Mafiascum.net

hrrrm

if we're dismantling this we aren't remantling on bins i think

Although my towncase for Elsa is pretty weak.

But like I have never seen a player who has a playstyle same as her, plays like this, and flip scum.
Literally zero, and I played quite a lot of games by now.

In post 845, xRECKONERx wrote:

In post 836, Bins wrote:I don't know how anyone likes that claim. I get made when I'm lynched as town too, but I don't get that snappy after claiming doctor. Like gee.

two shot doctor is a very specific thing to claim and also don't know why baezu-scum would come back and put the modifier on it after the fact and also lines up with how i know UT likes to design games bc ive designed a shitload with him and x-shots are in like every game

idk seems like a big coincidental lucky swing for scum to make in the claim dept

chance of a mod designed fakeclaim tbh I don't townread the role itself nor is doctor exclusively town aligned

how do you feel about her actual play around the L-1?

tfw I just won a scumgame fakeclaiming 1s doc

In post 707, Baezu wrote:If I’m at L-1 then I’d like to claim

In post 708, Bins wrote:

In post 705, Baezu wrote:What am I at? L-1?

Yep.

I posted this at the exact same time. It was unrelated.

In post 845, xRECKONERx wrote:

In post 836, Bins wrote:I don't know how anyone likes that claim. I get made when I'm lynched as town too, but I don't get that snappy after claiming doctor. Like gee.

two shot doctor is a very specific thing to claim and also don't know why baezu-scum would come back and put the modifier on it after the fact and also lines up with how i know UT likes to design games bc ive designed a shitload with him and x-shots are in like every game

idk seems like a big coincidental lucky swing for scum to make in the claim dept

this is actually a pretty interesting post

In post 852, the worst wrote:

In post 845, xRECKONERx wrote:

In post 836, Bins wrote:I don't know how anyone likes that claim. I get made when I'm lynched as town too, but I don't get that snappy after claiming doctor. Like gee.

two shot doctor is a very specific thing to claim and also don't know why baezu-scum would come back and put the modifier on it after the fact and also lines up with how i know UT likes to design games bc ive designed a shitload with him and x-shots are in like every game

idk seems like a big coincidental lucky swing for scum to make in the claim dept

chance of a mod designed fakeclaim tbh I don't townread the role itself nor is doctor exclusively town aligned

how do you feel about her actual play around the L-1?

tfw I just won a scumgame fakeclaiming 1s doc

In post 3, Untrod Tripod wrote:

Q: Did any anti-town players get fake claims from the mod?
A: No.

can yall read the fuckin op

In post 848, xRECKONERx wrote:it's someone trying to push shitty and disprovable logic to justify shoving a lynch on a PR claim

so yes

I mean this could come as either alignment.
Town could do this with "Aha, gotcha scum" without remembering that flavor is not related to alignment.
Scum could do this with "Aha, easy mislynch" without remembering that flavor is not related to alignment.

In post 850, implosion wrote:hrrrm

if we're dismantling this we aren't remantling on bins i think

don't need a remantling - why do you think bins is out of the question?

In post 849, Bins wrote:How about I was just shocked at the reaction? I was sitting on the bus like BIG YIKES and felt like it didn't seem warranted at all. Not only did no one claim intent, but Baezu just suddenly went from "Hey pals" to "FUCKYOUFUCKYOUFUCKYOU." I don't know how I was supposed to lurk that out and not make comments. I feel like everything I said was pretty neutral and just stated my reactions. No big pushes.

I literally said "Yep" to an L-1 question. I never said claim, lol.

she'd just said she'd claim at L-1 but we're arguing semantics

The fact you were mobileposting and reading doesn't change the way I read your reaction to that -- can you talk me through what you were seeing in more detail?

In post 845, xRECKONERx wrote:

In post 836, Bins wrote:I don't know how anyone likes that claim. I get made when I'm lynched as town too, but I don't get that snappy after claiming doctor. Like gee.

two shot doctor is a very specific thing to claim and also don't know why baezu-scum would come back and put the modifier on it after the fact and also lines up with how i know UT likes to design games bc ive designed a shitload with him and x-shots are in like every game

idk seems like a big coincidental lucky swing for scum to make in the claim dept

1. Could be scum
2. I don't think adding X-shot makes it harder to fake

In post 855, xRECKONERx wrote:can yall read the fuckin op

OH right ok we're in business

ok I'm on board

oops i misspelled xreckonerx sorry about that

In post 855, xRECKONERx wrote:can yall read the fuckin op

RTFM is a remain of the past these days.

In post 510, implosion wrote:do you think you oughtn't be strongly townread?

oh fuck uh uh uh i take it back just keep townreading me

In post 512, GuyInFreezer wrote:I stopped pursuing because I decided that it was just reck being silly.

I guess??? this also seems like a weird thing to say

In post 515, xRECKONERx wrote:this is v town imo

zito is being good and rational and logical but i dont understand why people (you & the worst) are calling his posts town-- could you explain

In post 528, MariaR wrote:I’m not really worried about T-bone right now. He hasn’t made any waves but I’m pretty confident that I’ll be able to have a solid read on him the more he posts. The last time I played with him we basically had a hard tr on each other for the whole game and we were both town. What posts make you want to vote him?

i dont remember and i dont think its very important to me anymore
i just think he had a mediocre ISO or something shrug

In post 530, MariaR wrote:Has the worst scum game turned god tier while I was away? Because last time I played with scum him his scumgame was laughably bad.

i think he's alright : )

In post 583, Bins wrote:does this still hold EP how ya feelin

neither of them really hold weight to me but that is not to say that they've done something scummy, it's that none of their posts recently have stood out to me + there are a lot of people currently in this game and sometimes vague reads have to be emotionally discarded because i'm stupid and my brain can only hold three things at a time

so i guess i cant really say anything about either of them except zor sure is making it hard to read this game in public!
+
now that i'm reading implosion's point about zor, yeah i mean that kind of makes sense

oh-- also implosion is town i'm fairly sure ASDFJSDJF i'm going to end this catchup post here for readability's sake (continuing on page 27 in the next post)
okay pedit: what the fuck is going on rn?

In post 857, the worst wrote:don't need a remantling - why do you think bins is out of the question?

the way she's interacted with the thread all game, mostly

In post 794, the worst wrote:d1 wagoning Jay is about as productive as practising martial arts on a stobie pole

imo vote someone who will actually do something then powerlynch Jay if we're still confused at eod

In post 864, implosion wrote:

In post 857, the worst wrote:don't need a remantling - why do you think bins is out of the question?

the way she's interacted with the thread all game, mostly

I think you're town but that's kinda vague...

ernparbntablo wrote:okay pedit: what the fuck is going on rn?

refer to post 830 for a comprehensive summary

In post 866, the worst wrote:

In post 864, implosion wrote:

In post 857, the worst wrote:don't need a remantling - why do you think bins is out of the question?

the way she's interacted with the thread all game, mostly

I think you're town but that's kinda vague...

it is and i can be more specific but i think she's just obvtown lol

In post 867, implosion wrote:

ernparbntablo wrote:okay pedit: what the fuck is going on rn?

refer to post 830 for a comprehensive summary

ilu

I guess I should ISO Bins soon for my glorious one-line summary read.

In post 856, GuyInFreezer wrote:

In post 848, xRECKONERx wrote:it's someone trying to push shitty and disprovable logic to justify shoving a lynch on a PR claim

so yes

I mean this could come as either alignment.
Town could do this with "Aha, gotcha

bitc

scum" without remembering that flavor is not related to alignment.
Scum could do this with "Aha, easy mislynch" without remembering that flavor is not related to alignment.

hm.

this is entirely valid.

also real talk im really not confident about my abilities to find scum anymore and last game i played i fucked up the game by defending the shit out of scum and falling for bullshit so like part of my brain is screaming at me LOL U IDIOT UR DOIN IT AGAIN IT'S ACTUALLY BAEZU

but i REALLY think the two shot modifier is such an odd thing to claim after the fact
i suppose the point stands that doctor could be a scum role but ehhhh? that's still not super compelling to me as a reason to think it's scum

and actually after evaluating GiF's point i think i probably jumped the gun on elsa bc that forgetfulness could come from either alignment?? idk

back to zor i guess

VOTE: zoraster

In post 870, GuyInFreezer wrote:I guess I should ISO Bins soon for my glorious one-line summary read.

Implosion shook my faith in this righteous wagon I'll sheep you on her

like, little things all game like 148. You have to be a REALLY good scum player to be that consistent about that kind of stuff.

In post 863, Errantparabola wrote:zito is being good and rational and logical but i dont understand why people (you & the worst) are calling his posts town-- could you explain

idk it's tone

zito is coming at this in a similar way to how i am coming at this and it comes thru in his tone

i mean maybe it's easy to fake that "lol idk what's going on halp" tone but knowing zito's personality it seems to ring true for me and that's enough for DAY ONE until we have more to go on to build something more concrete