Mini 1449 - Ordinary Town

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

post_id=4992023 time=1369848034 user_id=10128]Just because I can't logic does not mean I mafia

Wrong answer. Try again

I have also never seen a 4-shot Joat in my 3 years on this site. Dashie is a reviewer so I'm asking her if she has ever seen it.

[hp [leaves]]

I shot zef because he spent his days safely attacking Varsoon while riding the Cage bandwagon. Just look at his posts after he unvoted hapa:

Posts about Cage:

If you are talking about your first post of the game, 1) I detected sarcasm, so I believe that it was a "true" RVS-vote 2) If it wasn't sarcasm, then it certainly held no logic. Regardless, I am comfortable moving my vote there as well.

Vote: NicCage

@NicCage, I am voting for you because I think you're scum. You're initial reasoning for sheeping GCBC is poor. Jake from Rainbowdash responded to your "safe vote" argument precisely how I would have.

Posts about Varsoon:

Whenever I get prodded I come and skim the most recent posts that I've missed. It's usually 2-3 pages. The only new thoughts I have are that Varsoon is incredibly annoying and anti-town, and I can see why someone would want to vote him.

Posting because I got prodded, even though just skimming the most recent posts hasn't really changed my opinion on anything. More scummy posts from Varsoon, namely #213 where he says the NicCage isn't a good wagon even though he had just included him in his lynchpool a few posts earlier.

I find Varsoon's posts to reek of wishy-washiness, fence-sitting, and noncommittal attitude.

Strong FoS: Varsoon

. If I wasn't voting NicCage, I would vote Varsoon.

Note for reference: Varsoon's post listing all his reads and who he would like to flip is particularly scummy. Scum often like to group two names together when giving FoS'es, one a townie and one scum. This is a safety blanket. If Varsoon is scum, and because I personally believe NicCage is scum, GCBC is probably a townie (who I had a slight-town read on anyways). Likewise, because I personally have a town-read on hapahauli, Toomai might be scum (not sure on this one, yet). I don't understand why Varsoon would list out his lynch-pool and not place a vote in the same post, only to weakly continue on and place a parrot vote on Toomai anyway.

See the difference in the amount of content. He seemed to be safely attacking Varsoon while voting for Cage so I shot him down. Also his lame excuses for not posting. I don't like that kind of stuff.

[hp [leaves]]

Fine. Full claim.

Jack of all Trades:
1-shot vig
1-shot roleblock
1-shot "knifesmith"
1-shot bodyguard
1-shot bulletproof

I already claimed my actions so that's it.

[Varsoon]

woah woah woah woah woah woah

unvote

HP, what the fuck?
I'm really, really, really paranoid about PR claims and you do this to me?

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

post_id=4992078 time=1369849382 user_id=10128]Fine. Full claim.

Jack of all Trades:
1-shot vig
1-shot roleblock
1-shot "knifesmith"
1-shot bodyguard
1-shot bulletproof

I already claimed my actions so that's it.

that is 5 shot, not 4

and if you have a "knifesmith" role which is an investigation role, why not use that night 1 vs killing an obv town player?

you still did not explain why you blocked SB when you originally had him as a town read and he was on the scum wagon.

makes no sense...

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

dashie made a post in the QT and once she says I can post it here I will.

we both still agree that massclaim is good

[hp [leaves]]

post_id=4992078 time=1369849382 user_id=10128]Fine. Full claim.

Jack of all Trades:
1-shot vig
1-shot roleblock
1-shot "knifesmith"
1-shot bodyguard
1-shot bulletproof

I already claimed my actions so that's it.

that is 5 shot, not 4

and I have two actions left. Where did I claim 4-shot?

and if you have a "knifesmith" role which is an investigation role, why not use that night 1 vs killing an obv town player?

To quote PF, "I vig N0". Investigation is less risky and therefore more valuable nearing lylo so I kept it. Also last time I shot N1 I had hit a Mafia Godfather so the statistics were on my side

you still did not explain why you blocked SB when you originally had him as a town read and he was on the scum wagon.

That was the middle of D1. Then he started slipping under the radar more and more. A scum was lynched last night and you claimed "one-shot" tracker. That's more than enough reason for scum to be extra cautious. So I looked at the players who were under the radar. Daemon and SB caught my eye. With ac's lynch being inevitable, I thought no scum would pass an opportunity to jump on the wagon for towncred and targeted Scott. After the deadline, I noted dys had slipped under my radar too and I was hitting my head on the desk when I saw this post. I thought I had fucked up but apparently I hit gold instead.

makes no sense...

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

2 used + 2 left = how many?

Dude my 8 year old can do simple math

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

And what PF?

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

Dashie actually thinks scum/SK hp has inadvertently caught scum/SK SB

Mass claim is happening today. So toomai goes next and popcorns.

[Daemon385]

If you killed zef then...that means mafia has killed no one?

[Toomai]

2 used + 2 left = how many?

Bulletproof is typically reflexive, not activated, so that wouldn't count.

If you killed zef then...that means mafia has killed no one?

You awake to find there is one less possible suspect. A friendlier than ordinary person was

stabbed

during the night.

I don't know what to make of this right now.

Mass claim is happening today. So toomai goes next and popcorns.

Fine.

Claim:

Vanilla Townie

Ummmmm...................I guess more people would prefer that CP claims next.

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

Fine if you don't count the BP, typically he would not be told if his BP was used (most mods don't tell you)

@mod - hypothetically speaking if there was a 1 shot BP, would your order of night actions tell the person tit was used?

If he's a BP, why would he think a doc saved someone vs his 1 shot used up?

I've been told by normal reviewers that I should not tell if their shot has been used.

[GoodCopBadCop]

CP or Dys next.

[hp [leaves]]

I do get notified when my bulletproof is used. I checked it with qwints

[hp [leaves]]

And what PF?

pokerface

[hp [leaves]]

If you killed zef then...that means mafia has killed no one?

ac also targeted kuribo that night. his only action was the factional kill. So it was a double kill.

[hp [leaves]]

Dashie actually thinks scum/SK hp has inadvertently caught scum/SK SB

Mass claim is happening today. So toomai goes next and popcorns.

two factions? yeah nah. It's pretty impossible.

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

So which are you? Scum or SK?

You aren't town. No way.

I'm leaning SK given the knifesmith/BP SKs usually are 1 shot immune (mine was in my game)

Not to mention kuribo was stabbed. Your weapon would not be a knife if you were also a knifesmith.

Mafia = bullets
SK = knife
Vig = usually not a knife.

Yeah, you are the SK, so Scott is mafia or you just pulled it out of your hat.

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

Are you a hydra?

[hp [leaves]]

Kuribo was "killed". Are normals even allowed to distinguish between kill methods?

[Jake from Rainbowdash]

You awake to find there is one less possible suspect. A friendlier than ordinary person was

stabbed during the night.

kuribo, Compulsive Neighborizer, killed Night One

ooh yeah

vote: hp

[hp [leaves]]

Are normals even allowed to distinguish between kill methods?

[hp [leaves]]

Either way ac still killed Kuribo so that flavor still makes sense.

[hp [leaves]]

I feel like a defendant in an ace attorney game