Mini 1646: Quil's Smalltown (Game over!)

[Quilford]

quilly do u ship coliver

i ship it

IM ON S1 EP2 AND MAY NOT KNOW WHO EVERYONE IS YET

OK BUT ITS ADORABLE AND MY COMMENTS ARE NONSPOILERY

OH so I didn't know that Oliver was called Oliver yet

YES I SHIP THAT. I SHIP IT WITH A TRACKING NUMBER

[Quilford]

and the tracking number is 15H1PTH1550H4RD

[Quilford]

Anyway back to mafia now folks kthx

[DeasVail]

Hmmmm, should I try watching it? I'm not very good at staying entertained by TV shows though.

[DeasVail]

I don't see much reason to do reads things at this time, so I'll remain quiet. My preference would be that Marquis/Bookitty leave it unclear as to what their actions will be. It is obviously possible that one of them is mafia, but in the reasonably likely (imo) chance that both of them are town, I would rather scum not know what occurs until after the night is done.

Other than that, I see no reason not to lynch Antihero! I'll hold off from voting just because, but eventually I'm probably going to get impatient.

[DeasVail]

Oh but despite what preferences I may have, it is of course up to those with whatever role they have to decide how best to use it. I have inner control-freak tendencies, my apologies.

[Bookitty]

My preference would be that Marquis/Bookitty leave it unclear as to what their actions will be. It is obviously possible that one of them is mafia, but in the reasonably likely (imo) chance that both of them are town, I would rather scum not know what occurs until after the night is done.

I support and endorse this product and/or service.

I'm fine with the vote happening whenever. I've said my piece

[farside22]

i love you quilly

farside tracking vda could have gotten us notmafs by way of rb/kill target, but then molla claimed rb'd which i didn't expect for some reason and while i thought there was a good chance vda was the one to perform n1 kill, others thought it wasn't worth it

I don't see how the info helps town narrow the pool and with less people to check, net higher results for finding sk or scum.

[Jingle]

I'm still prokeeping every fucking action hidden forever and ever.

Anti, claim your kills, because they might help us murder some SK. And the longer we worry about the SK, the more likely your buddy is to escape notice.

[Jingle]

Also

VOTE: Antihero

[Antihero]

you're the sk, jingle. already figured that out.

VOTE: antihero

so long, suckers

[Bookitty]

Well, Jingle isn't the SK. I tracked him night one and he went nowhere.

So that was unhelpful.

Bye, Anti!

[Marquis]

WAIT JINGLE WHO KILLED WHO

[Bookitty]

Reck was maf, shii was sk. That's pretty obvious though.

Why, what's up, Marquis?

[Bookitty]

Per Jingle, Reck was the Mafia kill. Per me, Antihero visited Reck.

So Antihero is Mafia.

The SK killed Shiidaji by 1) aiming at me when Shii protected me; 2) aiming at Reck when Shii protected him or 3) aiming at Shii directly. I don't know how we can know which thing exactly happened though.

[Quilford]

• 
  
  Vote count 3.3
  
  
  >>>
  Antihero (5)— Bookitty, farside22, Flubbernugget, Jingle, Antihero
  <<<
  
  Not Voting (3)— Marquis, DeasVail, BBmolla
  
  It takes 5 to lynch and 4 to no lynch.
  
  
  Deadline
  
  
  A lynch has been achieved before deadline.
  
  
  Mod notes
  
  
  Flip incoming.

[Quilford]

• 
  
  >>>

  Antihero,

  member of the Mafia

  , lynched Day 3!

  <<<
  
  
  
  It is now Night 3.
  
  Night ends in (expired on 2015-03-15 22:59:56). Please note that this is a shorter Night compared to the last two.

[Quilford]

• 
  
  >>>

  Bookitty,

  member of the Town

  , killed Night 2!

  <<<
  
  
  >>>

  Jingle,

  member of the Town

  , killed Night 2!

  <<<
  
  
  
  It is now Day 4.
  
  Five players remain.
  Marquis, the Gentleman Thief has stolen the role of Flubbernugget, the Vengeful Vanilliser.

[Quilford]

• 
  
  Vote count 4.1
  
  
  Not Voting (5)— Marquis, DeasVail, farside22, BBmolla, Flubbernugget
  
  It takes 3 to lynch or no lynch.
  
  
  Deadline
  
  
  Day 4 will be 7 days long. It ends in (expired on 2015-03-23 05:30:53).
  
  
  Mod notes
  
  
  Best of luck to all factions during Day 4.

[farside22]

Bb is pretty much my strongest town read based on what is known.
I think dv is town, I had a paranoid moment about him as a sk but I'm going to bottle it up and see what he had to say.

Flubber and marquis are the ones I question the most.
Flubber has been all but invisible.
Marquis wanting to track dead scum really read as trying to mislead town to do useless busy work

[DeasVail]

Life is getting pretty crazy for me, so I don't know when I'll get to this, but I hope it will be soon.

[Marquis]

last night i realized i was townreading pretty much everyone left except flubber so i figured it'd be best to take away the vengeful to lynch him instead of gambling on one of my townreads

i expected boo to die but i thought if i stole the archivist, it wouldn't help, since if flubber was scum he'd vanillaize me anyway, or i'd just get nightkilled for having it

VOTE: flubber

i'll try to analyze mafia associatives later. i have no idea how to figure out who sk is so i'm kinda just hoping it's flubber right now.

also farside that was also explained earlier; i wasn't thinking straight about the odds and wanted to see who he killed- either clear not-mafia, or he targeted the sk if it didn't align with any claimed protectives

[BBmolla]

fuck I don't know

[BBmolla]

Flubb is probably scum though yeah

We should talk a bit more but that's probably where my vote'll end up

[DeasVail]

I remember thinking Flubber was town, but I also remember thinking that about everyone here except for Farside, and it's been ages since I last updated my reads, so this is happening now, right now!

First I want to talk about BBmolla because for some reason I was thinking about him as I went to sleep last night (not in the way you're thinking though, relax Molla) and I found myself really uncomfortable with all the people calling him so unquestionably town, probably because the paranoid part of me wants to lynch everyone or something. I had theories running through my mind of Victor and Molla being scum together and Victor roleblocking Molla being some big distancing act, but I actually ended up deciding that perhaps Molla is unquestionably town! Serial killer is very likely out, just because I'm pretty sure he actually was roleblocked by Victor, or at least would have used his gentleman thief role if he wasn't roleblocked. As for mafia, I actually considered that very possible, but then I realised that a mafia team of Antihero + BBmolla would not get Antihero to make the kill with Bookitty pretty obviously not tracking Molla. So this, along with the admittedly far-fetched nature of any Victor+Molla theories, throws mafia out the window for me. And, as much as I would like Molla to be some kind of unannounced werewolf role to satisfy my 'everyone is scum!' feelings, I will hold back from lynching him. So here you have had the unnecessarily long story of how I came to realise what you all probably already have realised, but just in case either of our scummy friends are as dense as I am and thinking he's the other scummy friend, I can tell you that he's probably not, so don't shoot him.

Unfortunately though, my late-night insights were limited to Molla and Molla only, so time to work on the others!

-

I did do some thinking about Marquis today though (I swear I'm not normally this mafia-obsessed), and despite liking his play here a lot, I really considered SK as a possibility here and still don't think he's mafia, but I'm about to read his posts and my opinion could completely change, so I guess we'll all see what happens!

7 is interesting because it specifically mentions wanting Anti as BP. I think it's yet another sign of not-mafia from Marquis though, because with being so far down the list along with BP actually being a useful role, there was pretty much no way Anti was going to get BP, so in Marquis' mind I believe that this would have attracted unnecessary attention to their connection if scum. Doesn't really have any impact on likelihood of SK imo though.

I've thought about it, and I also think that picking encryptor is another thing suggestive of not-mafia. I'm worried that it's my own biases coming into play here (I generally value scum daytalk less than the average person would), but I don't believe making it the first pick would be worth the likely attention received, even with his town reasoning for it. I was also thinking that this would be perfect for SK because it makes sense as a first town pick while also giving scum no reason to kill him, but I'm questioning that now. There's a pretty decent risk of him getting lynched if people take his pick the wrong way, and I'm not sure if the SK would risk that?

Oh 11 is also super weird from an SK actually.

Ok I'm quickly losing interest in Marquis being any kind of scum, which is weird because it very probably means that it's Farside and flubber, but that feels too easy?

I had grand plans of tryharding this now that I'm apparently paragon and everything, but after quick skims of Flubber and Farside's ISOs I really don't think I'm going to end up considering them as town as Marquis and Molla. Maybe my Marquis-town feelings are too strong, but I do feel pretty strongly about them right now. I've also still got lots of RL stuff to do so I'll probably be lazy and leave it at 'I'm ok with either Flubber or Farside' for now. I may check back in tonight though and see if I feel up to exploring things more.