Mafiascum.net

In post 485, April Ludgate wrote:

In post 472, morph the cat wrote:

In post 466, Prism wrote:

In post 461, morph the cat wrote:

In post 456, Bell wrote:Where’s alisae?

Cut them some slack. It's incredibly hard to plan your entrance into the main thread when several slots you fear drew town and you didn't.

Especially when there's other posts onsite to make that are less fraught with danger at every turn.

The real reason they're afraid is because I'm holding them hostage to release those Scumsman PTs, I'm not giving up on this

P-Edit: Me

Also, Alisae's most recent site check in is concurrent with page 16 of this game....

To be fair, that’s 16 pages of games e’d have to catch up on, and e does a lot of non game related things on site. I’m willing to wait for them before really pushing them.

What are your thoughts about their entrance/catchup?

brain dead today. May or may not be helpful today.

@journeymanbear, in this case signal to noise just meant that for every post that was related to the game there was a stray comment that wasn’t really related to the game.

In post 875, Remilia Scarlet wrote:I need easy reads so my amount of work done looks inflated.

You see, I have this secret tell that has pretty decent amount of accuracy even without me reading all those pages.
I'm going to use this secret tell and call morph and Bell town for until at least Day 3.

Hey cool thanks.

In post 896, Remilia Scarlet wrote:

In post 894, morph the cat wrote:

In post 881, Remilia Scarlet wrote:I'll give you 10 points if you figure out my secret tell though.

That stopped being a good tell for me the first time I scum-hydra'd with nacho. I think you know that.

There's town all over my iso, but number of posts isn't it.

Oh I wasn't serious. I literally didn't read the game yet still except for like 1~2 pages. And then I saw you complaining about there being no content. So I became lazy mode again.

Further proof that effort does not always equal accuracy. The world is ruled by slackers.

In post 917, Remilia Scarlet wrote:re Alisae's catchup:

Curious about a few things:
1) Why are you skipping morph's posts in particular? post count?
2) If it's post count, why are you reading bell to the point where you're just utterly shutting down any suspicion pointed that way? I assume you read that slot?

This catchup feels like someone who's been reading the game vs someone who's been catching up in the moment in that it seems to have already decided to handle specific slots in specific ways

-b

I pretty much feel the same. What bothers me the most is how many people are sorted into each category and who’s sorted where.

In post 922, morph the cat wrote:Given how my basing the read on you back then and not trying harder to read Nacho caused me to misread your slot, does it really surprise you that in this game I want to townread both heads?

It doesn't necessarily surprise me but it's certainly not the only reason you might do that and my initial impression wasn't "bork seems town but I'm still paranoid" (which, fine) and more "here's a bunch of town bork stuff but gif is a non-factor therefore imma stick them in my null pile with heavy qualification on my 4th tier"

I have a bit more to say about this but I don't have time right now. I'm trying to reconcile my own perspective with the one you are presenting here.

-b

That fourth tier is like... a box that sits outside the reads. Not actually the 4th tier down from the top.

I believe ffery actually originally called it something like "My heart wants" but then I made stupid meme-y names for the titles instead.

Now I feel like I came between townbork and townffery with my stupid memey shit and i really thin the FACT i think of it that way is an indicator that we should get over it and make you hang out with bell.

"Leftovers for dinner" are technically our null pile, not our scum pile.

In post 485, April Ludgate wrote:

In post 472, morph the cat wrote:

In post 466, Prism wrote:

In post 461, morph the cat wrote:

In post 456, Bell wrote:Where’s alisae?

Cut them some slack. It's incredibly hard to plan your entrance into the main thread when several slots you fear drew town and you didn't.

Especially when there's other posts onsite to make that are less fraught with danger at every turn.

The real reason they're afraid is because I'm holding them hostage to release those Scumsman PTs, I'm not giving up on this

P-Edit: Me

Also, Alisae's most recent site check in is concurrent with page 16 of this game....

To be fair, that’s 16 pages of games e’d have to catch up on, and e does a lot of non game related things on site. I’m willing to wait for them before really pushing them.

What are your thoughts about their entrance/catchup?

In post 617, Remilia Scarlet wrote:

In post 611, Bell wrote:

In post 608, Remilia Scarlet wrote:VOTE: Bell

I don't like the flip on Midwaybear for not playing ball
I don't like the engagement on muffin wrt morph/muffin comvo. I feel like if muffin weren't attacking morph that vote wouldn't be there

-b

Okay. You don’t like it.
Walk me through why you don’t like it.

Why does muffin need to be scum to come in attack morph?
And your progression on midway flipped from someone in town bucket to a scum read in a way that doesn't seem genuine to me. why is midway refusing to answer your Q even remotely alignment indicative (and moreover, to the point that you needed to whiplash the hell out of that read)

p-edit: that doesn't make any sense.

How do you feel about the form the attack has taken?

In post 638, Bell wrote:To me they don’t seem unhappy at all
And i’m Not picking up on that at all.

And if one of them was going to hate their existence as scum it would be ff.

And all the Cabd posts are the ones that pinged him.

You know this how?

In post 649, The Bulge wrote:all the meta talk bores me

i'll be in morph's iso

Our iso isn't a great place to escape meta talk, but you've probably realized that!

In post 683, The Bulge wrote:

In post 657, Something_Smart wrote:

In post 648, The Bulge wrote:the second part was a general statement supporting the first part. the line as a whole means I think it is somewhat scummy to lament about hydrae in-thread instead of just playing the game and sorting them, but perhaps not so scummy coming from someone who has never played with a hydra before.

You think it's scummy because it's distracting? Or, why did it matter that it was distracting?

I'll preface by saying that this could very well be a posting-style thing. i'm also having a hard time putting this to words so apologies if this is not well-explained

In post 345, Something_Smart wrote:

I must admit

, this game is not

doing a good job of

making hydras look

easy to play with

.

italicized are the bits, lets call them euphemisms for demonstrative purposes, that I read as fluff dressing this post up as something other than a simple "hydra bad" post, like +j's 309.

In post 425, Something_Smart wrote:Re: the hydra comment, it wasn't dislike per se, just that there was a decent amount of confusion with regards to who said what (and with IV, who was even part of the hydra/playing in the game), and it was hard for me to follow (and probably even harder for +J to follow).

and some downplaying of the previous post. maybe a +j buddying attempt?

This is pretty on track with how I felt about the post at the time it was made. My read of s_s has gone up the charts a bit on their content since then, including his interactions with you.

In post 695, The Bulge wrote:ie, by following up on scumpings, questioning slots indiscriminately, asking off-kilter direct questions, participating in discussion, etc etc, all very rudimentary day 1 townplay.

A kindred spirit. especially the indiscriminate and off-kilter parts.

This is probably at the heart of of my you-read.

In post 717, Bell wrote:If it was a scum read i’d voted him.

I need some words around what it means when you call someone scum and don't vote them.

Hang out with me. But don’t expect great things from me today.

I plead the fifth. We played together a long ass time ago.

I’m not an alt alt. This is just my main now, I quit mafia for 5-6 years? I used to go by remembrance.

In post 935, Bell wrote:Hang out with me. But don’t expect great things from me today.

I don't think it's a hard question, but ok. ish.

Bell wrote:I’m not an alt alt. This is just my main now, I quit mafia for 5-6 years? I used to go by remembrance.

<3

The extreme convergence of thought makes a LOT more sense now.

When Remilia-GiF gets his head in the game, I'll be very interested in your thoughts!

I've gotten my head around the stuff that was flying right past me late yesterday.

Bulge? Balls in your court.

@Meow cat - it’s fine, my initial reaction was lolAlisae’s scum, but not in the manner where I’m ultra confident in that.

I was talking about Remilia since you said you wanted us to hang together and discuss whatever I guess.

Prism/Alisae is an interesting thing

Why did Prism replace out?

In post 942, April Ludgate wrote:Prism/Alisae is an interesting thing

Okay, Neuter-half here and I'll bite.

Because of the things Alisae said, or are you only partially basing it upon Alisae's posts, and you see things from Prism-slot towards Alisae as well?

In post 943, April Ludgate wrote:Why did Prism replace out?

This, along with the number of licks required to get to the center of a tootsie pop, will never be known. At least not under the modern mafiascum rules set.

In post 941, Bell wrote:I was talking about Remilia since you said you wanted us to hang together and discuss whatever I guess.

What are your thoughts about Remilia?

I'm gong to disappear in about 10 minutes for a short while, but I'll be back as soon as I can.

In post 874, The Bulge wrote:ali any reason you skipped my posts on first read? none are particularly long

no particular reason, nothing you wrote really stood out to me and got my attention.

--

In post 917, Remilia Scarlet wrote:re Alisae's catchup:

Curious about a few things:
1) Why are you skipping morph's posts in particular? post count?
2) If it's post count, why are you reading bell to the point where you're just utterly shutting down any suspicion pointed that way? I assume you read that slot?

This catchup feels like someone who's been reading the game vs someone who's been catching up in the moment in that it seems to have already decided to handle specific slots in specific ways

-b

morph has a lot of posts and when I'm just skimming its hard for anything in particular to stick out. The only thing I can say really sticks out from them is the reads list and I feel like thats their most cohesive post but then again there's a bunch of other posts I missed so who knows.
I townlean Bell but I don't know how you're interpretting my catch up as shutting down scumreads on that post when I'm not. I'm mostly just interested in what midway had to say about the slot (which he posted and I'll look at it when I can turn on my brain) and your vote stood out because tone.

In post 942, April Ludgate wrote:Prism/Alisae is an interesting thing

In post 943, April Ludgate wrote:Why did Prism replace out?

Are you a drug dealer. What’re you selling.

@morph, Luke warm. Bork seems a little townie. On the surface, but no ahah’s or click’s yet.

In post 833, Alisae wrote:I don't get the Giffybork read. You're talking about it like its a townread you trust a lot in, and if thats the case, why is it so low? I feel like I'm just missing something thats obvious.

morph did u respond to this cuz i didn't see it