Mafiascum.net

In post 847, Maki and Kaito wrote:I think esp has some concerning stuff, but there's nothing wrong with post 440 - You were demonstrably in the thread and talking about off topic things, I'm not sure why you're so opposed to the idea of this, I linked the posts back.

I also had multiple iterations of a tiered readslist with notes so arguing my early game content was bad feels disingenuous

I get people are lazy and I was deliberately not trying to make the thread visually bloated with unspoilered reads lists but acting as though I wasn't solving strikes me as superficial at best and bad faith at worst

-S

In post 848, Sherlock and Watson wrote:Probably not flawless but Bit->Boon->Esp->Spiff probably hits 2+?

Alright, I'll bite, why those 4? Specifically Flavor Leaf and Spiffeh, since you haven't mentioned them

---

https://forum.mafiascum.net/download/fi ... 695799.jpg

In post 849, Bitmap wrote:@S&W: If you don't want to re-evaluate that's fine but don't get mad at me being a fanboy when I give you an honest and upfront answer as to why I read someone a certain way.

did I get mad? confused by this. I restrained myself from a direct pot shot at RC but I didn't really knock your reasoning on Esp even if it doesn't give me much reason to reevaluate

-S

In post 847, Maki and Kaito wrote:

In post 801, Bitmap wrote:I think that the Ali pick statement is WIFOM but while we're at it, why would Ali pick someone that gets lynched as town on D1/D2?

You acknowledge it's wifom then ask a wifom question

yes

In post 847, Maki and Kaito wrote:

In post 845, Bitmap wrote:I didn't know wanting to be a town leader became a scum tell in 2020.

Are you trying to be a town leader here? Doesn't look like that to me.

I'm saying Esp is trying to be town leader.

In post 850, Sherlock and Watson wrote:

In post 847, Maki and Kaito wrote:I think esp has some concerning stuff, but there's nothing wrong with post 440 - You were demonstrably in the thread and talking about off topic things, I'm not sure why you're so opposed to the idea of this, I linked the posts back.

I also had multiple iterations of a tiered readslist with notes so arguing my early game content was bad feels disingenuous

I get people are lazy and I was deliberately not trying to make the thread visually bloated with unspoilered reads lists but acting as though I wasn't solving strikes me as superficial at best and bad faith at worst

-S

You had a tiered read list but no explanations and no discussion, and a lot of off topic posts. And the read lists felt forced, imo

---

In post 852, Sherlock and Watson wrote:

In post 849, Bitmap wrote:@S&W: If you don't want to re-evaluate that's fine but don't get mad at me being a fanboy when I give you an honest and upfront answer as to why I read someone a certain way.

did I get mad? confused by this. I restrained myself from a direct pot shot at RC but I didn't really knock your reasoning on Esp even if it doesn't give me much reason to reevaluate

-S

Sorry, it felt like you were taking a pot shot at me because I'm a "fanboy/supporter". If you weren't then I take it back.

In post 851, Maki and Kaito wrote:haven't mentioned them

I just mentioned Boon was playing to scum meta like... a page ago?

And Spiffeh gives me 0 townpings in 22 posts, probably least confident on that read but I feel like I have a decent number of townreads at this point so PoE nudges me there

-S

VOTE: spiffeh

down for this

jury is out on bitmap for me but

In post 854, Maki and Kaito wrote:You had a tiered read list but no explanations

explanations are in the list...

also, why do you think it feels forced? I honestly don't get how you'd feel that at all

-S

In post 817, Sherlock and Watson wrote:

In post 813, Bitmap wrote:FL is known to be a strong player and has strong relations with Alisae. I know this sounds WIFOM but there's a good chance Ali might opt to not pick FL because e thinks FL is an easy mislynch as a result. Does this mean it's confirmed that Ali didn't pick FL? No. But I'm willing to give FL a pass today and see how he plays out in D1/D2 because if he's town, he's a viable asset and I think can help us lynch scum.

okay so putting alisae pick wifom aside how is this not Boon playing his scumgame to a T?

-S

You mean this? This doesn't explain anything.

OkaPoka wrote:VOTE: spiffeh

down for this

jury is out on bitmap for me but

I'm not down for it, probably - I was towreading them up until they said they trust us less, which I don't think that read feels real based onwhat we've actually done in the game and isntead looks reactionary and how they're 'supposed to act'.

In post 858, Sherlock and Watson wrote:

In post 854, Maki and Kaito wrote:You had a tiered read list but no explanations

explanations are in the list...

also, why do you think it feels forced? I honestly don't get how you'd feel that at all

-S

Linking to posts isn't explanations, especially when you don't change the linked posts between us going from townlean to reevaluate - it doesn't really make sense.

It feels forced because you weren't otherwise engaging with the game except for off topic thing and yet were churning out a super early reads list - I don't like that



---

And citing PoE as a reason to scumread someone at this point in the game is nonsensical, get out of here with that

---

Here, let me point you to the Boon posts I dislike this game:
https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.p ... er_sort=Go

-S

In post 859, Maki and Kaito wrote:Linking to posts isn't explanations

---

i like sherlock

Your tone feels really fucking weird this game Dunn, btw

like do you need me to wallposts shit or what? the posts are scummy, if you don't find them scummy then I can say what I find scummy about them but asking me to explain why a bunch of scummy shit is scummy is dumb and you know better

-S

I don't see how anything FL has done this game is scummy. They're null for me. You saying it's their scum meta without explanation doesn't do it for me, you linking their iso also doesn't do it for me. You're putting the minimum amount of effort possible to try to wave off FL as scum - not sure what I can "know better" when you don't explain anything.

I'm not asking you to wall post, I'm saying you're not explaining things, and are acting like everyone who calls you out on it is weird/scummy

---

Ok

Take what you just said

Boon is at best null; ok

So why are you more concerned with me sring him than bitmap emphatically saying he's not scum?

-s

In post 117, Flavor Leaf wrote:You wanna know who Ali would never draft.

ME!

Self serving

-s

In post 121, Flavor Leaf wrote:I believe it. And we finally get to play a game together, Bitmap.

Pockety

-s

isnt bitmaps reason to tr him based on wifom and likely not really that significant to him

Let’s see what the wheel says before I go to bed.

Yeah, just trying to get why dunn is nagging me simultaneously for too little content while recognizing some slots aren't readable without meta or bullshit

Boon feels like scum because he should be town by now

And instead all his posts look like scum boon

-s

Apparently I have a Scum Read.
SHOCKING!
But who is it?

TiMe To SpIn ThE wHeEl!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Apparently it’s Pine.