Gameshow Mafia (Reroll): Game Over

[Fuscosco]

You’ve also seen town me a few times now, I believe, so what makes you see that differently?

Looks advantage seeking, if you know what i mean. agenda based.

anyway if you are town kill scum with me.

This is suuuuper aggressive.

they have lots of talk but i dont see much substance but they speak of it in such a way that implies they have lots of substance behind it so i want to see what im missing

or maybe

they lie

Theyre different pushes. I felt like td was trying to pull out a reaction from nance, purposely pushing them into acting. I was disappointed when nance hard-pushed back; its such a stereotypical tunnel happening from not-much sustenance.

Chen's is kind of crap, td's is kind of towny in tone.

Chen Dann feels SvS, anybody else? That level of confidence from a player of Chenn's caliber is unwarranted, and feels wrong.

yes.

SvS might be possible. Id expect nothing to come of the push on nance in that case, since chen!scum would want the free tunnel and not to build a wagon.

oka's perspective

Im undecided on oka. I dont read oka's view as oppurtunistic. But diggy for info? sure. As scum I like to probe for a good foundation to build a legit-looking case on.

[NanceFloor]

the mbaki lynch list is terrible though

What's terrible about it? What names should be on the list that aren't?

Code: Select all

OkaPoka
Time Devil (TemporalLich + Baezu)
Shoshin
Confirmation Bias (??? + ???)
NanceFloor (Nancy Drew 39 + Dannflor)
Creature***
chennisden
Chemist1422
0verki11

We are lynching on this list today. No, not being here does not necessarily mean a town read. If you vote off this list I will be irritated.

Well, i feel like theres def some elitism and generally bad implications about this list i could infer. Like am I off this list because Im your likely choice for an 8ball?


This list is good. It gives us a good way to judge your future actions.

You shouldn’t be on anyone’s list because I think you’re pretty obvtown and we need to lynch who is scum and we can’t wifom scum. Last go round, scum!Momo tainted the well, this time we were fortunate that no one did and because of that, wifomming who is likely the 8 ball is pretty much pointless.

~ND

[Fuscosco]

Are you a Gryffindor?

what does this even mean?

cool

well the confbias wagon is unlikely to give us more to work with atm
the nancefloor wagon is not going to give anything useful because worst case, dann is sortable over the long term anyways

who else was being wagoned? I'll show why they're a bad idea and why mine is not in comparison too

Green in nature

[Fuscosco]

@mbaki

I thought Chennis was town; he was not on my original lynch list (separate statements). I just dislike his play/style. Honestly, I'm very disappointed at this playerlist, I was much happier with the first one. If I noticed how much it changed I probably would not have stayed in.

Do you have an Ank read?

[Fuscosco]

Spoiler: olayerlist from previous game

Subject: Gameshow Mafia (17/17)

Playerlist:

1. Shoshin
   
2. mbaki
   
3. OkaPoka
   
4. StarwingBeauvoi
   
5. Taly
   
6. momo
   
7. RadiantCowbells
   
8. Wisdom
   
9. JohnnyEnglish
   
10. Not Known 15
    
11. TemporalLich
    
12. rosterfoster
    
13. Creature
    
14. insomnia
    
15. Nancy Drew 39
    
16. JunkoChan
    
17. Baezu

Replacements:

1. Vedith

Looking for hydra partners:

1. Flavor Leaf
   
2. TemporalLich
   
3. 0verki11
   
4. Shadowlesscloud
   
5. StarwingBeauvoi
   
6. JunkoChan
   
7. GuyInFreezer

[Fuscosco]

lol wow thats a pretty solid list.

Look at how flavor is also in this list, btdubs.

[Fuscosco]

mbaki are you trying to get wagoned

Actually, my impression is that of concise play. Im tempted to write it off as town, but direct scum may be too?

Fusco, why you voting me gurl?

pressure vote to sort players. I think this nancefloor explosion is the most happening thing this game thus far.

I am town, and it is a waste to pursue me right now.

my my my
said the spider to the fly

Just letting you know, a town mislynch is strictly better than a no-lynch!

what?

VOTE: chen

We have 4 days. Please relax Chen.

Oka lynch is cool. I

think

Shadow is town, for some pretty garbage reasons.

I am not placing a vote. I will be voting by end of day, do not worry.

This post tells me they arent so uninterested in this game. they have notes and are playing.

[mbaki]

the mbaki lynch list is terrible though

What's terrible about it? What names should be on the list that aren't?

Code: Select all

OkaPoka
Time Devil (TemporalLich + Baezu)
Shoshin
Confirmation Bias (??? + ???)
NanceFloor (Nancy Drew 39 + Dannflor)
Creature***
chennisden
Chemist1422
0verki11

We are lynching on this list today. No, not being here does not necessarily mean a town read. If you vote off this list I will be irritated.

Well, i feel like theres def some elitism and generally bad implications about this list i could infer. Like am I off this list because Im your likely choice for an 8ball?


This list is good. It gives us a good way to judge your future actions.

No. You specifically are off the list because I think you're town. If we were basing it off my

opinion

of player quality, Creature definitely wouldn't be on that list, and you would probably be on it (no offense), among many other things.

[Fuscosco]

shadowless

I dont have a read on either shadow or overkill.

lll iso those two after i read up.

i have contacted multiple list mods and the game mods.

RC has shitposted this whole game, and i dont like it.

and yes, Im going to consider the whole spat w/flavor as part of a giant shitpost.

Ankle is town

i think so.
But why arent you posting at all?

Creature is not town?

gun to head, Id go here rn.

I'll tone back, I'm sorry

Dont be sorry. Its something I have to sort out myself. My playstyle can be . . . in need of improvement. Less shitpostting, less open with my TrainofThought, and more reserved. I come off, i feel, as immature and even juvenille. It grates me because people dont take it seriously until I bust open the game. Take flavor's talk about the recent musicals game. I had solved the better portion of the game but my style and an extended period of nonposting got me quicklynched by unsure town.

[mbaki]

@mbaki

I thought Chennis was town; he was not on my original lynch list (separate statements). I just dislike his play/style. Honestly, I'm very disappointed at this playerlist, I was much happier with the first one. If I noticed how much it changed I probably would not have stayed in.

Do you have an Ank read?

Yes.

[Fuscosco]

(no offense)

busting your stones, amoung other things.

[NanceFloor]

You’ve also seen town me a few times now, I believe, so what makes you see that differently?

Looks advantage seeking, if you know what i mean. agenda based.

anyway if you are town kill scum with me.

This is suuuuper aggressive.

they have lots of talk but i dont see much substance but they speak of it in such a way that implies they have lots of substance behind it so i want to see what im missing

or maybe

they lie

Theyre different pushes. I felt like td was trying to pull out a reaction from nance, purposely pushing them into acting. I was disappointed when nance hard-pushed back; its such a stereotypical tunnel happening from not-much sustenance.

Chen's is kind of crap, td's is kind of towny in tone.

Chen Dann feels SvS, anybody else? That level of confidence from a player of Chenn's caliber is unwarranted, and feels wrong.

yes.

SvS might be possible. Id expect nothing to come of the push on nance in that case, since chen!scum would want the free tunnel and not to build a wagon.

oka's perspective

Im undecided on oka. I dont read oka's view as oppurtunistic. But diggy for info? sure. As scum I like to probe for a good foundation to build a legit-looking case on.

How was TD trying to pull out reactions from us? All he keeps doing and continues to do, is call us caught scum/wolf on shampoo, rince, repeat. In what world do you read that as making any attempt at all to try to sincerely sort us. All I’ve seen from him other than that is ludicrous defensiveness. Agree about Chenn. I still don’t get the 180 on something clearly NAI. The only one tunnelling our slot, that I could see clearly looking for reactions was Taly. I do get Dann’s concern however.

~Nance

[Fuscosco]

Yes.

I hate tight-lipped people. I feel like youre fairly open here, and that scares me even more.

[NanceFloor]

@Dann, while I’m not hard townreading Chemist, I haven’t seen anything he’s done so far as remotely scummy, so until he does, I will tl him.

I pretty much agree with your readslist otherwise.

[Fuscosco]

. In what world do you read that as making any attempt at all to try to sincerely sort us.

In what world is the proper response is to push his lynch over what you believe is an ineffective push? Its an issue where your response to his push is to push him for the same quality of material as he was pushing you with.

[Fuscosco]

Ignore him for now, and see where he goes?

[Fuscosco]

Cant go after every jerkhead who picks a bone with you.

[NanceFloor]

shadowless

I dont have a read on either shadow or overkill.

lll iso those two after i read up.

i have contacted multiple list mods and the game mods.

RC has shitposted this whole game, and i dont like it.

and yes, Im going to consider the whole spat w/flavor as part of a giant shitpost.

Ankle is town

i think so.
But why arent you posting at all?

Creature is not town?

gun to head, Id go here rn.

I'll tone back, I'm sorry

Dont be sorry. Its something I have to sort out myself. My playstyle can be . . . in need of improvement. Less shitpostting, less open with my TrainofThought, and more reserved. I come off, i feel, as immature and even juvenille. It grates me because people dont take it seriously until I bust open the game. Take flavor's talk about the recent musicals game. I had solved the better portion of the game but my style and an extended period of nonposting got me quicklynched by unsure town.

To be fair to RC, this is NAI for him. He did the same, actually much worse in DnD and I don’t think any of it is scum indicative. He was town in that game fwiw.

Also, I am still currently nullreading Creature, so I don’t get the tr on him. He needs to town it a helluva lot more, before I give him as easy tr.

~ND

[NanceFloor]

. In what world do you read that as making any attempt at all to try to sincerely sort us.

In what world is the proper response is to push his lynch over what you believe is an ineffective push? Its an issue where your response to his push is to push him for the same quality of material as he was pushing you with.

The world where he remains my strongest sr. Why should my read on him have changed at all? He’s done pretty much jack to earn it?

[NanceFloor]

. In what world do you read that as making any attempt at all to try to sincerely sort us.

In what world is the proper response is to push his lynch over what you believe is an ineffective push? Its an issue where your response to his push is to push him for the same quality of material as he was pushing you with.

The world where he remains my strongest sr. Why should my read on him have changed at all? He’s done pretty much jack to earn it?

No, unlike TD, I actually have a decent case. Do I need to keep reposting it over and over again?

[Fuscosco]

If his push is weak then he will be lynched eventually. its too early to focus on one person only. it stymies progress, and we have enough of that rn

[NanceFloor]

Not liking dann this game.....

First: sr us, never really explains why.

VOTE: nancefloor

i think nancefloor is scummy but i also don't want to push them for reasons

Please do

Tries to manipulate RC into pushing us.

i think nancefloor is scummy but i also don't want to push them for reasons

And I 100% agree with you on this

If you

agree

with RC, what part of him not being interested in pushing us, went over your head?

I can't help but feel like the NanceFloor heads disagree with each other, and the fact 191 has to exist only gives credence.

Walking back initial fake sr on us.

VOTE: chennisden

I don't have any experience with chennisden and I don't want to jump on okas wagon, so I'm placing my vote there.

Feel free to sheep me unless you have reason to believe scum put the 8ball there

. If so let us know.

This does not seem right. Is there a reason for not wanting to be on Oka's wagon? I agree with Fuscosco that this is overly cautious.

(but yeah chen should effort more)

-TL

Really hard driving our lynch now.

Here’s one person that’s never 8 ball- dann...from what I’ve seen he never gets lynched day 1 so I think we’re all safe going there

Now, does an apparent 180 and suddenly tr us here. But NOW wants to push us because we’re 100% never the target.

If TD can’t push our mislynch by convincingly casing us as scum, he’s apparently good with casing us with NOT being the 8 ball.

So @TD, how did we go from your #1 sr to your #1 8 ball pick? Kind of sudden turnaround, wouldn’t you say?

~Nancy

@Fuscosco

[Fuscosco]

One half of mafia is finding scum. the other half is convincing everyone else you are right

[NanceFloor]

If his push is weak then he will be lynched eventually. its too early to focus on one person only. it stymies progress, and we have enough of that rn

Well I’m sorry, it’s unusual for me to have even one sr on D1. I’m not going to sr anyone before I feel very confident about it. Other than TD, i’m iffy on any slots I’m not currently tr.

Clemency may also be town. I’m more of a townblock builder on D1 than a scumhunter unless a scumslot pretty much just jumps out at me. I keep imploring TD to show me why he’s town here and he just keeps tanking at it, so what am I supposed to do with that?

~Nancy the frustrated

[NanceFloor]

One half of mafia is finding scum. the other half is convincing everyone else you are right

Well, I’ve made my case and if you don’t see it, there’s really not much else I can do, is there?