Mary and I both have a negative impression of Celestial Powerhouse.
Mary describes them as the hydra that wanted to roll town, but didn't, and is now doing whatever they want and finding it hard to get engaged with the game.
On my end, I think that the deity roleplay takes up too much of their persona and that they sometimes fail to deliver content in lieu of roleplaying.
I've additionally listed a couple of posts of theirs that we have problems with:
-----------
-
265 "we're anon for a reason". But then, in
904 they remark that pooky should know who one of the heads are.
^This bothers me because it's not consistent. This is my weakest point against them.
-
317:
In post 317, Celestial Powerhouse wrote:
This kinda reads like someone who didn't know what they were walking into, which is hard to believe if the game waa reas before rapping in
ZEUS FOUND A MENTAL DISCREPANCY
^Dannflor never claimed to have read before replacing in. This is failure to understand #1, where their view of the game is not what has actually happened.
-
337 "i should go see the "Mod Influence" posts again.
^As far as I can tell, this never gets brought up again. I remember I thought this was a bit weird when it happened, because I didn't think to focus on that as opposed to T3's claim and then the change of claim when Dannflor replaced in. This isn't a failure to understand, but it is a disconnect with what I'd expect.
-
868 "no, when I say dying I definitely just mean alive and well and in the game."
^This is failure to understand #2. Post
481 seems pretty straightforward in asking whether they mean through elimination or the night kill, but they don't initially catch this, and go as far to say they should vote Uncle Shelby for this.
-
871 "I was so happy with being middle tier on someone's reads list. why'd you ruin that?"
^This is failure to understand #3. Unwnd's list is not a reads list (except for the bottom tier). This is something Unwnd explained in both his next and previous posts.
-
890 "I dont really like how "correct" dann's reads feel. they feel like they are "right" and Im not sure how to explain that feeling. they just fit in so well and I dont question them when typically I pick at people's reads lists."
_Dann's reads:
[unwnd]
[lukewarm, echo, kazyan, celestial?]
[morph the cat, resistance]
[manatee, uncle shelby]
[..., ...]
^I am of the opposite opinion. This reads list in
327 is sort of crazy. Specifically: Unwnd at the very top, echo, kazyan, celestial all townreads as of 327, Uncle Shelby as a scumread. I didn't agree with that at all... their argument in 890 isn't a good argument because, as far as I can tell, the reads in 327 weren't consensus anyway
-----------
I'm inclined to believe that somebody that fails to understand things several times is more likely to hold a non-town alignment. I'd also apply this reasoning to people who still think Dannflor is being voted because t3 "slipped" - they're not thinking critically about the game, which usually means they're scum looking things over and blending in.
In addition to the above, I think their push on Pooky is awkward.