Mafiascum.net

↑ BK201 wrote:Forgot Acosmist claimed King Kai Cop, but still.

Effing wow

I would seriously lynch BK201 if we can get the votes before deadline.

We have 3 claims already? Day 1. Its not as easy to remember every single claim when you're playing in a handful of other games + school.

Not my fault you guys decided to wall-spam the game about stuff like flavor, doesn't really matter.

↑ BK201 wrote:

Yates

idk

↑ BK201 wrote:
Yates didn't claim did he?

↑ BK201 wrote:^typo, I meant two of my strong town-reads are voting Yates!

↑ BK201 wrote:I thought he did, I didn't feel like finding it. Claimed kind kai cop right?

↑ BK201 wrote:Thats really my only reason for not voting him.

↑ BK201 wrote:I'm not going to be bullied into voting. I think Yates is town for now. I also don't like how Acosmist is lining up lynches, so he can go back tomorrow and quote himself followed by a vote for myself.

These quotes do not make any sense.

First we get "Yates is IDK". No further reads lists since that post - That is not a Town read.

Next we get the string of "Did he claim?" "He claimed King Kai, right?" "That's the only reason I'm not voting him" - this does not say he has a Town read on Yates at all. In fact it says "i'd vote him if he wasn't the Cop"

Next we get "I'm not going to vote him he's a Town read"

If we don't lynch Yates I want BK's head on a pike.

↑ BK201 wrote:Not my fault you guys decided to wall-spam the game about stuff like flavor, doesn't really matter.

Reading is not a hardship Princess. If you don't want to read in a game of communication I'm not sure what to tell you ...

Its hard to read when its just a wall battle between two players. I recall Thor wall battled someone earlier in the thread, and lately its been Yates vs a few people in wall wars.

WHO ARE THE TWO PLAYERS

I AM A PLAYER

MAGNA IS A PLAYER

YATES IS A PLAYER WTF MORE THAN TWOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

With all the energy you are putting into remarks that say basically "READING HARD BK SMASH" you could have reviewed the thread, spent some time in thought, and made one decent post.

↑ MagnaofIllusion wrote:I’m going to tie this up in a nice little post to demonstrate how Yates’s post doesn’t make sense from a Town perspective.

He’s provided two interlinked premisese –

A. That the major characters (Goku in his example) from a series MUST be power-roles.
B. That all characters fit based on “flavor”

From this he drew the following conclusion – that Slandaar was either lying and was either a Town PR or Scum with a Goku fake-claim.

This much is true.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:

Premise 1

- The major characters from a Series MUST be power-roles.

False. I believe *THE* major character MUST be a power role.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:

Premise 2

– Roles must match their characters via flavor.

This also bad as ‘flavor matching’ as he’s relied on is completely subjective. Take for example Red Robin from DC Mafia. He argues being a VT makes sense while ignoring the rather salient point that three other characters in the DC Universe who were also Robin to Batman were all power-roles. He doesn’t want to argue whether they make sense or not as it undermines his case – if Nightwing and Damien Wayne Robin make sense as Cops then Red Robin doesn’t make sense as VT logically. Furthermore he avoids completely that Stephanie Brown (who was briefly Robin and also Spoiler) was a Doctor which doesn’t make a bit of flavor sense.

This isn't an outright falsehood but is fallacious in it's twisting of logic. IN THAT GAME, with that character list [which was weird to begin with] it absolutely made sense that Red Robin was a VT. Yes, Nightwing was also Robin at one point. As of that game, he was already a superhero in his own right, not Batman's sidekick. Granted, I gave you Damien and Stephanie because I don't know them.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:Now let’s talk Ghostbusters 2 – Which further cements that assigning characters from flavor to roles can be done in any way the Mod wishes and clearly doesn’t have to ‘make sense’/

This is a BS argument. I put all the roles out there for everyone else to make their own assumptions so I'm clearly not trying to hide anything.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:

Conclusion – Slandaar has to be lying and thus is either a Town Powerrole or scum

Yes. I agree with this.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:What is the normal reaction to this from Town? Continuing to vote and push for lynch the person in question as someone claiming VT has no reason to not be lynched if they are scummy.

That might be what YOU would do but it's not what *I* would do. The fact that he claimed Goku and has not been countered is reason enough to unvote regardless of how scummy I think he has been. It is absolutely possible for Town to act scummy and I'm not down with accidentally lynching a PR because he lied about that part of his reveal.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:Yates’s reaction is not this. It is “OMGZ GOKU CAN’T BE VT YOU ARE EITHER LYING TOWN OR LYING SCUM” with an accompanying unvote. Which makes no sense.

As you can see above, you are wrong and it makes absolute sense. You are, however, misrepping how this went down. But that's a minor point and I don't care enough.

MagnaofIllusion wrote:All Yates’s reaction served was to allow him an excuse to get off the wagon which eventually leads to claimed PR Acosmist being wagonned to claim.

Yeah. I clearly took the easy path. I don't know why Acosmist claimed so early or why he was acting like scum but I was obviously not the only one that saw how scummy he was being. So unless your argument is that I'm scum and my whole scum team jumped on the Acosmist wagon, this is bullshit.

I may not have contributed much so far, but I have contributed, and I have my reads.

↑ BK201 wrote:Its hard to read when its just a wall battle between two players. I recall Thor wall battled someone earlier in the thread, and lately its been Yates vs a few people in wall wars.

In fairness, I'm arguing for my life since I don't have a fancy PR to claim or hero name to fakeclaim.

you still think Goku is a fakeclaim? so you think Slandaar is scum?

I claimed 53 hours before the (then) deadline. How is that early?

And I was at L-1 at the point when only 8 people had posted, so, you know, THAT would have been 1. early and yet 2. justified. But I held off. Look at me, being a boss.

↑ MagnaofIllusion wrote:You’ve already claimed you are ‘Town’ who knows he is getting lynched. Why bother to not leave your thoughts on record?

You must have missed this post.

↑ Yates wrote:I'm tired and the wagon is OBVIOUSLY not moving. Go read my posts and figure it out yourself as I've already stated my opinions on EVERYONE. I can't lead everyone to water in this game.

Stop being lazy.

@MoI - You're not down for counterwagons? Yeah, we totally disagree on that. And it's kind of silly regardless of your scum read not to want that info out there on general principle in my opinion.

I don't get your issues with that VT part of his claim, I think that's the strongest argument for him being town. Your theory is that he was Scum, "thought" he had claimed VT...realized he didn't, and went with an awkward explanation thereof to cover? I'll agree the lack of reads look suspect, but I'm worried you're in a tunnel if you're taking everything he's done and calling it scummy, because unless he's like a drmyshotty level player clearly everything he has done isn't a scumtell.

And now you're down for BK scum? You do realize if he is scum Yates is almost definitely town, right?

@Yates - I will agree with MoI about the lazy part. Just re-state your old reads or offer new reads on them. Just say the reads.

If there's a Krillin out there he needs to counter-claim. I see no reason for a DBZ fan to not include the funniest character to make fun of Krillin. Thats my call.

↑ BK201 wrote:you still think Goku is a fakeclaim? so you think Slandaar is scum?

No. I'm saying Goku *could be* a fakeclaim because Slandaar has been scummy and I'm not buying that he would be a VT. I asked the question WAY back when to determine if Goku was the main character for Saiyan Saga and was told he *IS* the main character [which matches up with the brief bio I read on wiki]. I'll put it to you this way, I unvoted Slandaar based on the strength of his name claim and subsequent lack of a counter. Nothing else about him makes him Town so I continue to be leery.

↑ Thor665 wrote:@Yates - I will agree with MoI about the lazy part. Just re-state your old reads or offer new reads on them. Just say the reads.

[sigh]
Fine. I'm too tired right now and need to scoot. I'll revisit tonight when I have time to put effort into this.

↑ BK201 wrote:If there's a Krillin out there he needs to counter-claim.

This. Please.

↑ Yates wrote:

↑ Thor665 wrote:@Yates - I will agree with MoI about the lazy part. Just re-state your old reads or offer new reads on them. Just say the reads.

[sigh]
Fine. I'm too tired right now and need to scoot. I'll revisit tonight when I have time to put effort into this.

no. Gutreads right now.

^gutreads

Thor wrote: I'll agree the lack of reads look suspect, but I'm worried you're in a tunnel if you're taking everything he's done and calling it scummy, because unless he's like a drmyshotty level player clearly everything he has done isn't a scumtell.

And now you're down for BK scum? You do realize if he is scum Yates is almost definitely town, right?

So let me get this straight – you are ‘concerned’ that I am tunneling Yates. Yet when I offer up that I find BK scummy and possibly will lynch him you go after me saying “BK being scum means Yates is Town”?

Furthermore enlighten me about why BK scum means Yates is Town ..

--

Yates wrote:False. I believe *THE* major character MUST be a power role.

Then we get back to whether Goku is ‘THE’ main character or not. Again – Gohan can just as easily be considered ‘THE’ main character.

Also – Was Ted Mosby a Powerrole in HIMYM Mafia?

Yates wrote:This isn't an outright falsehood but is fallacious in it's twisting of logic. IN THAT GAME, with that character list [which was weird to begin with] it absolutely made sense that Red Robin was a VT. Yes, Nightwing was also Robin at one point. As of that game, he was already a superhero in his own right, not Batman's sidekick. Granted, I gave you Damien and Stephanie because I don't know them.

Do you know DC Comics well? Because Red Robin is not some small secondary character. He’s the second most significant Robin in Batman’s history (to Nightwing who was the first Robin) and is a significant character in his own right. Much more so than either Damien Wayne or Stephanie Brown.

Yates wrote:This is a BS argument. I put all the roles out there for everyone else to make their own assumptions so I'm clearly not trying to hide anything.

Well you don’t address the points I made. Do you think those roles I mentioned made ‘flavor’ sense?

Yates wrote:That might be what YOU would do but it's not what *I* would do. The fact that he claimed Goku and has not been countered is reason enough to unvote regardless of how scummy I think he has been. It is absolutely possible for Town to act scummy and I'm not down with accidentally lynching a PR because he lied about that part of his reveal.

Well I can’t help that you would go through hoops in assuming a player is lying in claiming VT when they said “Whelp I’m VT lynch me today and Yates tomorrow it’s a good 1 v1”.

Yates wrote: Yeah. I clearly took the easy path. I don't know why Acosmist claimed so early or why he was acting like scum but I was obviously not the only one that saw how scummy he was being. So unless your argument is that I'm scum and my whole scum team jumped on the Acosmist wagon, this is bullshit.

Again – everyone else who got wagonned is acting like scum but you aren’t

Acosmist quite properly hit it on the head that he didn’t claim early so that’s not a valid point.

Why do you say I MUST think your whole team jumped on the Benmage wagon to think you were scum? Probably at least one is waffling on the subject like BK is doing …