Mafiascum.net

In post 505, StubbsKVM wrote:I'm still not convinced massclaim is a good idea, but if everybody wants it...well I don't really have a choice, do I?

Scum

Mr Flay
Feel It
Champino
Generic
Nacho
Miss Stranger

Town

I'm sorry Mr Flay. Your predecessor has ruined your slot for me. You can say whatever you want basically. There's no way I'll ever trust you enough to keep you around for long.

Well sure, but this last line still applies.

Nacho: Am I correct in the assumption that you don't actually find Karnage scummy, however you think both Stubbs and Flay are more likely town than Karnage?

In post 866, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 856, champinoman wrote:Nacho: Why have you not placed a vote on who you find scummier out of Stubbs and Karnage? (you said you consider Flay the least likely)

I wanted to talk to stubbs a little bit first.

Vote: Karnage

What do you think of my Flay town case?

When I read the game after I replaced in the two players that were scummiest to me were you and flay. I could go back and quote posts but I'm not. I don't have the time right now.

I'd say there is a 66% chance you are scum, 33% that flay is, and 1% that its stubbs.

I'm for either shitting or getting off the pot here.

We lynch flay today and if he is town we lynch nacho tomorrow (or vice versa.) either way its a town win.

Wait, you're against the three lynch model?

In post 876, champinoman wrote:Nacho: Am I correct in the assumption that you don't actually find Karnage scummy, however you think both Stubbs and Flay are more likely town than Karnage?

No.

Well Nacho, you're going to need to make a case if you want me to vote him.

In post 879, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 876, champinoman wrote:Nacho: Am I correct in the assumption that you don't actually find Karnage scummy, however you think both Stubbs and Flay are more likely town than Karnage?

No.

Please, don't elaborate or point me in the right direction. That'd actually be helpful.

I can't wait to lynch you.

In post 879, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 876, champinoman wrote:Nacho: Am I correct in the assumption that you don't actually find Karnage scummy, however you think both Stubbs and Flay are more likely town than Karnage?

No.

Excluding your vote, the only point over the that you suggest a Karnage lynch is:

In post 780, Nachomamma8 wrote:i would love to be useful this day but i literally have no idea what the fuck is going on at this point. i feel great about flay and great about stubbs to the point where i would go with karnage in the end.

So explain to me how my assumption was incorrect?

Just seems like another chance for you to vote against the grain (all other votes were on Flay or Stubbs) to try and drag this saga out. Is that your scum ploy? Drag this game out in the hope we abandon it?

In post 880, StubbsKVM wrote:Well Nacho, you're going to need to make a case if you want me to vote him.

i know i know, don't have time at the moment

In post 882, champinoman wrote:Just seems like another chance for you to vote against the grain (all other votes were on Flay or Stubbs) to try and drag this saga out. Is that your scum ploy? Drag this game out in the hope we abandon it?

that seems like a pretty bad ploy.

Better than your chances as scum, though fairly unsporting.

.

In post 884, Mr. Flay wrote:Better than your chances as scum

I can't say I understand this.

How's the weather where you are today Nacho?

In post 878, Mr. Flay wrote:Wait, you're against the three lynch model?

You know what? I think I am.

*sigh* Go back and read the argument between champino and I about it. Then tell us why you're still in favor.

In post 887, champinoman wrote:How's the weather where you are today Nacho?

i think his play since he's replaced in has been bad
i don't like how his flay suspicion is essentially based on nothing
i don't like his small attack on stubbs because it shows paranoia but that paranoia isn't reflected anywhere else in his posts
he sort of agrees with the plan every day but not really and seems to be confused from it even though it's pretty simple

but at this point i'm pretty ok with lynching flay now and if he flips town, lynching karnage.
i feel good about stubbs and i feel good about flay.

but i'm not really willing to pull a yesterday in order to get the against the grain push today

VOTE: Mr Flay

Let's see what happens.

Still waiting for Karnage.

In fact, that comment is enough to switch my order for today/tomorrow.

UNVOTE: Stubbs

VOTE: Karnage

.

.

[/b].

I've always considered Stubbs scummier than Karnage so; Nacho, how are you going to convince me to change my mind?

Karnage, why are you against the 3 lynch model? (As it was described above)

In post 898, champinoman wrote:I've always considered Stubbs scummier than Karnage so; Nacho, how are you going to convince me to change my mind?

Karnage, why are you against the 3 lynch model? (As it was described above)

I'm 99% sure nacho is scum but if he isn't we lose with his lynch since that would make stubbs a Roleblocker.

I'm 99% sure that stubbs is town but if he isn't then we can still lynch nacho tomorrow for the win.

My gut is telling me to just lynch nacho and be done with it but my brain is saying that lynching stubbs (even if he is most likely town) is the better play.