Newbie 1964 [Game Over]

[RadiantCowbells]

Can you guys sell me on bepwei?

I'm going to make a hard right turn here. What do you think about BB as scum?

Looking back at his ISO I don't like his early sheeping on the jones vote. Then he makes a weird 180 at the end of the day on the jones/guilded slot. naked votes on billy and bep to start the day. the only reasoning he can give is "the same reason as karnage"

UNVOTE:

There's also this derail of the Bepwei wagon, plus the fact that Bepwei won't shut the fuck up about how he's "uncertain" of his read on him.

[Jamelia]

Jesus I wish more people were online.

[Billy Pilgrim]

I like voting Bepwei. I'm gonna go to bed soon. I need to know if that's not gonna get lynched and I need to be somewhere else. God always around the deadlines.

[RadiantCowbells]

I thought I was all you needed <3

[RadiantCowbells]

Can you give me 15 minutes to finish my last catchup then you're free?

[Karnage]

@RC - probably would have been a good idea to have done this deep dive into the game when you subbed instead of being intentionally scummy for almost all of Day 2 but ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Are we lynching me or are we lynching somebody else? I need to go to sleep

[RadiantCowbells]

I don’t have a guilty or an innocent or anything I just think Billy is scum

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Bepwei

Feeling this instead more atm

Also Billy’s reaction was townish I think

I'm good with a bepwei wagon

I don't think this comes from town

I am confused why they would choose arkias as their NK. Any idea?

VOTE: bepwei

Can you guys sell me on bepwei?

I voted him same reason as Karnage

Old epic mafia tell is that only a doctor or mafia comments on the nightkill

I voted him same reason as Karnage

Old epic mafia tell is that only a doctor or mafia comments on the nightkill

You've never had people comment on the NK? That is one of the tells of who could be mafia. The reason I posted that is because Arkias was one the more inactive people toward the end of the day. The only reason I can think of for lynching Arkias is he was very analytical, and was not under heat from the town. I am confident there was at least one scum on the LCpl/Gilded wagon. Of course, that does not clear my name, but some reasoning behind your vote, @BBMolla, would be nice. Karnage didn't really give reasoning either, but he was suspicious of me yesterday, so I expected his vote today.

Can you guys sell me on bepwei?

I'm going to make a hard right turn here. What do you think about BB as scum?

Looking back at his ISO I don't like his early sheeping on the jones vote. Then he makes a weird 180 at the end of the day on the jones/guilded slot. naked votes on billy and bep to start the day. the only reasoning he can give is "the same reason as karnage"

UNVOTE:

This isn't great.

[RadiantCowbells]

It's more fun to play the game normally instead of doing what I'm doing now but I don't want to lose this game.

[bepwei]

Jesus I wish more people were online.

worst case hammer me.

Can you give me 15 minutes to finish my last catchup then you're free?

Ill be here

[RadiantCowbells]

Looking back at his ISO I don't like his early sheeping on the jones vote. Then he makes a weird 180 at the end of the day on the jones/guilded slot. naked votes on billy and bep to start the day. the only reasoning he can give is "the same reason as karnage"

UNVOTE:

Not sure where I should "flesh out" the case on BBMolla. I think its pretty well summarized in what I've already posted. PLUS his read on Billy is flip flopping now followed by sheeping Micc again...
VOTE: BBMolla

@Billy another reason could be straight confusion. To send us down a wild goose chase. I’m leaning toward that because there wasn’t a whole lot of information to begin with. A NK like you said gives info and it isn’t super obvious which one happened right now. Is there one option you think is more likely to have occurred.

this feels like scum bragging how they've confused town with their NK choice

I'm not wholeheartedly against lynch gyro but I don't like how the wagon has formed. feels artificial or something

Also next page, he goes right back to calling Bepwei scum as soon as the wagon's dead.

[RadiantCowbells]

what does scum molla have to gain by making naked votes at the start of the day or flipping his vote around?

so we should just accept him as town for "reasons"?

yikes

[Jamelia]

There’s 4 of us online right now to vote for either Bep or Karnage.

I think the strongest case lays within Karnage. Does anyone disagree with me?

[Karnage]

It's more fun to play the game normally instead of doing what I'm doing now but I don't want to lose this game.

neither do I but I also wish I hadn't wasted my Sunday following your fake scum trail when I could have been focusing in on ACTUAL scum

[RadiantCowbells]

I am actual scum. I'm just not mafia.

[Karnage]

There’s 4 of us online right now to vote for either Bep or Karnage.

I think the strongest case lays within Karnage. Does anyone disagree with me?

I don't agree but do what you gotta do

[RadiantCowbells]

Do you mind if I postpone this 20 minutes and do a second meta on Karnage from an alternate viewpoint

aka can you stay up for 20 more minutes Billy/Jam

[Jamelia]

It's more fun to play the game normally instead of doing what I'm doing now but I don't want to lose this game.

neither do I but I also wish I hadn't wasted my Sunday following your fake scum trail when I could have been focusing in on ACTUAL scum

Or you could have used your own judgment instead of blindly following someone who you then deemed scum.

You’re either scum or a bad townie, and either way it doesn’t help us.

[Karnage]

Do you mind if I postpone this 20 minutes and do a second meta on Karnage from an alternate viewpoint

aka can you stay up for 20 more minutes Billy/Jam

its your world my man, the rest of us are just living in it

[Jamelia]

There’s 4 of us online right now to vote for either Bep or Karnage.

I think the strongest case lays within Karnage. Does anyone disagree with me?

I don't agree but do what you gotta do

Who is Bep’s partner? @Karnage
Who is Karnage’s partner? @Bep

This is free to answer for everyone else. I am curious what they think.

[Jamelia]

Also Karnage, I apologize for being so aggro towards you. I’m just trying to figure out scum the same way you are. I’ve just had less time and we cannot afford a mislynch.

Reading this game last night made me realize so many people are complacent. That’s why RC was able to waste so much of your time. Do I think hEs mafia? No, but I think everyone else should have been trying to figure it out

[bepwei]

I think Heavy by PoE

[RadiantCowbells]

One of the advantages of lynching Karnage over Bepwei is I totally buy that he was trying to PR hunt me and Molla and so if Karnage flips scum I can reasonably confidently townread Bbmolla.

[RadiantCowbells]

Come on man, why did you sign up to play the game if you're not gonna try? Look, I think theres a better than average chance that Gyro is scum now. If both scum are lurking it explains why there isnt any scummy play that's presenting itself. Also, he did hop yesterday's wagon fairly easily.

I want that lynch and it's not just policy. Is a good bit policy? Yes, but come on that slot is infuriating. He literally responded to his fourth prod with the word "post."

yeah, I think the risk is well worth the possible reward at this point

VOTE: gyro

weird ass fking post

[RadiantCowbells]

in the event we mass claim, or for any claims really:

cop claim can be CC'd by jailkeeper, tracker, and friendly neighbor
doc claim can be CC'd by jailkeeper, friendly neighbor
jailkeeper claim can be CC'd by cop and doc
tracker claim can be CC'd by cop
friendly neighbor can be CC'd by cop and doc
mason can be CC'd by any other PR

@RC, you're the brains behind this setup, let me know if I got any of that wrong

aww :3

[bepwei]

One of the advantages of lynching Karnage over Bepwei is I totally buy that he was trying to PR hunt me and Molla and so if Karnage flips scum I can reasonably confidently townread Bbmolla.

even with the BBMolla soft claim? I think karnage would have already killed BB