Mafiascum.net

In post 947, Selkies wrote:I believe your read is genuine.

Good; I'm not willing to vote Mara today, bur I'm willing to entertain the idea of scumMara at LyLo if not before. We good?

In post 950, Belisarius wrote:

In post 947, Selkies wrote:I believe your read is genuine.

Good; I'm not willing to vote Mara today, bur I'm willing to entertain the idea of scumMara at LyLo if not before. We good?

Probably. I think Orcinus will be ok with letting this lie for today.

- f

In post 951, Selkies wrote:Probably. I think Orcinus will be ok with letting this lie for today.

Query to both heads: do you think I'm townreading you?

I think so. You're interacting with me which to me means you're at least trying to get a read.

- f

All quotes here are of Thad's two most recent posts, formatting sucks, I'm sorry.

Matrim Cauthon. My commute power is "foxhead medallion". I was told it grew cold against my chest last night, which is how I know I was targeted by at least one one power ability. I'm sure the person who targeted me knows I am telling the truth.

Uh.... Would any of our other claimed commuters like to attest that they have an item? I know others touched on this, but having a commuter that knows when they WOULD have been hit by a role? That's more broken than Shadow Tag Chandelure in Pokemon Battles. (Which is very broken for the record)

Now you are thinking along the right lines.

Are you claiming village idiot here?

wanna bet $5?
Anyway ghost was obv town, if no one else saw that it ain't my fault.

No, because betting is against the rules. I'll have the satisfaction of your scumflip, thank you very much.
And please go back and quote posts that made ghostlin obvtown.

I don't know why he chose to call me modified commuter and not something else like "self-protecting medallion guy", but that is between you and cephrir.

I know why! It's because you made shit up.



But the biggest issue I have is this. In 866 you say "there's more to the role as well" but then in 906 you say you planned on claiming first thing today. So which is it?


~BC

In post 953, Selkies wrote:I think so. You're interacting with me which to me means you're at least trying to get a read.

In what universe does "trying to get a read" equate to townreading?

Please answer the question I actually asked.

In post 954, GoodCop_BadCop wrote:Uh.... Would any of our other claimed commuters like to attest that they have an item?

There are no other claimed communism but I've claimed 1Shot Dreamwalker and I sure as hell don't havean item.

Eh, by communism I mean commuters.

God donut auto-cucumber

In post 955, Belisarius wrote:

In post 953, Selkies wrote:

I think so.

You're interacting with me which to me means you're at least trying to get a read.

In what universe does "trying to get a read" equate to townreading?

Please answer the question I actually asked.

I said I think so. I don't think would have tried to negotiate keeping Mara alive today with someone you think is scum.

- f

So basically you don't think I'll try to negotiate with ThAd. You are correct as far as that goes.

Why did you ask if I/we think you are townreading this slot?

Beli-no no no. MS is more likely town b/c she has flavor and hasn't read.

Amrun-but she could have a mod provided fakeclaim!!!

Beli-nope, I've never been given a fake claim.

hrmmm...I mean Beli could be lying and have a town read on MS 'cause he knows that she's town. But I don't think I like a Beli lynch for today.

In post 936, GoodCop_BadCop wrote:Not really sure where he is going with the SK thing today... I would much rather lynch scum personally if we had a choice.

An SK is still scum you turds unless you are claiming that there is no sk and that your group is 3 mafia strong.

In post 952, Belisarius wrote:

In post 951, Selkies wrote:Probably. I think Orcinus will be ok with letting this lie for today.

Query to both heads: do you think I'm townreading you?

I don't really pay attention.

Beli...
quick question to you:
If you don't think the Mod gives out fakecalaims, then why do you doubt ThAd's claim? Someone would have to have some pretty big balls to fake-claim Matt, as he would definitely be in the game..
Also, you know for a fact (since you are familiar with the books) that Matt would know whether or not the One Power was used on him..
Also, Matt's "commuting" is to a different place other than the "dream world"...so if anyone would be a "real" commuter , it would be him...all of this you should know...yet you still call for his head?

I'll get to this tomorrow guys, I don't really have the time to do anything today

In post 960, Selkies wrote:Why did you ask if I/we think you are townreading this slot?

Curiosity.

In post 963, sword_of_omens wrote:Beli...
quick question to you:
If you don't think the Mod gives out fakecalaims, then why do you doubt ThAd's claim? Someone would have to have some pretty big balls to fake-claim Matt, as he would definitely be in the game..
Also, you know for a fact (since you are familiar with the books) that Matt would know whether or not the One Power was used on him..
Also, Matt's "commuting" is to a different place other than the "dream world"...so if anyone would be a "real" commuter , it would be him...all of this you should know...yet you still call for his head?

Vote: Beli

I doubt ThAd's claim because commuter doesn't fit the setup, and I don't accept the stipulation that Mat would "definitely be in this game;" There are a lot of characters in WoT, and I drew a pretty minor character. There are enough major characters in the series for every player in the game to roll one if that's how the flavour was being done.

Yes, but Matrim is a very major player in the books...you think scum would chance that he's not in the game this early? Really?
Considering you don't think scum are given fake-claims, i don't see how you would think this...

Why doesn't commuter fit the set up? Obviously doctor and commuter can't co-exist, so I understand that, but there's no reason either one shouldn't be in the game on its own.

p-edit: Once gain scum would not have to "chance" anything. They have fakeclaims, like every scum in a source material theme EVER. JEsus christ, sword, i know you know this.

I KNOW THIS....
what i'm saying is that BELI DOESN'T BELlEVE THIS...
so his logic isn't making sense...
Matt is a Major character...he was one of the 3 main characters that the Forsaken actively hunted after to try and kill...
If scum do not get fake claims (according to Beli) then why would they chance an early Matt fake-claim?
They wouldn't...

In post 969, sword_of_omens wrote:I KNOW THIS....
what i'm saying is that BELI DOESN'T BELlEVE THIS...
so his logic isn't making sense...
Matt is a Major character...he was one of the 3 main characters that the Forsaken actively hunted after to try and kill...
If scum do not get fake claims (according to Beli) then why would they chance an early Matt fake-claim?
They wouldn't...

Sword, you know that it's not true that all themed games have pre-defined fake claims for scum. MOST, yes.

But you, Beli and I (fferyllt) played DragonballZ together very recently and the scum team did NOT get fake claims in that game.

glossing over that fact looks kinda hinky.

- f

Last half of reread is being put off a bit due to [redacted]; apologies.

No, I get it now.

You're right, sword. Beli's logic doesn't add up.

@ Selkies - i KNOW that..what i'm saying is look at it from Beli's point of view..not mine...not yours...HIS logic doesn't make sense...
He has shown that he knows the flavor pretty well...He thinks that scum do not get fake claims...so why would scum Fakeclaim a huuuuge main character this early in the game? One that most likely would be in the game? From his point of view it should be a extremely ballsy gamble, yet he doesn't bat an eye...Whether the Mod gives' fakeclaims or not isn't the point here...its WHY Beli thinks it's fake...