Mafiascum.net

Eh, not too much. That would just be a random die roll at this stage for me, and there isn't enough meat to get any traction with so it'd just be an odd play that would accomplish nothing. Benmage actually has enough traction to make something happen here, and that's more interesting.

Why do you think Benmage is scum?

I'd vote JF, but it seems like a waste of time.

It is surprising MoI is not screaming for my head as 100000000% confirmed scum.

↑ MagnaofIllusion wrote:

Thor wrote: What do you think of that weird Benmage thing where he wailed in to defend your meta read of him, tish-toshed mine, and then basically agreed with mine later in an odd mealy-mouth thing? Am I insane for seeing that, or did you take it the same way I did?

It was odd. Benmage is clearly active when he’s Town. That’s a cornerstone he’s used in his own defense and pretty clearly a lack of activity (and by that I’m saying “Having less posts than the Mod as opposed to not having the most posts”) is a good sign of scum Benmage.

I don’t really like that 20% of his total posting (10 posts out of 52ish) happened AFTER I called out his lack of activity. And furthermore that those 10 posts are pretty much appeasement “Well, I’m not always active but MoI is more right than Thor” posting as opposed to scum-hunting.

My only guess is MoI is scum.

if both Thor and Benmage take their votes off of Benmage and Yates respectively, JF will be at 3 and the other wagons will be at 4. WE CAN MAKE THIS HAPPEN!

I'll be around to the end of a todays time....

also lol at PV's vote following JF's.

↑ Benmage wrote:I'll be around to the end of a todays time....

I will not be claiming.

Since you can't get back on, I suggest you name claim. It doesn't tip off scum and does present a chance for counter-claim for us.

All three of the last votes are... "lets see what this does" "idno" "derp".....

Solid wagon fellahs.

↑ BK201 wrote:

↑ Benmage wrote:I'll be around to the end of a todays time....

I will not be claiming.

Since you can't get back on, I suggest you name claim. It doesn't tip off scum and does present a chance for counter-claim for us.

There's like a bagillion chance scum have fakeclaims.

But fine.

I am BULMA.

And I said I WILL be around (like to move my vote if need be, if JF was plausible...) Although gonna go food shipping now.

Oh and BK, your reads least is spot on.

↑ Benmage wrote:Oh and BK, your reads least is spot on.

yay

Benmage basically said he will move his vote to JF if plausible.

Thor basically sounds ok with the lynch if plausible.

Lets pretend JF is at 3 votes then, need some more!

↑ PeregrineV wrote:At what point in your mafia career did you decide you weren't very good at mafia?

In every game I've been in I've been detrimental to the town. In every game I've lost as town I've at least been partially responsible or totally responsible. And in the games I've won its always been on the shoulders of better players and despite my efforts I'm always totally wrong about everything. I think this is absolutely the best way to play towards my win condition for the time being.

↑ snifit wrote:Can you link me an example of your scumhunting, syndrome?

geeeeeeeeez I literally just replaced in yesterday. But seriously what's with you being completely unwilling to vote benmage "because he's just picked at random" and yet you can in your next post vote me for absolutely no reason other than you don't like me? That seems inconsistent and I feel like I might be being used as a scapegoat here just so you can not take a position on the active wagons.

That said I'm naturally a very OMGUSy person so I acknowledge that I might be overreacting a bit right now just because comments like "Is anyone happy having this guy in the game?" is very hurtful

Syndrome, I like your four-star dragon ball. Whats your read on Johnny?

I'll cut off your tail.
Problem solved.

@BK - Benmage is scum for being wishy washy in how he answered something to the point he basically said both sides were right. About his own ruddy meta. That level of doubletalk feels to me like, when he initially made the proMoI antiThor commentary it was just a general attack thing to look proactive and involved and like he might be reading. His error was, I don't think he even really recalled what I had originally said about his playstyle and thus ended up agreeing with me as well. Then got awkward and didn't want to admit that and backed out poorly. Then power lurked. Then barely had anything to say upon return.

Combine that with gut and not really being too fond of some of his recent pushes and I would be quite content to have him dead.

You apparently find him town for some reason - clarify?

There was no double talk.. you weren't clear either in your questioning.. or your understanding.....

For example:

↑ Benmage wrote:

↑ Thor665 wrote:He didn't say you were awesome - he implied you normally would have posted more.

You're now saying that isn't true.

I'm now confused...can you go back and tell me if you still think Post 750 is an honest reflection of your opinion of your playstyle?
If the answer is 'yes' can you tell me how it connects to Post 759 where you seem to be saying something different?

While you're at it - what's your call about my summation of the Yates case, and why do you think he's lynchworthy?

-I know I'm putting words in MoI's mouth. (Imadeafunny)
-I don't see the difference in 750 and 759, but rather both refer to the totality of my play as awesome and prolific. (yes there may be lulls... but the totality is a high)

-Your Yates case will have to wait for tomorrow... mind linking it or naming the posts I can find it at..... otherwise Ill just iso you.

You saw a difference apparently in posts 750, and 759... where there was none.

I think you may be trying to hide the legitimacy of your vote being this 'viel' that I was.. as you say mealy-mouthed.

Look at the rest of the votes, and be happy with the wagon you alone stand responsible for.

Here's my disclaimer.

EVEN though I read Thor as town. LYNCH ON SITE IF ALIVE IN LYLO.

And MoI, lynch on site if alive D3.

You can lynch me now.

↑ syndromeofadown wrote:

↑ PeregrineV wrote:At what point in your mafia career did you decide you weren't very good at mafia?

In every game I've been in I've been detrimental to the town. In every game I've lost as town I've at least been partially responsible or totally responsible. And in the games I've won its always been on the shoulders of better players and despite my efforts I'm always totally wrong about everything. I think this is absolutely the best way to play towards my win condition for the time being.

You should request out, and simply play in the newbie zone until you feel more comfortable with your play. (I.E. You are ruining any game you are in for everyone else)

**Read completed games without looking at the flips, and see if you can determine who the scum are.

Thor, I sat there with you trying to figure out what you were asking me...and you are lynching me for it. Get better.

I actually am becoming more sold by this reaction than less sold.

Congratulations? (you'restillwrong)

↑ Thor665 wrote:I actually am becoming more sold by this reaction than less sold.

Better yet, since this is such a fucking abstract statement.


WHAT possible statment could I have uttered that would have changed your mind? HMMMM????