Newbie 1433 - Game Over

[Peabody]

Meh, I should have waited til he answered my questions.

Oh well, I still have a hunch it will be a scum flip.

[Peabody]

Shoot, that was a really impulsive hammer.

I'm sorry if Skelda is town.

[Mr_Ree]

Sthar, I really like that. Had you actually lynched him, I would have been outraged, but as it stands I think it reveals a lot about how quick to accuse some people are. At least one of the people who immediately voted for you is probably scum.

And the people going after Nomninull want an easy lynch. I'm reading him as stubborn town, and I don't want a lynch wasted on him when there are better candidates whose lynches will tell us more. Nomni, can you just give them reads to get them off of your back? Right now, if you are town, you had beter make an effort and not just let them waste today on you.

We don't want an easy lynch, Skelda, we want a correct lynch, and he's the scummiest to me right now. Why do you think we want an 'easy lynch'?

I feel like scum are convincing well-meaning townies to vote Nomni because he is being stubborn and trying to get rid of a behavior that is detrimental to the town's win. He has by no means great play, but there is a difference between disliking something and using your vote and persistence to make it stop, and scumminess. You guys need to see that.

And yes, because of his behavior and the town we have, getting Nomni lynched wouldn't be hard, especially with no one but me willing to defend him. I don't care about 2Pac, and I don't care about Nomni. Right now, I am convinced that they both are town. It is the people pushing Nomni who are scummy to me.

P-Edit: Fuzzy, that was obviously a gambit, no scum motive is there for sthar to do such a thing as she knew it could get her votes. That is why I am voting for you.

Nomni, please don't do that. You need to get your priorities straight. This is about winning, not proving a point. 2Pac has't even posted in a while, with any luck he will be replaced and we can move on. In the meantime, take the highroad, post your reads, and play to your wincon.

@ Skelda

You make a good point about his action .I am not sure yet.I need time to think it over a bit. I think maybe i was being a bit hard headed. Also I said that thought that the Nom wagon semed to be easy wagon so you were not the only defending him.

Skelda_ who do you deserves lynching .

The possibilities I see are...
Fuzzy-Bob
2Pac-Ranawey
Ranawey-Fuzzy
Fuzzy-2Pac

I am thinking 2Pac is town, but the arbitrary defending of him got him on the list. Those are the four that jump out at me, I'll go through all the combinations that are likely in a bit.

Also one thing I want to note before I forget, I really really don't think the interaction between Satan and Skelda are partners at all. The entire push and argument between each other heavily points against it. That means that if Satan flips scum which I'm pretty sure he will then Skelda is sadly town.

Why is that sad? Just sad you don't have both Day 1? I'm pretty sure the other scum will reveal themselves in time. Very well could be Ranawey... Or 2Pac, him voting Nomni now is idiotic.

This is ridiculous. We were so close to getting done with time to spare...

Ree, we are not lynching Null. All he has done is tunnel on 2Pac and be attacked and defended. Satan's flip is what we need right now. End of story. You just don't have the votes to kill Null.

my thoughts exactly.

Do you see the Nom connection or am I just seeing things here?

[Mr_Ree]

Yeah, that was impulsive. Better hope he flips scum. Either way, enjoy the game. I probably won't be around tomorrow. In case of town flip, Nom/Peabody/fuzzy are good options.

[Peabody]

It's definitely possible if Skeda is scum.

I just regret hammering him so quickly after I caught up.

It truly was impulsive.

I was trying to convince myself he is scum when I said he probably will flip scum. We'll see if my convincing of myself is correct.

If Skeda flips scum, Nomi could be scum too. Satan would be town. Probably Fuzzy would be town too.

If he's town, we'd benefit from a VCA.

[Mr_Ree]

I really do want a scum flip here. I think it's quite possible but that hammer...

It makes me doubtful....

[Nominull]

I don't know what to think anymore. I really had a townread on Regfan.

[Nominull]

I will be greatly shocked if Skelda turns out to be scum given that manner of hammering. For goodness's sake we still haven't replaced Ranawey! I can't see it as anything other than an attempt to throw us into LYLO with as little information as possible.

[Peabody]

For the town and for my life, I hope I'm right.

[Peabody]

Based on Nominull's post, I wouldn't be surprised if Mr_Ree lives tonight.

If one of the two are scum.

[SafetyDance]

Votecount 2.5

Skelda (4): SatanHellYeah, Ranawey, Mr_Ree, Peabody

Ranawey (1):

Nominull

Peabody (1):

TheFuzzylogic99

TheFuzzylogic99 (1):

Skelda

Not voting

:

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-10-12 12:00:00). With 7 players, it's 4 to lynch.

A lynch has been reached!

[SafetyDance]

All things considered, the drop-down oxygen masks make rather handy nooses when you need it. MacGyver would be proud!

Skleda has been lynched. He was a

Vanilla Townie

.

Klick has replaced Ranawey.

It is now Night Two. All actions must be sent in the next 72 hours.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-10-09 08:30:00)

[SafetyDance]

Cabin fever and DVT, not a good mix.

Peabody has been killed. He was a

Vanilla Townie

.

Day 3 has begun!

Votecount 3.0

Not voting

: Klick, TheFuzzylogic99, SatanHellYeah, Nominull, Mr_Ree

The deadline is Saturday, October 23rd, 2013 at 11:00 AM EST.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-10-23 11:00:00). With 5 players, it's 3 to lynch.

[Klick]

Sup guys. I'll make a post when I get home.

[Nominull]

Nice of the mafia to give us a sporting chance, I guess?

[Nominull]

We're in LYLO now, so don't vote until we're ready to lynch. Use FOS instead, like so:

FOS: Fuzzy

The nice thing about FOS is that since it's unofficial it doesn't have to be on its own line.

[Nominull]

Here is what I'm thinking - mafia could have won the game by shooting literally any other townie and then letting us lynch Peabody. So either they're toying with us, or they didn't realize that. If they're toying with us, okay, whatever, we lose, but we would have lost anyway. If they didn't realize it, that indicts Fuzzy and Satan.

[SatanHellYeah]

My top scum reads flipped town. Well, that is not at all good.

Peabody's townflip was by far more expected that Skelda's, at least for me...

Thing is, ¿why would scum kill Peabody? Indeed, if any other of us had been killed, the others would have gone for Peabody.
You think they either didn't realize or are toying with us. You are assuming there is no other option, then? I'd rather check the ISO and analyze that.

In fact, I'll do this right now.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Welcome Klick


I dont know....I dont see them killing off a replacement ie Klick. Not sure if there any value in that kill. The only reason remotely possible is that they would not want a radom factor inserted so late in the game. Unless Klick is somehow scum than I would guess that he was spared bc he had no value as a kill.

I wonder if they figured that PB would seem still be consider town despite his action so they killed him off . I dont see PB gathering enough votes to garner a lynch.
Interesting that Ree survived the night. I would think he would be the most obvious kill. PB all but hinted that Ree kill would be a Nom lynch. If I was scum I would of offed Ree without thought. Why would the scum not take the nicely wrapped gift? This seem very odd to me.

More thoughts later....

[SatanHellYeah]

Are you somehow suggesting Ree is scum?

Peabody said that if Ree was NK'ed, Nom would be a great option. This is because, obviously, Ree has been trying to catch Nom all Day 2. So, supposing Nom was scum, the main target would be Ree.

At the same time, this would have been suspicious enough to earn a lynch.

So Ree being alive does not clean Nom at all.


Maybe they are really toying with us. I can't see anybody being specially harassed by him.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

I am just noticed it was odd that Ree is still alive, I found it odd and wanted to others thought if this. i guess it is possible Ree is scum I think at this point i should consider anything possible. I do think it is not likely. I think it is likely Ree is alive bc killing him would make Nom a huge target. So if Nom is scum it is a very good reason we could be seeing Ree alive.

I also think Nom is wrong. I do not think that PB would be considered despite his rash hammering. Maybe I a being naive . I think the scum knew that a PB wagon was not likely .

[Klick]

Just based on the posts so far in Day 3:

- Nominull is probably town. He spent time (from 1:33 to 2:04 PM CDT) thinking about the game, and posted his thoughts. I think this shows that he had just now started to consider the meaning of the Peabody kill, instead of already having thought about it during the Night.

- Along the same line, SHY is a slight scumread. His Post #892 looks kinda fake to me.

If I had to call the scum right now, it'd be SHY/Fuzzy.

[Mr_Ree]

I'm alive???

I have take another look at this game. Since my links to Nom flipped town, it's more likely he is also town.

I think I may be down for fuzzy now. I have to check into him some more.

[TheFuzzylogic99]

Klick---- can you give any other reason that Nom didnt think about his words except for the time difference between his log on and his post. I am not saying your are wrong about you analysis of Nom posts but I would like a bit more info about reasoning.
Also what basis do you have me marked as scum.?? You seem to be giving very little evidence for your theories and I would like to try to understand where you are coming from?

[Nominull]

I think we should all reread the game while we wait for Klick to finish his reread. From here on out we can't get any wrong answers.