I am fully caught up, here's where i am at right now:
TOWN
Sakura - strong metaread, also i like their stances so far
NPOM - the vehicle towards out of RVS
Porkens - this wagon had no reason to exist except pressure and i think the verdict is town
Frederick - expected less from a low-to-mid poster iso but the content is actually good
Mohab500 - towny activity, liked readlist in 622
^^^ TOWN CONFIDENCE ^^^
Cooldog - liked his entrance a lot although i'm quite distant from him with my reads
Firebringer - need to read him better, there's too much activity there to sort out with a single catchup
Norwegian - somehow i always dislike norwegian in normals but i have been sooo wrong before that i don't want to touch this base d1. This was as of page 25 or something - then improves around ~585, i feel confident about leaving him alive today, also cooldog vs norwee smells like TvT
--- TRUE NULL LINE ---
Persivul - bad slot due to interactions around him more than his participation (= none)
popopo - bad slot votewise
Drew-Sta - also bad slot votewise
Quick - 134-135 feels like resuming shitpost on purpose when the situation had recently evolved to a non-shitpost stage due to NPOM claim; all of their followups are bad takes to me. Looks scum by the manual.
SCUM
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 2:50 am
by Farkran
VOTE: Quick
Prove me wrong
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 2:54 am
by Mohab500
I am honestly starting to get really lost, any idea which page I should start from to catch up to the current wagons?
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 2:59 am
by Mohab500
Briefly looked at pages 30 and 31. I still don't like Firebringer, the 'everybody here is Town!' attitude seems to align more with scum rather than naive town here.
In post 931, Mohab500 wrote:Briefly looked at pages 30 and 31. I still don't like Firebringer, the 'everybody here is Town!' attitude seems to align more with scum rather than naive town here.
if u got a scumread u want to convince me of, i am all ears
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:08 am
by Farkran
Yes
And a lot of his followups and takes. 363 is an astrologist comment, the 1v1 vs frederick is terrible on his side and i don't understand his read of popopo.
and really isn't that more important than being right
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:12 am
by Mohab500
Did you kids just spend several pages arguing with Sakura regarding their self-meta defense, right after saying that meta doesn't matter and that reading through meta is not alignment indicative since everybody does it?
And a lot of his followups and takes. 363 is an astrologist comment, the 1v1 vs frederick is terrible on his side and i don't understand his read of popopo.
pedit: you've not proven anything though
I had a scumread on them at some point, but after the Firebringer thing happened it felt like they were scumreading firebringer out of anger than anything else, and that's what made me think the slot was probably town at that point. What's your take on that?
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:16 am
by NorwegianboyEE
A lot of the comments explaining your reads don't really explain much Farkran.
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:16 am
by Drew-Sta
In post 938, Mohab500 wrote:Did you kids just spend several pages arguing with Sakura regarding their self-meta defense, right after saying that meta doesn't matter and that reading through meta is not alignment indicative since everybody does it?
No, I said they weren’t consistent with their own arguments.
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:19 am
by Firebringer
i still dont get why quick scumreads me.
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:20 am
by Mohab500
I just read the last 8 or so pages and my brain completely died. So can someone actually summarize the whole Drew-Sta VS Norwegian or Sakura or CoolDoG or whatever is going on here? What's with the wagon on Porkens, can I find actual reasons here?
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:20 am
by Drew-Sta
In post 916, Firebringer wrote:i don't think its possible me playing mafia and not being a disrespectful prick....
can such a thing be done?
I’m fine with people being arseholes. If I cared enough I’d probably be one in this game but I’m backed up at work so don’t have the energy. You just seem tetchy that people are calling you out. /shrugs
In post 912, Drew-Sta wrote:I don’t use meta as a primary source to inform my read on a player. Why is that so fucking horrible? Honestly, you read like Kermit D Frog flailing because someone disagrees with your worldview.
honestly i wasn't even talking to u buddy or fredrick.
i was talking about people calling meta trash in general sense. If u fall into that group. Then sure, take that rant at urself personally or something idc.
if i wanted to call people names i would direct them right at them. I think u and drew got way to defensive of my rant on meta haters and decided u belonged to the group and my rant was at u guys. Which is like ???? since both of u decided to also distance urself from the group i labelled but also felt marginalized by me.
I got defensive? You’re the one with a stick in your arse as a consequence of what I’ve said.
You’re really behaving wildly. I don’t follow you.
In post 921, NorwegianboyEE wrote:Why r u mad at Firebringer now Drew? I've been much more disrespectful. And i relish in it.
I’m not..? If I was mad it would be pretty clear.
Posted: Mon May 25, 2020 3:21 am
by NorwegianboyEE
In post 928, Farkran wrote:Porkens - this wagon had no reason to exist except pressure and i think the verdict is town
What?
In post 928, Farkran wrote:Persivul - bad slot due to interactions around him more than his participation (= none)