Greatest Idea VIII - Game Over

[TemporalLich]

found the scum

[davesaz]

@people who think I'm not saying anything.
We have two ears and one mouth for a reason.
My words are always few, and they're always important. (well, almost always -- I'm capable of joking once in a while)

Tbh I just wanted the Judas as a substitute Unlynchable to use in a dire circumstance. But this set up can be hugely townsided so I want to win as town.

Claiming it early does not jive with wanting it for a dire circumstance. I think this one is actually a lie and not just truth that looks like a lie. However I agree with being risk adverse, so lynching into it especially on day 1 is a bad move.

Scumread on Elsa.

I think I'll assume there are more of whatever Elsa flips, unless of course it's a different singleton alignment.

Reaction to Elsa's "surrender" which seems manufactured to make it seem like he's all alone in the world.

You're still scummy for discarding Cop though.

VOTE: TemporalLich

Obviously a scumread, I believe I started this trend.

I'm beginning to believe this case on Performer.

Performer is a scumread too. I think all this lack of understanding the setup is actually a disguised attempt to get as many people as possible to leak their roles. And I'm suspicious that he townreads me here with past history.

[TTTT]

I kinda just want to big Performer
for calling me a lurker when I stated VLA
and then came back exactly when I said I would

[TTTT]

*vig

[TemporalLich]

I kinda just want to big Performer
for calling me a lurker when I stated VLA
and then came back exactly when I said I would

agreed, 851 is very suspiciously timed

[davesaz]

Oh God don't make him bigger! He's inflated enough as it is!!!

(actually he hasn't been inflated this game but it's too good to pass up)

[TTTT]

Dayvig: Elsa

[TemporalLich]

EBWOP: ignore 854's reference

[Sakura Hana]

Why everytime i read one of Lich's posts it feels like he's in an alternate dimmension.

[Performer]

Performer is a scumread too. I think all this lack of understanding the setup is actually a disguised attempt to get as many people as possible to leak their roles. And I'm suspicious that he townreads me here with past history.

You've got to be kidding...considering you said past history, you're well aware I'm strongly against outing prs on d1 unnecessarily. I literally just said that in an earlier post that I'm not fond of 4 claims already, and you're saying I'm trying to get people to out roles, which isn't at all what I'm doing.

The part where you said I tr you with past history, that's extremely cryptic - elaborate.

[TemporalLich]

Why everytime i read one of Lich's posts it feels like he's in an alternate dimmension.

because it's true

[Performer]

I kinda just want to big Performer
for calling me a lurker when I stated VLA

v/la = inactive = lurker
I asked for your reads to see who else you thought was scum along with the obvious one (EJ). But people think that's "devoid of info" and "needing to be vigged."

I've got temp as an sr.

[Sakura Hana]

v/la = inactive = lurker

This is incorrect.
V/LA means that due to irl circumstances you cant be around.
Lurker means you're reading but not posting.

[Performer]

v/la = inactive = lurker

This is incorrect.
V/LA means that due to irl circumstances you cant be around.
Lurker means you're reading but not posting.

I understand it differently .

[TTTT]

challenge:
explain Temp!scum
without resorting to calling his play weird
like explain it from a motive POV

[Performer]

challenge:
explain Temp!scum
without resorting to calling his play weird
like explain it from a motive POV

-Called dave & my ISO devoid of info, which isn't true
-Had sak & I as his sr

[Elsa Jay]

Atleast I get to signup for other stuff now. Tnx TTT. Atleast my record for getting "lynched" day 1 is still 0. And no Almost, that 1 time with you in that 6p doesn't count since I not only lived but became an IC.

See y'all later.

[davesaz]

Performer is a scumread too. I think all this lack of understanding the setup is actually a disguised attempt to get as many people as possible to leak their roles. And I'm suspicious that he townreads me here with past history.

You've got to be kidding...considering you said past history, you're well aware I'm strongly against outing prs on d1 unnecessarily. I literally just said that in an earlier post that I'm not fond of 4 claims already, and you're saying I'm trying to get people to out roles, which isn't at all what I'm doing.

The part where you said I tr you with past history, that's extremely cryptic - elaborate.

Second part first, you almost universally scumread me early game. It seemed strange that you didn't in this one.

If you don't want to out PRs why post so many obviously wrong things about the setup? It's almost like you're trying to not get how this works.

[Performer]

@dave

very first greatest idea 8 so I'm asking as many questions as I can to understand things

Also I somewhat regret signing up, since this setup is so bastard.

Regarding scumreading you early on in other games, that's a good point. I didn't even think of that at all until you brought it up so I was mystified by what you even meant .
I just don't read you as scummy in this one - poe, providing info & analysis (like voting), interactions.

[Irrelephant11]

PoE? You have a PoE going here, Performer? Would love a quick summary

[Irrelephant11]

Why everytime i read one of Lich's posts it feels like he's in an alternate dimmension.

^

Same for Performer

[davesaz]

Fair enough on it being your first Greatest series game -- but it might be better to fully absorb and embrace the setup mechanics vs. a series of questions that could inadvertently out someone. The repetition is what's triggering myself (and apparently others).

[Performer]

PoE? You have a PoE going here, Performer? Would love a quick summary

I'm just doing it by comparison , like against who's been scummy and townie...it's nothing fancy.



-This is what i have in my pt:
Reads & Claims 1.02

tr dave/pint/ofr/shad/sakura/irrel/a50
sr temp/alch/xtox (feels off)

tt = dayvig
ej = fake claimer
irrel = cc judas claim of ej
shad = cc hero claim of ej
-------

@dave I didn't realize it was to that extent for this setup...thank you

[Irrelephant11]

Hmmm
I could see town!performer here
Not letting him off easy though because I did that our last time together and he was scum

[pinturicchio]

@micc please replace me.

I'm in the middle of probably accepting a new job and just cannot keep up, it's only going to get worse at the end of the week when I anticipate starting on my two weeks notice.

Good luck brass, I'm in the middle of searching too and it's stressing as fuck. Hopefully you'll have to stop looking after this one.