Mafiascum.net

its worth noting that scum!midway consists of iioa, active lurking, and fluff. he takes a back seat.

Here is what I have so far for people who are least likely to be teamed at this point:

VP/votato
VP/Puppy
Gamma/R2R
Blair/Atarashi
Atarashi/Puppy

So based JUST OFF THIS. The most strongly TR people should be:

VP
Puppy
Atarashi

But we haven't seen Atarashi post in a while...

I wouldn't call Votato a hard townread, but I am not scumreading him. I wish he would be a bit more vocal in his scumhunting, but he does not appear to be steering an agenda in the thread.

In post 923, Quick wrote:Also, votato cannot be Scum with Puppy

In post 924, Quick wrote:ASSUMING R2R is Scum means Gamma is NOT Scum and vice versa.

It's worth noting here that both of these actually fit my solve.

In post 926, Quick wrote:VP/votato
VP/Puppy
Gamma/R2R
Blair/Atarashi
Atarashi/Puppy

This also fits my solve.

You should vote Gamma with me.

In post 925, votato wrote:its worth noting that scum!midway consists of iioa, active lurking, and fluff. he takes a back seat.

that is not my scum meta. That was my first game on the site btw. My scum game is not that obvious anymore

In post 929, Blair wrote:

In post 926, Quick wrote:VP/votato
VP/Puppy
Gamma/R2R
Blair/Atarashi
Atarashi/Puppy

This also fits my solve.

You should vote Gamma with me.

I would but I am not SRing Gamma. Also, I don't have that as SvT, but just Not SvS.

In post 930, midwaybear wrote:

In post 925, votato wrote:its worth noting that scum!midway consists of iioa, active lurking, and fluff. he takes a back seat.

that is not my scum meta. That was my first game on the site btw. My scum game is not that obvious anymore

which you know because youre currently scum?

In post 931, Quick wrote:I would but I am not SRing Gamma.

Care to review this exchange?

686 694 697

I keep asking people for thoughts on that.

no

In post 919, Quick wrote:

In post 917, votato wrote:

In post 916, Quick wrote:I think the wagons should be between votato and R2R tbqh.

VOTE: votato

why is that your lynchpool? why do you prefer me over r2r?

I think there are people who want to spill your blood. I also think there are people who want to spill R2R's blood. I currently have R2R above you. That's why I am voting you. That and the fact that there are already some people voting for R2R and I want to help facilitate the wagons here.

mav's switch from votato to R2R seems a bit short sighted and I have previously thought mav to be a critical thinker. So this puzzles me.

Thanks for the compliment haha.
Votato is the one person I’ve been swinging wildly on since the NPOM town flip. I go from thinking he’s DEFINITELY scum with R2R to think he’s DEFINITELY town. So expect more, but currently I’m on the he’s DEFINITELY town part of the pendulum.

@Blair: R2R is absent from your possible pairings list. Looking through your posts, I don’t actually see a case on why you believe him to be town or explain a town read? (Full disclosure: when I say “looking through” your posts what I mean is skimming through them as there are A LOT.)

In post 934, midwaybear wrote:no

ok, midway, enough coasting for you. you have a total of 6 posts, and 0 content so far. what are your scum reads? what are your town reads? what did you think of the wagons and lynch yesterday? are you gonna vote today?

I don't have any strong pairings with R2R. He could be scum, but not with that solve.

P-edit: @Mavs

In post 933, Blair wrote:

In post 931, Quick wrote:I would but I am not SRing Gamma.

Care to review this exchange?

686 694 697

I keep asking people for thoughts on that.

Yeah, this all means pretty much nothing considering Gamma wasn't on the NPOM lynch. Also, Gamma comes out of that looking better than you.

Gamma's reasons for staying off the lynch are irrelevant because he was off the lynch?

I'm really trying to communicate with you here but you're being deliberately obtuse again.

I'll spell it out: It is my hypothesis that Gamma was avoiding the NPOM wagon because he knew it would flip Town, and those posts support that hypothesis because they represent a defense so flawed that even NPOM himself rejected them.

In post 940, Blair wrote:I'm really trying to communicate with you here but you're being deliberately obtuse again.

I'll spell it out: It is my hypothesis that Gamma was avoiding the NPOM wagon because he knew it would flip Town, and those posts support that hypothesis because they represent a defense so flawed that even NPOM himself rejected them.

Except it's an argument from silence. Saying Gamma is Scum for being right not being on the NPOM lynch is bad. That is why I said Gamma comes out of that looking BETTER than you. Hence, if Gamma fucks up on something later in the game, we can probably nail them for that.

In post 940, Blair wrote:I'm really trying to communicate with you here but you're being deliberately obtuse again.

I'll spell it out: It is my hypothesis that Gamma was avoiding the NPOM wagon because he knew it would flip Town, and those posts support that hypothesis because they represent a defense so flawed that even NPOM himself rejected them.

i propose that a good test of this would be lynching r2r. if r2r flips town then you have a case on gamma. I'm not voting gamma otherwise though.

also, im gonna try to start doing some efforting. i started with the low-effort efforting, reading the midway and dunn slot isos. thoughts on midway above in a previous post. thoughts on dunn here.
dunn's catch-up wasnt great, and followed with a pretty shitty vote. dunn what are your thoughts on the wagons today? who do you think is scum? are you scum?

Nice 6 post read

Consider this a trial-run of the Blair System™

The Blair System™ lynches Gammagooey Day 2. It's a good system. It has never failed.

In post 935, mavsfan41 wrote:

In post 919, Quick wrote:

In post 917, votato wrote:

In post 916, Quick wrote:I think the wagons should be between votato and R2R tbqh.

VOTE: votato

why is that your lynchpool? why do you prefer me over r2r?

I think there are people who want to spill your blood. I also think there are people who want to spill R2R's blood. I currently have R2R above you. That's why I am voting you. That and the fact that there are already some people voting for R2R and I want to help facilitate the wagons here.

mav's switch from votato to R2R seems a bit short sighted and I have previously thought mav to be a critical thinker. So this puzzles me.

Thanks for the compliment haha.
Votato is the one person I’ve been swinging wildly on since the NPOM town flip. I go from thinking he’s DEFINITELY scum with R2R to think he’s DEFINITELY town. So expect more, but currently I’m on the he’s DEFINITELY town part of the pendulum.

@Blair: R2R is absent from your possible pairings list. Looking through your posts, I don’t actually see a case on why you believe him to be town or explain a town read? (Full disclosure: when I say “looking through” your posts what I mean is skimming through them as there are A LOT.)

So rn you are SRing R2R more than you are SRing votato. I can see that I suppose. Flip flopping usually comes from Town, so that is a slight reason to boost the TR on you to Null-Slight Town. Still, that is how you stack up anyways...

I see what you did there

For some reason, I had a scum read on VPB, but it seems like you guys think that is unrealistic

Sig bets were outlawed, so I'll just say regardless of how Gamma flips we both get to put this in our signatures:

In post 944, Blair wrote:The Blair System™ lynches Gammagooey Day 2. It's a good system. It has never failed.

In post 943, midwaybear wrote:Nice 6 post read

are you gonna answer any of my questions? you have said that you're reading but you havent contributed anything. not even shitposts. its a total void.