If the PR works only by being shot, you literally negate the PR by lynching them
ok this is town
Why tho >_>
Posted: Sat Mar 04, 2017 7:28 am
by TheRealGin-N-Tonic
In post 8603, Nero Cain wrote:its 12/5 now. Worse case scenario is that we have 3 more mislynches so they only have 2 more nights to use it. Its not a guarantee that there's another vig wonder. I understand that I'm not Math but I would want to use it ASAP when I knew there was a vig in play. So even though you disagree I'm still not understanding how it was so difficult to understand my POV that a vigcop not wanting to get vigged was scummy.
When I first read your POV it didnt make any sense to me considering you advocated to lynch someone after saying they should be shot.
insert doesnotcompute.jpeg
Even still if people's wonders are not announced, if Math!scum, the whole thing doesn't make sense.
You're saying a scum player secretly picked a wonder and announced to everyone that he picked the wonder where he needs to be shot and can then confirm a player.
From your point of view, the optimal play for scum is to boast loudly "hey shoot me" and I can confirm someone and needlessly risk their life over the actual optimal scum play of just building the wonder and keeping your mouth shut because no one will know where it went.
Like you're surface level scum hunting. Go past that newbie queue shit and look into the motivations as to why a player would do such a thing.
As scum, would you build that wonder and then ask to be shot? That basically conf! your death and as scum, you just don't do that.
As town, you told us what I would do, but do you honestly think that's the only thing you should do?
Posted: Sat Mar 04, 2017 7:29 am
by TheRealGin-N-Tonic
In post 8608, Alisae wrote:Hey! I said "In theory."
That doesn't mean that's how it works "In Pratice."
In post 8601, TheRealGin-N-Tonic wrote:Alisae brought up the point that it would be better to save the alignment because numbers and to add to that, with there being a higher percent chance of Math hitting a townie, if the player was mod confirmed D3 as town, that person would be killed the following night.
also just to clarify, the
plan
was to have the pyramids claim and Math would cop them but PV didn't claim for ???? so we'd still have that IC.
That's grody. That makes sense now from your side.
It's still a damn stretch, tell me still how, as scum it would be best to claim you should die?
I normally wouldn't be posting, but for you, I'll make a special exception. <3
This is me in a teaching role, so I'm not really playing, but if you want me to give you a lesson in-thread, you can ask for one and I'll do my best to give one to you! I suppose I could also trade banter with you if you'd like, but I can't DIRECTLY intervene play-wise. This is Jae's game, I'm just here along for the ride. <3
With 17 players alive, it takes 9 to lynch by majority.
Lynch deadline is in (expired on 2017-03-11 09:45:13), at which point we will default to no lynch.
Noble Senators, I hear your dissatisfaction and turmoil, and request quarter. A brief recess while tempers cool, and for Us to address these new and spurious charges in full light of day.
Spoiler: Translation
Ugh, there's a bunch I want to say, but it's 4AM and I have a six-hour training in the morning. I'm quite confident that I can eviscerate the wagon on me, as I've actually examined the cases against me and the only one with any original thought or attempt at gamesolving is nancy, maybe Math. The rest is largely thinly-veiled OMGUS and "lol why not this wagon seems fun." Looking at you, CK. My training ends around 3PM EST tomorrow, but I might be able to get out early considering it's a basic first aid/CPR class I need to qualify as a trainer and I'm a professional EMT. Don't lynch me til then and I'll finish this omnibus case on LUV and finish re-evaluating Vecna.
And stop hating on Caesar, he's really fun
Hope you didn't think I'm hating on your flavor. I've been loving it all game, has nothing to do with this push
I skimmed and saw some shade from Cloud and Caesar implying he scum reads me.
Skim again because you misread
Posted: Sat Mar 04, 2017 11:20 am
by Maxous
In post 8673, CloudKicker wrote:Macous vote on me looks like proxy omgus, just because im sheeping nancy doesnt mean its nott valid to do so
Uhh
1) how the hell is it "proxy omgus" when I've been voting your predecessor - something you acknowledged you're aware of.
2) sheeping is one thing. Making it explicitly clear that this is not your vote so when Pine flips town "
you can't blame me
" is another thing entirely.
Kyouko was scum because he fluff posted for practically the entire game and had bad votes on both mislynches
In post 8673, CloudKicker wrote:Macous vote on me looks like proxy omgus, just because im sheeping nancy doesnt mean its nott valid to do so
Uhh
1) how the hell is it "proxy omgus" when I've been voting your predecessor - something you acknowledged you're aware of.
2) sheeping is one thing. Making it explicitly clear that this is not your vote so when Pine flips town "
you can't blame me
" is another thing entirely.
Kyouko was scum because he fluff posted for practically the entire game and had bad votes on both mislynches
kyouko wasnt scum because of the role pm, i didnt read a second of what my pred did and idc, if you push me for my pred behaviors then dont be surprised if i scumread you back when you dont try to read me
Did you even actually try to read my post or just go ham because you think i shaded you. Its all implying that you would change a long lasting read you had on kyouko just for a pred not townreading you, even if its not the case.
Posted: Sat Mar 04, 2017 11:29 am
by CloudKicker
I might claim grudge on that tbh, mefia wouldnt push someone on the basis of something that is clearly false
Posted: Sat Mar 04, 2017 11:30 am
by Lil Uzi Vert
It's shade because it is implying I shouldn't be taken seriously. There are other reasons for my vote, I'm just waiting for Ceasar's case on me.
