Newbie 1365 - Vantasmagoria of Flower View (Game Over)

[awestfie]

Man, I actually think you're town now, dang! I'm not actually JK.

UNVOTE: Nekoko

Let's just NL, screw it; it's better anyways.

[awestfie]

Anyways, why'd you check me, Nekoko?

[awestfie]

Oh, and I want to have everyone's reads before we do actually NL. If Nekoko is actually cop then Ms Marangal and I are clear, right?

[MontyWhittaker]

Uh? Thor and Monty have been online and posted elswhere during the night-phase (Just checked) meaning how would they forgot to send in a kill? This is really weird.

Sorry, but can someone explain again the benefits of not lynching?

[Tierce]

Votecount 3.1

(2)

Nekoko

-

(awestfie,)

Regfan, Ms Marangal

(4)

Not voting

-

(awestfie,)

MontyWhittaker,

(Ms Marangal,)

Nekoko,

(Regfan,)

Thor665, awestfie

With 6 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 30 at 10:25 AM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-30 10:25:00)

[Ms Marangal]

V/LA until tuesday

[Thor665]

Vote: No lynch

[Regfan]

Vote: No lynch

Man, I actually think you're town now, dang! I'm not actually JK.

You're a really bad person. And also this means mafia didn't submit a kill (Which makes no fucking sense).

Sorry, but can someone explain again the benefits of not lynching?

Right now it's 5-1 (That means we have two lynches to hit scum and win). By NLing it turns into 4-1 (That means we still have the same two lynches to hit scum and win in) however in that situation there's one less person to have to worry about; in situations with clears (Awestfie/Ms) that's not a gain however since we have a cop claim by NLing even if one of Awestfie/Ms die we attain a new clear (ie. Nekokos new report) or Nekoko dies in which case the suspect pool drops by one.

[awestfie]

Vote: No lynch

Man, I actually think you're town now, dang! I'm not actually JK.

You're a really bad person. And also this means mafia didn't submit a kill (Which makes no fucking sense).

Says you.

VOTE: No Lynch

[Regfan]

Unvote

There's something I want explained first, noticed this when I was doing some reading; Monty in Post 590 which is at the end of D1 you state that Irish has 'won back into your good graces' and that you want to look more closely at Thor and Nekoko yet in Post 716 which is first post of D2 you come out with a case against Irish in so what initially brought about the change of read towards him moving back into your good graces and what brought about the change back to a FoS on him? And did you ever go to look more closely at Thor/Nekoko (Try and run me through your actions and thought process at the start of D2 please).

[awestfie]

Hey Regfan, if Nekoko is indeed cop, who's mafia and why?

[Regfan]

Hey Regfan, if Nekoko is indeed cop, who's mafia and why?

That's something I'm trying to work out (I have town-reads on the both of Thor/Monty and am still finding it hard believing that scum forgot to send in a kill when both of them were posting elsewhere online at the time) but I don't want to waste too much time since if Nekoko is mafia then we'll know it by tomorrow.

[Tierce]

Votecount 3.2

(2)

No Lynch

- Thor665,

(Regfan,)

awestfie

(1)

Nekoko

-

(Regfan,)

Ms Marangal

(3)

Not voting

- MontyWhittaker, Nekoko,

(Thor665, awestfie,)

Regfan


Ms Marangal is V/LA until May 21.

With 6 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 30 at 10:25 AM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-30 10:25:00)

[MontyWhittaker]

Ah, I see.

VOTE: No Lynch

[MontyWhittaker]

Unvote

There's something I want explained first, noticed this when I was doing some reading; Monty in Post 590 which is at the end of D1 you state that Irish has 'won back into your good graces' and that you want to look more closely at Thor and Nekoko yet in Post 716 which is first post of D2 you come out with a case against Irish in so what initially brought about the change of read towards him moving back into your good graces and what brought about the change back to a FoS on him? And did you ever go to look more closely at Thor/Nekoko (Try and run me through your actions and thought process at the start of D2 please).

Yeah, certainly. Shawn's flip made me have to go back and reevaluate everyone. It was that simple.

I did, but at the time, there wasn't much to say. It was hard to determine a town/scum alignment either way. After tomorrow's actions, it should be simple to ascertain, but right now, I simply want to see what happens.

[Ms Marangal]

Still really don't want that no-lynch

[Thor665]

Why?

[Nekoko]

Anyways, why'd you check me, Nekoko?

I already said before that I suspected the scum team could be TheIrishPope X sycorax/mathdino/awstfie
and I already said scum is most likely in [TheIrishPope, sycorax, MontyWhittaker].

---

I also support no lynching. We'll have odd players again and scum would plan
whether to night kill me (so people who suspected me could find where the scum really is)
or to let me live and risk that I will investigate the real scum and win the game

[Ms Marangal]

The Idea of it really, really makes my skin crawl and with a no lynch, we go into tomorrow with possibly 4 conf. town and two non-conf. town who of which we lynch

or a cop, or a conf. town is killed during the night in which we start tomorrow with 2 conf. town and 2 non. conf town

or, we go into tomorrow with 3 conf. town and on conf. scum

with no chance of tagging scum

with a lynch, we will go into tomorrow with

4 possible conf. town, and one non-confirmed townie of whom we lynch

3 possible conf. town, and conf. scum of whom we lynch

or we lose cop/conf. town during the night go into tomorrow with 2 conf. town and have 2 plausible scumspects

but that's only assuming if we don't tag scum today, and we won't have a chance of tagging scum if we do a no-lynch

I think scum is in Regfan or Monty, I want to go with Monty because he was an earlier read and Reg can easily be a paranoia read

[awestfie]

Well, no lynching is optimal today, Ms Marangal; there's literally no reasons why we shouldn't do it. If Nekoko is indeed cop, then she should be dying the next night, because there's a 1/3 chance she'll be getting a guilty report and even if she is fake, then it's auto-win for the town; if she dies, then we'll have a clear for both remaining days, assuming we lynch incorrectly. We're in an incredibly good spot and I don't see us losing this at this point; assuming that we NL today.

[Tierce]

Votecount 3.3

(3)

No Lynch

- Thor665, awestfie, MontyWhittaker

(1)

Nekoko

- Ms Marangal

(2)

Not voting

-

(MontyWhittaker,)

Nekoko, Regfan


Ms Marangal is V/LA until May 21.

With 6 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 30 at 10:25 AM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-30 10:25:00)

[Thor665]

@MM - we have three suspects.
We have two lynches whether we no lynch or lynch.
We have +1 player that scum will need to fool if we no lynch.

Make sense?

[Tierce]

Votecount 3.4

(3)

No Lynch

- Thor665, awestfie, MontyWhittaker

(1)

Nekoko

- Ms Marangal

(2)

Not voting

- Nekoko, Regfan


Ms Marangal is V/LA until May 21.

With 6 alive, it takes 4 votes to lynch.
The deadline is May 30 at 10:25 AM PDT. Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2013-05-30 10:25:00)

[awestfie]

Eh, this is going slowly, Regfan; maybe you should just NL and see what happens? I know you're trying to figure things out today, but; no one's really willing to do much today for some reason.

[Regfan]

Yeah, unfortunately seems that way.

Vote: No lynch