why you thought I wasn't town and answered jake's post, the post right after mine. So again, why do you think I might not be town? Anti-hero's posting certainly hasn't clarified anything at all.

[sangres]

You mentioned me before Anti-hero posted, ignored my questioning of why you thought I wasn't town and answered jake's post, the post right after mine. So again, why do you think I might not be town? Anti-hero's posting certainly hasn't clarified anything at all.

That post was made by Nacho, which is why I haven't answered it. We haven't talked about this game at all except for a quick text burst I initiated about Jake before I moved our vote last night. You've been null to me, and afaik null to Nacho prior to Antihero's replace-in.

[Antihero]

Anti-hero's posting certainly hasn't clarified anything at all.

haha, is that right?

here's the original PhD vote: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 6#p5815906
and a few iso posts later...
here's the bail: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 8#p5821468

first off, the "case" is complete bullshit. catboi never "reversed" his read on phd, he simply asked BRO the reason for his vote. also, the timing of catboi's vote was scummy... how...? we don't know, so i guess that's left up to the imagination.

second, there's no attempt to analyze phd or

his

response to the wagon AND/OR the wagon in its

entirety

(aegor, BRO, and actiondan). when it looks like phd's about to get lynched, aj makes sure to hurry up and peel off the wagon and waste no time in incriminating someone on the wagon

he

started.
^that's because he's scum. he's not worried about actually analyzing what happened with the phd wagon; he's only interested in thinking 3 moves ahead and who he's going to attack next

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Pardon me, I am slowly becomging drunk but jjake is so fucking sucm it isn't even funny anymore

This is garbage... Both jake and HKC need to stop posting towards each other, but Jake doesn't seem to be any bit more likely to be scum than HKC, although I'd take an HKC lynch due to that drunk post streak apparently being Mara... I expect better from mara

ok, is there any reason to why you keep making these kinds of posts, not following througj, and ignoring any and all interaction I try and have with you?

If you want me to stop tunneling, you need to at least try and get me to via interaction, and if you are scum reading me, even slightly, I expect you to firm it up in some way shape or form

[Antihero]

yes, it's because he's scum, mara

vote him

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

who do you have in mind?

and this is mara, bert hasn't touched booze I don't think

aj or kdub

Ehhh, i havnt really touched Kdub, though I guess I can see where you're coming from re him

with aj, I had a tentative town read on him because I can't really see him as scum with Jake, don't really remember why, but i really like jakescum more than anything else.

[Antihero]

you know things are fubar when you're giving scum a townread based on your tunnel

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Well, I guess it's more, I feel like someone between the Jake/aj is scum but not together and, if I am wrong on one of the reads, id much rather it be Jake because I don't know how ti work with town him while I have some idea as to how to work with aj

pedit: :/

[Antihero]

yeah, still awful.

tell me when you're ready to leave your tunnel of stupid emotion and start lynching scum

[Jake from State Farm]

I'm actually easy to work. Obviously if you call me scum for bs reasons I'm not but sangres doesn't agree with my reads yet I'm not fighting with him. He stays calm and interacts with me in a calm manner.

Use your words and actually explain your thinking using logic and I'm typically not going to argue with you. I may disagree with you but not argue.

Do you see me arguing with anyone else?

[sangres]

He claimed he had a PR and I thought he was scum, so I was hoping he would claim something that could be counter claimed.

OK, this statement shows an underlying lack of town motivation. First of all, there is such a thing as safeclaims. Second, and more importantly,

you wanted to potentially out more PRs by looking for a counterclaim

. Your thought process here is not pro-town.

Also, let's say nobody counterclaims. Then what? Do you believe Jake, or do you want to lynch him anyway?

When you're scumreading someone, how do you generally feel about their claims? How much more burden of proof do you want than from someone you're townreading who claims?

Factor in relative inexperience at the game. His play in the boardgame mini showed a similar depth of thought IMO.

Do you think scum-shroom would have such open, visible, clear thought process?

I don't. I think as scum someone with his number of games under his belt wouldn't be making such brash waves.

[sangres]

And I feel like you're going after low-hanging fruit here.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

#fucklogic

[sangres]

#fucklogic

maybe just stop reacting to every little thing he posts for a while and take a wider look at the game?

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

UNVOTE:

[Aegor]

VOTE: Anti

[Jake from State Farm]

Ok I'm ok with the idea of aegor being scum now. Anti has made good points and while I don't 100% town read him he's proving to be fairly towny. That vote was bad

[Antihero]

was wondering when scum would show up revving the chainsaw

[Antihero]

don't let it distract from lynching aj the scumbag, though.

he's scum. and very transparently scum at that. lynch him.

[Jake from State Farm]

AJ is null so I don't see myself joining that wagon.

Given the point you made earlier about shroom I'll let him slide for now but hk and smp are still my desired lynches