Mini 1646: Quil's Smalltown (Game over!)

[farside22]

I had some concern with the idea of boo being Rolf to track vda from night 1.

What does this mean, please? Can you provide an example of it?

I do not know what you mean by this. I think it's autocorrect gone wild.

Are you saying you suspect my slot or Marquis's slot for the VDA suggestion, Farside?

It was auto correct gone wild.

I was saying I don't trust marquis for suggesting to track vda.

Not sure why you questioned my marquis steal or why you trust him.

[Bookitty]

Since this game began, Farside, you have been throwing shade at my slot for reasons I do not understand.

You were certain that Pine/BBMolla were going to steal your role and were pushing suspicions at them based on a theory that does not even make sense.

You seemed to be trying to preemptively undermine whatever results I would be able to give. You can understand how that would make me suspicious.

It's more process of elimination. I don't trust you and you're differing with him. That makes me trust him more.

What is the advantage of Marquis stealing my role, Farside? Can you explain how you see that playing out to the benefit of town, specifically?

[farside22]

Based on what is known.

Bb claimed block and no cc. Can't be sk or scum based on action
Jingle tracked night 1 by boo, went no where. Confirmed not sk, could be scum I doubt this.
Boo: I had aronis/boo scum team since day 1. Arnois flip makes me reasses reads.
Anti: tracked to reck. Asked reck to check him. If anti was a sk he would be happy to have innocent results from reck. Kill from sk makes no sense here.
Shi: said would block between reck and boo, based on deaths from night 2 more likely dead bg on boo.
Me: I'm town
Dv: gave shi bp, this would leave uphill battle doing so as either scum or sk.

POE leaves marquis and Flubber.

Marquis suggest tracking vda which doesn't help town

How him stealing helps town.

POE deteroriates if town based on what is known. If scum or sk by stealing from boo puts target on his back

[Bookitty]

At this point, Farside, it's too late to build trust between us. I tried earlier but eventually your obvious desire to get rid of my oh-so-valuable role did wear me down and I lost my townread on you.

I don't particularly care to put a target on someone else's back so you can throw darts at it in the same way you've done at me all game long.

It's up to Marquis. I trust him more than I trust you and I'm sure he'll do the right thing.

[farside22]

It was pretty hard to trust you boo while your defending arnois and calling him scummy in the same breath.

Just saying.

[farside22]

And bluntly put every olive branch you tried to offer to me came with what felt like poison

[Bookitty]

@Farside: Do you think that Marquis thinking VDA was a good investigation is significantly different than you thinking Reck Night One was a good investigation? Why or why not?

I tried, Farside, but you were confbiased from the very start and there was not anything I could do to shake it. There's no trust now, but when I did trust you as town you rewarded me by trying to get me lynched and trying to undermine my use of my role in every possible way that you could. You admittedly weren't paying good attention to the thread, but you were definitely sure I was scum just the same.

Ultimately I couldn't see a town reasoning behind what you were doing. It's fine, it's the way some games go, but I just don't think you're town.

[Jingle]

Reck was maf, shii was sk. That's pretty obvious though.

[Bookitty]

So Antihero is Mafia. Hmmm.

Okay, I'm good with going ahead with this. I've given my reads such as they are. We still have two kills tonight though.

I won't be around this evening (I have a previous engagement) but if I don't see you guys again til the end of the game, it's been delightful and I <3 you all, even Farside whom I suspect of being scum.

[farside22]

Boo: I don't want to argue with you. If you want to talk after the game about this or the dead thread I'll be happy to.
From my prospective all I felt was you attacking me from the word go about things that did not happen. I didn't consider role just who I was scum reading.

As for investigation. I didn't suspect jingle so that didn't really mean anything to me.
I was a bit suspicious of reck just for him saying he didn't check anyone. I just could not wrap my head around a player who says come get means doesn't use their role.

[Bookitty]

I'm not upset with you, Farside. I think you're scum of some variety, but I surely don't think you're a bad person and my feelings are not hurt. I still <3 you, but I don't trust you in this game anymore.

If you're town, then that's on me and I will own my mistake in post-game. I just don't think you are town in this game.

[farside22]

I'm not scum.

[Bookitty]

I don't think my opinion on this matters very much, Farside, since I doubt I'll be around to argue about it later.

What does matter is this, I think:

Since Reck was killed by scum and since I saw Antihero carry in the kill, we can say for sure that Antihero-Victor-???? are the scumteam. The SK is still out there and still has a bulletproof.

I'm certain BBMolla is town. I have DeasVail and Jingle as town too. Jingle in particular was instrumental in helping me figure out to look at last night and not the night before, so I am giving him a shiny badge emblazoned with towncred for that.

Flubbernugget's naked vote could be a buddy vote; it's not as though Antihero WASN'T going to be lynched.

I read over both Antihero and Victor and I guess I could kind of see Farside as a partner there; I'm just not really sure about that, though. The attempt to taunt the nightkill, though, doesn't seem like a thing the SK would do. (Remember when she was convinced Pine was after her shiny Invictus role? That would be weird if she were the SK.)

Marquis is pretty far down my suspicion list right now. I could be wrong, but he hasn't seemed like scum, especially not with Anti and Victor.

[DeasVail]

I love you all and will get to this when I can. <3

(Shii )

[Bookitty]

Congrats on your new status, DeasVail

I'm sad about Shii too, but either I'll have another investigation in the morning or I'll be in Mafia heaven with him.

I'm heading out now and I won't be around until much later and maybe not at all tonight. I don't mind if you lynch Anti in my absence since I'm sure he's scum and Jingle verified he's Mafia.

<3 <3 <3

[DeasVail]

Thanks Bookitty.

[Quilford]

• 
  
  Vote count 3.2
  
  
  Antihero (3)— Bookitty, farside22, Flubbernugget
  
  Not Voting (5)— Marquis, DeasVail, Jingle, BBmolla, Antihero
  
  It takes 5 to lynch and 4 to no lynch.
  
  
  Deadline
  
  
  Day 2 will be 8 days long. It ends in (expired on 2015-03-20 07:45:36).
  
  
  Mod notes
  
  
  I did this on my phone while addicting myself to
  How to Get Away with Murder
  ! Yeah!!!!

[Marquis]

i love you quilly

farside tracking vda could have gotten us notmafs by way of rb/kill target, but then molla claimed rb'd which i didn't expect for some reason and while i thought there was a good chance vda was the one to perform n1 kill, others thought it wasn't worth it

[Marquis]

quilly do u ship coliver

i ship it

[BBmolla]

hi

[BBmolla]

I stole Encrypt to try to get it sneak killed

But alas

[BBmolla]

I can't believe Reck was actually fucking town and just decided not to use it night 1 LOL

[Quilford]

quilly do u ship coliver

i ship it

IM ON S1 EP2 AND MAY NOT KNOW WHO EVERYONE IS YET

[Marquis]

I can't believe Reck was actually fucking town and just decided not to use it night 1 LOL

yeah i just couldn't get around that

are you mafia btw? not that you'd have much to talk with a partner about rn tbh

[Marquis]

quilly do u ship coliver

i ship it

IM ON S1 EP2 AND MAY NOT KNOW WHO EVERYONE IS YET

OK BUT ITS ADORABLE AND MY COMMENTS ARE NONSPOILERY