Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 6:47 am
I hate people when they sprout 100% certainties day 1.In post 873, Not_Mafia wrote:Geraint is locktown
But I will make an exception for this
But I will make an exception for this
Page 36 of 224
But I will make an exception for this
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 6:47 am
:/
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 6:54 am
In post 876, Gamma Emerald wrote::/
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 8:17 am
not mafia isnt actually playing the game they just purposefully post the bare minimum to annoy ppl and yet we still allow them to play like this (((:
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 8:19 am
This reads as a whole pile of nothing. "I think this but i guess that but also this and that oh yeah weird that this bc i think you are town so yeah"In post 874, Tayl0r Swift wrote:i dont think ive seen math play scum. im just saying math always feels lurky and bland to me. i think math's takes as town are generally decent even though they are sparse though. so maybe bad takes = math is scum? not sure about tunneling either. anyway VP this is the sort of engagement re math i was looking for from someone on the wagon. shockingly it came from the person on the wagon i most strongly townread.In post 872, VP Baltar wrote:I'm open to being persuaded elsewhere. Haven't seen super strong cases today (but it is also D1, so we can only expect so much).In post 871, Tayl0r Swift wrote:im not here to defend math. the case is eh. maybe. but this looks a lot like what ive seen from math as town. math is a wallflower who doesnt really do much. i dont know how to sort math and maybe math makes for a good policy lunch, but eh. i think we can probably do better.
So are you saying you think this is Math's town meta or just his general play all the time, regardless of alignment? Does math usually tunnel?
I'll be curious to see what Math says about gamma's entrance.
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 8:19 am
taylor still scum btw
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 9:09 am
Ok scumIn post 878, DkKoba wrote:not mafia isnt actually playing the game they just purposefully post the bare minimum to annoy ppl and yet we still allow them to play like this (((:
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:08 am
I'm not opposed to yeeting them because I really don't like condoning shit behaviorIn post 878, DkKoba wrote:not mafia isnt actually playing the game they just purposefully post the bare minimum to annoy ppl and yet we still allow them to play like this (((:
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:15 am
Koba, what are your reads atm?
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:17 am
Good evening all and Happy Birthday JV!
Welcome Gamma Emerald, thank you for stepping in to keep the game going
831 from DGB is much appreciated and looks like there is plenty there to unpack - I've had a brief look over it for now and will look through the links more thoroughly at the weekend when I have time.
The point Andres makes in 845 ref the large pool of hard to read players is on the money -> to me, finishing D1 in a good place includes having more engagement from that pool so that we are able to make a more informed read on those slots going into D2.
The interaction between Geraint | Not_mafia is noteworthy here, as is other players' views towards the pair of them:
@DGB - what differentiates Not_Mafia (top of your townreads) from Geraint (in your scumreads)? Other players' reads have varied for those two, but those that I have been able to find tend to have read both of them as being in a similar place in terms of alignment. IMO they are both in a similar place of engaging with the game in a very limited manner and being very blatant about it although Not_Mafia takes this further.
Welcome Gamma Emerald, thank you for stepping in to keep the game going
831 from DGB is much appreciated and looks like there is plenty there to unpack - I've had a brief look over it for now and will look through the links more thoroughly at the weekend when I have time.
The point Andres makes in 845 ref the large pool of hard to read players is on the money -> to me, finishing D1 in a good place includes having more engagement from that pool so that we are able to make a more informed read on those slots going into D2.
The interaction between Geraint | Not_mafia is noteworthy here, as is other players' views towards the pair of them:
I'm not sure how self-aware this post is (it may be deliberately ironic), but Geraint is basically also describing himself here.In post 856, geraintm wrote: I've not played with SCum Not Mafia. I have a hige fear the game they are scum, their playstyle will just let them coast through the game for ages and ages
Why? Having looked at a couple of his previous games, I certainly don't find him as scummy as I initially did as I can see the lack of engagement in D1 is in character, but I don't see anything in his posts that marks him as town.In post 873, Not_Mafia wrote:Geraint is locktown
@DGB - what differentiates Not_Mafia (top of your townreads) from Geraint (in your scumreads)? Other players' reads have varied for those two, but those that I have been able to find tend to have read both of them as being in a similar place in terms of alignment. IMO they are both in a similar place of engaging with the game in a very limited manner and being very blatant about it although Not_Mafia takes this further.
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:23 am
I'm all for reducing the amount of guesswork in the game and would favour an elim on a less active/engaged slot over a more active one if all other things were even in terms of scuminess.In post 882, VP Baltar wrote:I'm not opposed to yeeting them because I really don't like condoning shit behaviorIn post 878, DkKoba wrote:not mafia isnt actually playing the game they just purposefully post the bare minimum to annoy ppl and yet we still allow them to play like this (((:
That being said, we have over a week of time left in D1 should we need it so we don't need to be overly worrying about this at this point (I'm not saying you necessarily are
)Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:25 am
Honestly I might rather lim DGB/math than n_m if we're limming a low activity slot, I wanna sheep VP's townread on n_m.
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:28 am
Relevant to the above ref hard-to-read players - I would've thought using PRs (vig especially) would be more effective on scummier but more active slots rather than high variance slots. Idk if there's an accepted meta on this though.In post 534, VP Baltar wrote:So how does someone read this slot? I mean I guess we can wait a day for a cop or a vig. But that's annoyingIn post 526, Infinity 324 wrote:Generally no
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:29 am
I like using lims on more active slots rather than PRs since it gives more info.
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:31 am
He just isIn post 884, Marky Mark wrote:Why?
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:36 am
And on that enlightened note from N_M, I'm going to call it a night. Will have limited availability tomorrow but will try and stay afloat and then will look through things more thoroughly at the weekend.
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:36 am
Yes, I would still rather yeet someone we agree is scummiest.In post 885, Marky Mark wrote:I'm all for reducing the amount of guesswork in the game and would favour an elim on a less active/engaged slot over a more active one if all other things were even in terms of scuminess.In post 882, VP Baltar wrote:I'm not opposed to yeeting them because I really don't like condoning shit behaviorIn post 878, DkKoba wrote:not mafia isnt actually playing the game they just purposefully post the bare minimum to annoy ppl and yet we still allow them to play like this (((:
That being said, we have over a week of time left in D1 should we need it so we don't need to be overly worrying about this at this point (I'm not saying you necessarily are
I think it's a complete waste of a day to some degree to have to yeet n_m, but it is also very annoying behavior to encourage. Last resort for the day if needed I guess
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:41 am
My pronouns are they them thanks!! Il
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 10:45 am
I believe they were talking about gerain
Can you give reads?
Can you give reads?
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 11:10 am
I'm soulmason with Not_Mafia.In post 884, Marky Mark wrote:@DGB - what differentiates Not_Mafia (top of your townreads) from Geraint (in your scumreads)? Other players' reads have varied for those two, but those that I have been able to find tend to have read both of them as being in a similar place in terms of alignment. IMO they are both in a similar place of engaging with the game in a very limited manner and being very blatant about it although Not_Mafia takes this further.
Geraint is a one-note whining machine moping about playing the game he signed up for, it's all excuses. Just lazy scum AtE.
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 11:12 am
Just wait until I start spamming the game.In post 886, Infinity 324 wrote:Honestly I might rather lim DGB/math than n_m if we're limming a low activity slot
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 11:25 am
We were talking about Geraint tyvm, it's not all about you y'know
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 11:27 am
VOTE: NM
I'll probably always be okay with yeeting him so I'll just park this here
I'll probably always be okay with yeeting him so I'll just park this here
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 11:31 am
I'm here specifically for thisIn post 895, DrippingGoofball wrote:Just wait until I start spamming the game.In post 886, Infinity 324 wrote:Honestly I might rather lim DGB/math than n_m if we're limming a low activity slot
Posted: Thu Oct 29, 2020 11:33 am
i dont like thisIn post 897, Gamma Emerald wrote:VOTE: NM
I'll probably always be okay with yeeting him so I'll just park this here