Mafiascum.net

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 4:31 pm**

↑ itlepip wrote:All of that assumes Kling is town which you still haven't made a real argument for.

itlepip

, Show any real argument for me being Scum.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 4:32 pm**

↑ inte wrote:ok i got up to page 15 before i said fuck it

whats the rundown and whos town?

^ ^ ^
This could be lynched for lurking.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 4:34 pm**

↑ Passionate Storm wrote:
Klingoncelt
Passionate Storm is scum. That is all.

ftfy

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 4:42 pm**

Spoiler: all my bella posts (which there are a lot of)

↑ itlepip wrote:KLING FOR THE THIRD TIME, READS! I'm about the change votes again if you keep ignoring me and I already hit my quota today.

Pedit: yeah I'll unvote when you get reads then

VOTE: Celt

Pedit 2: have none of those reads changed in all of the pages since you made them?

↑ itlepip wrote:I am feeling pretty cold about the Eagle wagon, he actually feels like the easy mislynch today for me. His posts have a noob quality to them, but I think at least for right now it is more noob town. I think that he thinks that the gambit was much more risky than it actually was, and so it was towny cause of that. Elyse's last post reads soo scummy to me... If you think he is scum you should go balls to the wall automatically, not just if other people are okay with that lynch. Klingon needs to really start defending herself before I unvote though.

↑ itlepip wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
↑ Garmr wrote:I still want to see more reactions from klingy as it would probably bring some clarity to the people revolving around her and herself.

A wagon building fast so early in the game is built by Scum. Simple as that.

When did this become a thing? Cause I don't see what scum gains from it.

↑ itlepip wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
↑ Spifflop wrote:whos the scum on your wagon, kling?

Passionate Storm and itlepip for sure,

maybe you, AJ, &/or Elyse (Elyse is not looking like solid town right now.)

Aneninen, I never could read him, so maybe. The Cotilde thing is creepy btw.

So everyone on your wagon....

↑ itlepip wrote:The difference is that Eagle is clearly town and Klingon isn't. Eagle is posting stuff, some of it is wrong, but as someone who does this the brain throw up on the thread is easy to read. Eagle is actually pretty high on my town list right now. Kling on the other hand still hasn't done anything that I know of that I can town read, but a lot that I can scum read. I feel like Eagle's read on Klingon is sympathy instead of analysis. I personally have no problem picking on people new to the site if I am trying to get a certain reaction, but with Eagle I have already gotten that reaction so there is no need.

Pedit: Okay, Elyse can go over your opinions on the controversial figures (grape, Kling, EE, Titus). The problem with kling is that she still hasn't responded to our accusations 300 posts ago. I originally voted to get a response, and when she talked about tangential stuff instead of about our questions my vote became a real read.

Pedit 2:um 273, all 3 of us agreed that your arguments were incorrect there.

↑ itlepip wrote:No, but if Kling can't make an argument that isn't meta and the consensus of people who know the meta is that the meta makes kling scum, I think kling is scum.

Pedit: Explain how it isn't fishing instead of attack Varsoon please.

↑ itlepip wrote:Lol wut, what reads????

↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
↑ Passionate Storm wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:

I'm doing my usual as Town, whether you like it or not. Reads come as I get them.

So your only reads are AJ town and us scum? Really? Nothing on grapes Alch ee? Spiffeh? Elyse?

I posted a read on Grapes.

I want to re-read Elyse and Spiffeh.
Alchemist, Anen, PereV, and Hiplop I always have trouble reading.

Extrapolated Eagle, Randomidget, Spider Gwen I don't know, they'll be harder to figure out.

^Everyone in null "hey guys I posted a readlist so get off my back pls"....

↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
↑ itlepip wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:

I can drop a vote on Jeanne in a New York minute, but it's very hard for me to vote for Titus on Day1. Don't worry, I'll get around to it.

do you have any other reads?

Yeah, but first:

I was waiting for a game to be not ongoing. The Day lasted exactly 11 posts, shortest Day I've ever seen here at MS, and Titus was lynched. Not her fault really, she replaced into a Scum slot. But anyway, I just felt heartless throwing a vote on her. The hydra's posts since my FoS, however, haven't done jack to make them look Towny.

So,

VOTE: Passionate Storm

Other reads:

I'm bugged by Grapes' thing. Is he buddying me? Maybe, but I think he's setting up mislynches, as in, "Oh look, those guys all called poor Klingon Scum but she flipped Town -
they
must be Scum!!"

Even though she's wrong about me, I think Auntie J's sweet.

Mo' better reads will come as this Day progresses.

So grapes is a scum-lean and Titus is scum. Can you give any evidence for either of these, cause you haven't. For someone who doesn't like defending themselves you sure did it a lot today. You haven't even tried to scumhunt, nor have you posted any reads. You are misrepping what happened earlier this game and making generalizations. I might even lynch you through a claim you are that scummy.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 4:49 pm**

↑ Aneninen wrote:

↑ Klingoncelt wrote:The Clotilde thing is driving me up a wall too.

Cool townies are willing to be Clotild. It's very "in" nowadays.

If you say so...

↑ Aneninen wrote:

↑ Klingoncelt wrote:Titus' play was very strange. (So was Wgeurts' and LQ's.)

Why was the part in brackets important?

One person playing strangely in a game messes up the dynamic a bit, but when 3 players do it the game can get very confusing.

↑ Aneninen wrote:
Klingonette, 790 Was that a readlist?

848 is a more complete one.

More coming tonight.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 4:55 pm**

↑ Aneninen wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:And I wasn't rolefishing. I don't give a fuck about your role.
Alignment, now that's another story. I'm hoping you're Town.

Oh shyt, you DO give a f-ck. You give a lot of f-ck.
You really want to know who Varsoon is and you really want to know who I am.

Varsoon is Luke Skywalker and he will never go to the Dark Side, so Varsoon's Town and that's all that matters. I truly do not a single fuck give about his role.

As for you, bucko, I'm not the one that's dangling Clotilde in front of everyone. I want to know who she is, not what you are.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 5:06 pm**

@itlepip

, your 928 wall is a bunch of quotes. The first one was a phony "third time" demand for my reads, when I hadn't yet had the time to respond to your first demand.

The rest is a bunch of tl;dr.

You do not have a case on me. Admit it.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 5:11 pm**

↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
@itlepip
, your 928 wall is a bunch of quotes. The first one was a phony "third time" demand for my reads, when I hadn't yet had the time to respond to your first demand.

The rest is a bunch of tl;dr.

You do not have a case on me. Admit it.

I am not trying to convince you that you are scum, your opinion is meaningless here. I have made points about certain posts you have made that you are refusing to acknowledge, but you have never even attempted to defend yourself this game with anything other than meta, so I've given up on you not being scummy.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 5:19 pm**

↑ T S O wrote:
↑ Dapper Stranger wrote:
↑ T S O wrote:Sometimes the method in which Elyse posts reminds me so heavily of YCBA III where she was scum, but then other times there are fantastic posts which convince me she's town. As well as that, I like everything she's saying. I find it unlikely that she is bussing, so either she's town or she's scum and my reads are completely off as well.

I cannot remember the last time my reads were completely off, so I'm going to assume it's not the case here either.

A man is remembering YCBA3 until late game.

I was unlucky with the speedlynch I created d1, and was blinded d2 by Peregrine's remarkable scumminess, as was AJ and anyone else with a working brain.
The day 3 Elyse-scum lynch was all me
, you got Guiltied d4, and the day 5 massive-scum lynch was, again, all me.

I only regret the d1 speedlynch. Nothing else.

Nah uh my bus convinced more people to join the wagon. You can say you were the townie with the most persuasive case

but not the one with the most persuasive case

.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 5:35 pm**

@tso

I have been a big part at arguing with eagle yet you haven't mentioned me once or gave a thought on me. Some of your quotes your commenting on are replies to me. I'm curious why your leaving that part out if your interested in eagle. Eagle shows his scummiest side when arguing with me?

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 5:49 pm**

↑ itlepip wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
@itlepip
, your 928 wall is a bunch of quotes. The first one was a phony "third time" demand for my reads, when I hadn't yet had the time to respond to your first demand.

The rest is a bunch of tl;dr.

You do not have a case on me. Admit it.

I am not trying to convince you that you are scum, your opinion is meaningless here. I have made points about certain posts you have made that you are refusing to acknowledge, but you have never even attempted to defend yourself this game with anything other than meta, so I've given up on you not being scummy.

*smh*

That's lame.

As Town there's no way to defend myself other than by meta and by saying that I'm not Scum.

(Unless the Mod wants to pop in and confirm me as town, but I don't see that happening.)

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 7:01 pm**

↑ hiplop wrote:
death in family might be a little more absent than usual for a few days. will try to still post if i can

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 7:05 pm**

Sorry for your loss hiplop

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 7:21 pm**

↑ Spifflop wrote:
↑ hiplop wrote:
death in family might be a little more absent than usual for a few days. will try to still post if i can

My condolences, Hiplop.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 7:56 pm**

↑ T S O wrote:I've been finding it rather scummy in this game, actually.

Nah you are wrong this time if you think so.

Btw people I really think we should lynch alchemist.
I cannot sake the feeling that the post that called out Aneninen was the worst thing that has happened in the game.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 7:57 pm**

My condolences from here as well hiplop : (

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 8:11 pm**

↑ Klingoncelt wrote:
↑ Aneninen wrote:
↑ Klingoncelt wrote:And I wasn't rolefishing. I don't give a fuck about your role.
Alignment, now that's another story. I'm hoping you're Town.

Oh shyt, you DO give a f-ck. You give a lot of f-ck.
You really want to know who Varsoon is and you really want to know who I am.

Varsoon is Luke Skywalker and he will never go to the Dark Side, so Varsoon's Town and that's all that matters. I truly do not a single fuck give about his role.

As for you, bucko, I'm not the one that's dangling Clotilde in front of everyone. I want to know who she is, not what you are.

How do you know Varsoon's Flavor?

Second, God was scum in YCBA2

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 8:12 pm**

↑ Spifflop wrote:
↑ hiplop wrote:
death in family might be a little more absent than usual for a few days. will try to still post if i can

Sorry for your loss.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 8:47 pm**

↑ Titus wrote:How do you know Varsoon's Flavor?

Well he was only a little . Less discrete about it than me tbh.

Could he be faking it? Sure but his references are all over the place

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 8:50 pm**

↑ Titus wrote:
How do you know Varsoon's Flavor?

He's been dropping hints like anvils off a rooftop.

Second, God was scum in YCBA2

I'm a witch, so...

Plus I don't think I played YCBA2.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 9:19 pm**

I'm sorry for your loss hiplop.
@alch readslist coming tonight.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 9:47 pm**

↑ Aunt Jemina wrote:
↑ Dapper Stranger wrote: Elly is facing the flame and is sweating most profusely. Spitflop, like everyone else, is knowing this is just so. Spitflop is taking the opportunity to derail any attention from Elly onto Celty.
I refuse to consider any scenario in which Spiffyloppy is sour, sorry.

Regardless of your alignment, you are therefore wrong. The question is whether this is you as a sweet player with an honest albeit inaccurate view, or scum who thinks pressing this is a good idea.

I have yet to form a definitive conclusion.

↑ T S O wrote:Sometimes the method in which Elyse posts reminds me so heavily of YCBA III where she was scum, but then other times there are fantastic posts which convince me she's town. As well as that, I like everything she's saying. I find it unlikely that she is bussing, so either she's town or she's scum and my reads are completely off as well.
This is promising for you, deary. Your prior posting was not leaving an impression on me either way, but this looks sweet.

Unless a lady is masons with or a day cop who is investigating that one already you are either closing doors which should be left open or are scum with. Spifflop's ISO is chopped full of evidence of their scummitude.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 10:35 pm**

Finished reads list:

Alchemist21

- He's one of the players on this site that I can't read. Can't Read

Aneninen

- He's one of the players on this site that I can't read. This game... He's kinda goofy. Not alignment indicative, though. The Clotilde thing... wtf. Can't Read

Garmr

- Another one that I can't read, ever. Can't Read

Errantparabola

- Very much in the game, paying attention... Town

Extrapolated Eagle

- Gawd I hate wallposts. Lots and lots of them... my eyes have blisters. Guys, if the Eagle is Scum, then he deserves some kind of special award, like Best Bullshitter in the Universe or something. Town

Shiro

- A lot of lightweight posts, but my gut says Town

Spider Gwen

- Hmm, so Passionate Storm made up stuff about her as well. PS is Scum. But this is Spider's spot, and Spider is very involved in the game. Very Town

Varsoon

- The Jedi is Town

Dapper Stranger(Fresh & Jaqen hydra)

- Looks like Fresh is having trouble using Jaqenspeak. Anyhoo, they're paying attention. A bit fixated on SpiderGwen, but...Lean Town

I Am Innocent

- Got off to a good start, then vanished. Bets this one gets replaced. Anyway, the slot is Lean Town

My Other Head Is Scum(Vedith & FireBringer hydra)

- Not a heavy saturation of content, I'd like to see more from a hydra. That said, they aren't saying anything scummy-looking. Lean Town

TSO

- He's active and paying attention. Too bad his reads don't agree with mine, but Lean Town

Grapes

- I'm not sure what to think. Null

Randomidget

- Not much there, I need to see more. Null

Spifflop(Spiffeh & Hiplop hydra)

- The posting style looks like way too much Red Bull was consumed. Their reads differ from mine... I think they're knee-jerking reactions. Null

TheWayItEnds

- Why do people sign up for games and then not post anything useful? Null.

Aunt Jemina

- C'mon, AJ is always Town, isn't she? Isn't she? It bugs me that she jumped on my FoS post, but w/e. It bugs me much more that after I explained my hesitation to vote Titus, AJ made no comment towards me, nor did she remove her vote. Until very recently I was the usual Day1 low-hanging fruit lynch, I wonder if she's just going for the easy mislynch. Lean Scum

Elyse

- Happy to finally be in a game without RC, but she acts like a basket case regardless. Her posts are full of busywork, but I'm not seeing any depth. She bounces her votes with little clarification: Garmr, Aneninen, Extrapolated Eagle, Klingoncelt, Extrapolated Eagle, Klingoncelt. Scum

Inte

- 3 posts, the final one bitching about the number of pages. Scum.

Itlepip

- That he demanded reads from me 3 times before I had the chance to read his first demand shows impatience. But when I look at his other posts I see more. I see a condescending attitude, no real content in the posts, yet an expectation that Town should work with him. Scum.

Passionate Storm(Jeanne11 & Titus hydra)

- GreyGreen is the color of snot, of pond scum, of the slime that clings to cellar walls in Old South bayou mansions, of the fuzzy lichen that grows on the limestone markers of Revolutionary War dead in old, forgotten graveyards...
135 shows that their vote on me is purely opportunistic - sheeping Auntie J to keep her vote off themselves.
The ISO tells a story much like Itlepip's: the hydra isn't working with Town. They're trying to stay on AJ's good side, but are otherwise talking

at

other players, going so far as to threaten those that disagree with the hydra. Scum

PeregrineV

- 5 posts. 1 is a confirming, 3 are promises to read. I thought PV was a better player than this. Scum

Discuss.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 10:40 pm**

Klingonette.

This seems to be off, but answer the question.

You're alone on a planet and come across me, a Romulan, alongside a Borg temporary disconnected from the Collective. You know that I'm able to "dissimilate" him and if I'm successful you may get back a long lost member of your crew. Your ship is available for beaming up but there's noone there (nor nearby) who could perform a successful "dissimilation". I'm severly injured, being me up may or may not kill me. You have a medkit. The Borg is obviously after me, and you don't know how long it takes to them to get me.

What are you doing?

(A) You kill me, no Romulan can be trusted and take the Borg with you. Something could be done to him in the near future.
(B) You kill both of us because it's a trap.
(C) You beam both of us up. It is worth the risk.
(D) You try to heal me on the spot, hoping there will be enough time for that.
(E) You ask for reinforcement and prepare for a groundfight.
(F) You ask for an away team consists of a doctor and a scientist. The doctor heals me, the scientists examines the Borg. If the Borg arrives you engage them to buy some time for all of us.
(G) You ask for a bigger away team to make it sure that I can be beamed up. Then you make me "dissimilate" the Borg and ask for ransom from the Romulan Empire.
(H) You beam me up. If I'm still alive you beam up the Borg too. If not, you leave him there.
(I) You kill the Borg because he's a traitor and leave me there.
(J) You leave without doing anything.

Posted: **Thu Dec 10, 2015 10:42 pm**

↑ Spifflop wrote:
↑ hiplop wrote:
death in family might be a little more absent than usual for a few days. will try to still post if i can

I am sorry for your loss I send my best wishes.

Mafiascum.net

You could be Anyone IV - GAME OVER