Mafiascum.net

Why are you town CC?

I have gone through her ISO in this game 7 or 8 times now. Every time my conclusion is that these are transparent scumposts with nothing redeeming about them. And yet she still has half the field calling her town for no reason. I don't understand it, it's painful for me, it makes me frustrated and angry, I kinda feel like people are refusing this because they just want to stick it to me even if they know that what I'm saying is true.

In post 925, YukzYuk wrote:Why are you town CC?

bad question.

shoshin does not look like scum to me. It makes sense for her to scumread me since she only has a single game with me where i was scum, so she doesnt know better and thinks she sees scum me everywhere. I suppose she could try and imitate that as scum, but eh

In post 928, Wisdom wrote:shoshin does not look like scum to me. It makes sense for her to scumread me since she only has a single game with me where i was scum, so she doesnt know better and thinks she sees scum me everywhere. I suppose she could try and imitate that as scum, but eh

You two scumbuddies then, is that what's up?

The only way I'm going to be okay with sheeping a nullread is if you are willing to take a BoP.

And even then I'm not sure if I'm okay with that.

In post 930, YukzYuk wrote:The only way I'm going to be okay with sheeping a nullread is if you are willing to take a BoP.

And even then I'm not sure if I'm okay with that.

Sure. BoP me on Shoshin flip.

there is literally no chance in hell she makes about 15 of the posts that she has made this game as town. and that should be obvious to anyone who knows her beyond a superficial level.

CC who else in this lobby do you think can read Shoshin other than you?

In post 933, YukzYuk wrote:CC who else in this lobby do you think can read Shoshin other than you?

???????????

i dunno

who else is scumreading her?

take the set of all players and subtract the players town or nullreading her. those people can read her.

but i suppose sheep rc is a more enjoyable game than mafia around here as per usual, so eh

if i had my way id obv baton nacho and kill in {yukzuk, s_s, gameplay, danflor, pmysterious}

In post 936, Wisdom wrote:but i suppose sheep rc is a more enjoyable game than mafia around here as per usual, so eh

if i had my way id obv baton nacho and kill in {yukzuk, s_s, gameplay, danflor, pmysterious}

Are you townreading nacho?

In post 929, Celestial Coordinates wrote:

In post 928, Wisdom wrote:shoshin does not look like scum to me. It makes sense for her to scumread me since she only has a single game with me where i was scum, so she doesnt know better and thinks she sees scum me everywhere. I suppose she could try and imitate that as scum, but eh

You two scumbuddies then, is that what's up?

I haven’t even read the bloody 37 pages of the game yet, but do you think scumbuddies defend each other like that?
-Bill

why wouldn't they

shoshin/yukzuk probably has more scum equity than shoshin/Ceph

am i even playing mafia anymore?

In post 940, Gay Dance Gone Wrong wrote:shoshin/yukzuk probably has more scum equity than shoshin/Ceph

i don't even know about ceph

like i just wanted him to fucking respond

this game has already made me tremendously unhappy. i knew as of before last game i hated mafia. i hated last game. why am i here

I can't read Shoshin. I've misread her both times I've played with her. So it's very possible I'm wrong on my initial town read.

Ceph's response to RC's case was bad but not scummy bad, just like bad bad. I'm still pretty null on him.

In post 943, Celestial Coordinates wrote:this game has already made me tremendously unhappy. i knew as of before last game i hated mafia. i hated last game. why am i here

take a break from the thread

the day just started

wait and see how shoshin/others respond?

In post 939, Dannflor wrote:why wouldn't they

One townreading the other and the other scumreading them?
Not really; they link each other too much in too many annoying ways. They’re both obliged to carry through their reads and have legitimate-sounding reasons for changing them, and they have to remember the read, so to speak, and keep following through with it. No real reason for them to.

Although that’s in general; in this case Wisdom’s defense of Shoshin sounds like it’s very... weak and changeable, really, which is what scumbuddies like between them: flexibility.
-Graeme

In post 945, Dannflor wrote:

In post 943, Celestial Coordinates wrote:this game has already made me tremendously unhappy. i knew as of before last game i hated mafia. i hated last game. why am i here

take a break from the thread

the day just started

wait and see how shoshin/others respond?

The day just started and there's already been so much 'fuck this shit bc it comes from RC' from the game thread.
Also I'm pretty sure if I just leave the game for a day Shoshin will get us lynched and everyone will still think Shoshin was town.

In post 940, Gay Dance Gone Wrong wrote:shoshin/yukzuk probably has more scum equity than shoshin/Ceph

I agree with this currently.

There was a weird interaction earlier:

In post 574, YukzYuk wrote:

In post 566, Shoshin wrote:I'd propose Wisdom/Goodies at the moment.

I'm okay with this.

@S_S because this is more productive than what was happening before.

In post 580, Shoshin wrote:I'm going to say everyone who agreed with killing Wisdom/Goodies is town.

It was a blanket statement but the YukzYuk part stuck out to me because they haven't really done anything I'd consider town indicative. I found it odd Shoshin would give them a town read just for that.

Besides CC and Nacho, are there any other baton candidates at this point? Why are people still voting for S_S?