Starcraft Mafia Mini 1210 (Over)

[scooby]

Just kidding, I'm staying mod.

[Shadowmod]

For my and every one's convenience (mostly to help me keep track of claims and all the replacements when rereading):

player	role name	role spec.	status	misc. claims
Kiwieagle	Zeratul		alive
killerjester Acronach	Selendis		blown to smithereens night 1
ooba HellloooNewman	Artanis	name confirm for protoss/??? for other race	alive
Scott Brosius gbevilchaos	Valerian Mengsk		alive	knew Arcturus was in the game
Morthas	Gabriel Tosh		alive
Espeonage	Arcturus Mengsk Matt Horner		lynched day 1
Iecerint kondi2424	Samir Duran		alive
Scooby avasthearties	Jimmy Raynor		alive	not allowed to vote vifam
??? Vifam	Overlord	Watcher	alive
Furcolow rewq455	Fenix		alive
ShadowDancer Psyche	Tychus Findlay		alive	confirms Raynor
DemonHybrid Stels	Edmund Duke		alive

[Shadow Dancer]

For my and every one's convenience (mostly to help me keep track of claims and all the replacements when rereading):

player	role name	role spec.	status	misc. claims
Kiwieagle	Zeratul		alive
killerjester Acronach	Selendis		blown to smithereens night 1
ooba HellloooNewman	Artanis	name confirm for protoss/??? for other race	alive
Scott Brosius gbevilchaos	Valerian Mengsk		alive	knew Arcturus was in the game
Morthas	Gabriel Tosh		alive
Espeonage	Arcturus Mengsk Matt Horner		lynched day 1
Iecerint kondi2424	Samir Duran		alive
Scooby avasthearties	Jimmy Raynor		alive	not allowed to vote vifam
??? Vifam	Overlord	Watcher	alive
Furcolow rewq455	Fenix		alive
ShadowDancer Psyche	Tychus Findlay		alive	confirms Raynor
DemonHybrid Stels	Edmund Duke		alive

[ooba]

Also: Hello! Hello? Tarsonis to Ooba! This is Shadow speaking. You still did not explain your scott vote, neither did you adress your night action as I asked you to do.

Gbevil was scummy as helll around page 15. I'm not clarifying the rest of my ability or claiming my N1 night action right now.

I just voted Vifam in this post since that's the only lynch which is happening today and just before I clicked submit, asked myself why didn't Iece hammer yet?? To put my paranoia fears to rest,

I'd like Iece to hammer Vifam please.

[Shadow Dancer]

So

in what way

was Gbevil "scummy as hell" on page 15?

[Iecerint]

GBE was EXTREMELY scummy, and the only reason SB isn't obvscum is the Arcturus element, and I think it'd be ballsy to outright claim your "real" role like that.

Vote: Vifam

Woe to Kerrigan, we hardly knew ye.

You guys clearly didn't play In Utter Darkness enough...

[DeathNote]

A lynch was inevitable when one does nothing and fights the system. In mafia as in Starcraft, one must learn to fight only battles he can when no matter how strong you think you are. The Queen of Blades would go down with no contestation.

Deadline for night 2 is Wednesday, 10:00 P.M. central. Searching for replacement for Furcolow.

~Vifam was Kerrigan, Queen of Blades (Modified Cult Leader)~

[DeathNote]

One day closer to minerals becoming scarce and battles becoming fierce. Its time to unleash the true force of everyone's potential!

DemonHybrid (Edmund Duke) was silenced night 2.
ShadowDancer (Tychus Finley) was vengefully killed night 2.

Furcolow (Ulrezja) was blown to smithereens night 2.

~Day 3 ends three weeks from now. With 6 alive, its 4 to lynch.~

[DemonHybrid]

THIS IS MY BAH POST

[Iecerint]

ShadowDancer used to be Psyche, right? Was obvtown IMO. Oh well.

I don't even know who/what Ulrezja is. Is that one of the Protoss crystals, or someone from the novels...?

[Iecerint]

Looks like Ulrezja is a villain from a Map of the Month series or something. No connection to Arcturus Mengsk AFAICT. So that's kinda senseless, but w/e.

[Iecerint]

I just got a PM from the Mod that gave me a new ability called "Mafia Sided." This ability does NOT change or augment or modulate my wincon in any way, but it gives me the following information:

1. There is exactly 1 mafia remaining.
2. The sex of the role is implied to be male (due to pronoun usage).
3. Any actions that might have yielded information about that last mafia did not work N2. (Stuff @ Furco should've worked normally AFAICT.)

It's not clear whether this ability will also mess with night information from this point on or not. It implies that it affected only N2. I have sent the Mod a PM requesting clarification.

[Iecerint]

Could we keep who the various dead players replaced in the first post, please?

[Iecerint]

DeathNote has clarified that the ability will only affect Night 2.

[scooby]

WHO IN HIS RIGHT MIND COULD VENGEFUL KILL SHADOWDANCER?

OH RIGHT IT'S DEMONHYBRID HERPDERP THAT ALSO SAID VIFAM WAS OBVIOUS TOWN WATCHER.

[scooby]

I'm not sure I trust Iecerint but I think Morthas is the play for today.

I need to reread who defended Vifam because modifed cult leader is modified cult leader and with DemonHybrid flipping town this means someone else got recruited.

Balance reasons: How many scum left. 1 mafia + 1 recruit ? Is this remarkably balanced?

[Scott Brosius]

Blown to smithereens was also the N1 kill, given that it was a mafia kill last night, I guess it is some sort of vig/third party.

Morthas or kiwi today.

[Iecerint]

I need to reread who defended Vifam because modifed cult leader is modified cult leader and with DemonHybrid flipping town this means someone else got recruited.

Balance reasons: How many scum left. 1 mafia + 1 recruit ? Is this remarkably balanced?

Unless I am the only one whose town wincon is 100% secure, anyone who was recruited N1 is almost certainly functionally town by this point.

They may even be dead. Either way, finding them is not the best use of effort, even if we can probably assume only 1 anti-town left.

My best guess is that DemonHybrid was recruited N1. The claim that Edmund Duke could block recruitment never made any sense with flavor, and we now know that Duke was a vengekiller. DH was also the obvious target for Vifam, as he had already gone on record defending her (so no awkward opinion change was necessary) and was viewed as town due to catching Espe.

As I stated over and over D2, you can ask the Mod about the 100%-ness of your own wincon to confirm this -- it doesn't have to be a mod-outguess thing unless the Mod randomly only wanted to share this fact with me. It's not like it's in my role PM.

If the Mod does NOT confirm this for you, let me know.

[Iecerint]

Update:

player	role name	role spec.	status	misc. claims
Kiwieagle	Zeratul		alive
killerjester Acronach	Selendis		blown to smithereens night 1
ooba HellloooNewman	Artanis	name confirm for protoss/??? for other race	alive
Scott Brosius gbevilchaos	Valerian Mengsk		alive	knew Arcturus was in the game
Morthas	Gabriel Tosh		alive
Espeonage	Arcturus Mengsk Matt Horner		lynched day 1
Iecerint kondi2424	Samir Duran		alive
Scooby avasthearties	Jimmy Raynor		alive	not allowed to vote vifam
Vifam	Kerrigan, Queen of Blades Overlord	Modified Cult Recruiter Watcher	lynched D2
Furcolow rewq455	Ulrezaj Fenix	May have vengekilled	blown to smithereens night 1
ShadowDancer Psyche	Tychus Findlay		silenced night 2.	confirms Raynor
DemonHybrid Stels	Edmund Duke	Claimed recruitment blocker; may have vengekilled	vengefully killed night 2 .

I missed where Tychus confirmed Raynor. Where?

[Iecerint]

I doubt Fenix and Zeratul are both fakeclaims. Kiwi is probably town. Also, Kiwi is the last Protoss, so Ooba should use his ability on Kiwi N3/lynching Kiwi is literally the worst possible move.

If Scooby is confirmed, that's also taken care of.

That leaves [Valerian/Tosh == SB, Morthas] as the possible lynch. Ooba will investigate Kiwi N3; my ability will not interfere. There is only 1 scum left, so unless he has redirection or something, this should establish a reasonable narrowing of the possibilities. Town Ooba will give us accurate information, and Scum Ooba will (correctly) narrow it to Ooba/SB/Morthas or Ooba/Kiwi.

I think Morthas is the best bet banking on Nova as the last scum. Since both Mengsk and Ulrezjzj are scummy scum, and Kerrigan, and there's 1 scum left, we still need a "not so evil" scum role to discern as per the Mod's early note.

[ooba]

Lol@Vifam's role of Modified cult recruiter who a townie can't vote for flavor wise .. Would really like to see the entire setup soon ..

Morthas is the play for today .. All of analysis for yesterday + Furclow's insistance on a Vifam lynch purely on flavor - didn't have conviction - hence was defending Morthas ..

Unfortunately, I don't have anything useful to add to the current situation in terms of night actions .. Will target kiwi tonight and hopefully be alive to share em tomorrow .. However I anticipate the game to end with Morthas's lynch

Also, the person who killed Furclow should claim to confirm towniness ..

Wasn't me ..

[Iecerint]

You should probably go ahead and list your N1 and N2 targets so that hypothetical trackers or watchers can evaluate.

[Shadow Dancer]

Ouch! Sucker!

[Morthas]

Veng Kill Shadow?! Wow.
3 Kills imply there to be a 3rd party alive and kicking which also NK'd either DH or Frank(The other name is too hard to remember)
I'd bet on Iec ( Being the 3rd party ) and Scott being the scum. I'll ask the mod about the wincon thing by Iec. I'll post more later ( Probably ISO Scott or something )

[scooby]

Question to the people with more flavor knowledge, is Tosh part of Raynor Raiders?