In post 6891, Off The Hook wrote:Also: idk if there’s been anything major since our last couple games but I also was scum in our last 2 (Slaughter Hour and uPick) and BOTH demanded I play my fucking head off at the start to not die.
This sort of looks like you are claiming mafia. Both because you are wondering why you are not getting pushed this game and because you say you were "also" scum in the other games.
His most recent read.
He also disliked Taly but maybe he was just explaining his choice in the gladiate?
In post 8460, JohnnyFarrar wrote:Not caught up but was thinking about the games gamestate last night
Did scum kill frogger, Dunn, or none of the above?
Ignoring that last option just based on probability.
If scum killed Frogger, they were really worried about the cop thing? Because he was a wild card and didn'tagree to a leash? I can't imagine that was too frightening a prospect considering several of us were talking about wanting them dead. So, based on that thought, I'm looking for scum that are either paranoid or inexperienced.
OR
If scum killed Dunn, his mystery power was frightening? Or he was onto someone. Again, both of these would have to outweigh the fact that he was suspected yesterday and that suspicion very well could have continued into today. So based on that, looking for someone paranoid, inexperienced, or suspected by Dunn
These two profiles are similar enough that I think I can narrow it down. I'm also less interested in the top wagons from yesterday, because if scum were featured heavily there I don't think they'd be brave enough to make that pool smaller
scum couldn't have known frog would get vigged; maybe they shot dunn because they thought frog would check him?
~GE
I think Dunn scum kill makes the most sense because of their FN claim.
In post 8485, Lukewarm wrote:As for Dunn, I think that the thread consensus was that he was softing Friendly Neighbor (I am unsure how that lines up with his soft at me, but I also failed at breaking that in general, so :shurg:)
If they also thought that was his claim, then they might have felt the need to shoot one of : Dunn, Roden, or Dwlee because the list of confirmed town was getting kinda high. Given those three options, I think that it makes sense to kill Dunn because he was the only one of the three that fully keeping up with the game, and the best suited to become a leader because of it.
mb we should look at what dunn's reads were before he got nightkilled but i'm too lazy for that shit
Don't you literally have a spreadsheet with everyone's reads day 1. Just sitting there?
true but i stopped updating it after the gladiate cuz i got tilted out of my mind rofl
I responded to that before with what was effectively a full refutation. Given Dunn didn't post anything following that to the effect of scumreading me, it can be figured the refutation made him drop the point. So why would I have any reason to fear him?
~GE
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2022 9:27 am
by JohnnyFarrar
Math is so hard to read -_-
I don't love a BBT push but I see why he does it.
PEdit - Did Dunn full claim somewhere? Because that cryptic shit went way over my head
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2022 9:28 am
by Lukewarm
@RAD
Why did you think that Dunn was a Paranoid Gun owner?
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2022 9:28 am
by PookyTheMagicalBear
i mean Dunn also scumread BBT according to the spreadsheet
but like so did 70% of the game so p much any nightkill was going to look bad for BBT rofl
In post 4873, Bell wrote:Is it a role that is confirmable or extremely useful and you would not recommend killing in any capacity D1 Dunn.
Confirmable: yes
Extremely useful: no
Would not recommend killing day 1: yes
Right, so I’m right and therefore he actually makes more sense than a mason, because if scum kill either Roden or Dwelee, than the other’s confirmed but Dunn likely sent a message to someone - probably not one of the masons - who didn’t have to die to confirm them and then you’d get another two confirmed slots.
Btw, extremely solid on Taly!town here. I hard veto any votes on them.
This is the only veto I'm going to accept this game from your slot.
You can stop campaigning for it.
I have other ones like OtH, so I will veto anyone I hard tr.
If you want to play alone this game, okay.
???
OtH is like my strongest tr, so why wouldn’t I veto them?
I have thoughts on this but I wanna hash out opinions w marci first before vocalizing
~GE
btw my thought on this was: think there might be a reason Bell doesn't want to allow you more than one veto?
ik you think Bell is town but I feel like his play very well serves a possible scum agenda.
~GE
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2022 9:39 am
by Off The Hook
there a reason C+G hasn't posted anything major today?
Btw, extremely solid on Taly!town here. I hard veto any votes on them.
This is the only veto I'm going to accept this game from your slot.
You can stop campaigning for it.
I have other ones like OtH, so I will veto anyone I hard tr.
If you want to play alone this game, okay.
???
OtH is like my strongest tr, so why wouldn’t I veto them?
I have thoughts on this but I wanna hash out opinions w marci first before vocalizing
~GE
btw my thought on this was: think there might be a reason Bell doesn't want to allow you more than one veto?
ik you think Bell is town but I feel like his play very well serves a possible scum agenda.
~GE
Yeah but he’s not wooden here. Like he just posts nonsense as scum and his reads progression on us made logical sense.
Posted: Tue Jul 19, 2022 9:42 am
by BlueBloodedToffee
In post 6405, Dunnstral wrote:I was already voting for Taly, but in case this resets the vote count:
Btw, extremely solid on Taly!town here. I hard veto any votes on them.
This is the only veto I'm going to accept this game from your slot.
You can stop campaigning for it.
I have other ones like OtH, so I will veto anyone I hard tr.
If you want to play alone this game, okay.
???
OtH is like my strongest tr, so why wouldn’t I veto them?
I have thoughts on this but I wanna hash out opinions w marci first before vocalizing
~GE
btw my thought on this was: think there might be a reason Bell doesn't want to allow you more than one veto?
ik you think Bell is town but I feel like his play very well serves a possible scum agenda.
~GE
Rephrasing Bells position, as i understand it:
"Nancy is willing to bet the game on Taly being town. Fine. But she only gets one read that I am going to just sheep her on"
If anything, I am surprised that Bell is just accepting that Veto, so i am confused why this is phrased like he should be allowing Nancy more then one, and you are questioning why he is only giving her the one