Mafiascum.net

your vote is missing too

Gera while you're here, thoughts on Ivy and Dunn?

vc fixed

Lemons is missing as well?

Lemons unvoted

In post 919, Anya wrote:egix called me up last night and confessed he was a hyena

===

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Dunnstral

Not Voting: InsiduousLemons

don't you give me that look while slyly voting for dunnstral egix

i should at least reevaluate egix before deadline

In post 887, bugspray wrote:my dislike for osuka is personal

you'll be glad to hear you're not alone, get in line

ignoring the PR/PT absurdity because i think that can be chalked up to genuine confusion and that kind of thing happens

In post 901, bugspray wrote:maybe scum has informed roles that know something about town roles and hoods/pts.

In post 903, humaneatingmonkey wrote:They don't. I just made a mistake.

??????????

In post 924, VFP wrote:

In post 914, InsidiousLemons wrote:do you have anything more substantial on ivy?

It seems that Ivy is going for whats popular.

i think vfp is spot on here. ivy hasn't had any hot takes or voiced strong disagreement to anything, which to me is worse than just agreeing with most stuff. i think having your reads generally align with the rest of the players' isn't necessarily bad, but not disagreeing with _anything_ is strange

In post 883, bugspray wrote:

In post 880, bugspray wrote:

In post 879, osuka wrote:that all said: i have no idea what the fuck the votecount is at and i'm about to go to a friend's house here so i'll be on later to figure out what the fuck is going on

i promise to be back tomorrow morning (should be about 12h from now?)

VOTE: osuka you're hammered

In post 877, osuka wrote:

In post 859, Ivyeo wrote:

In post 858, InsidiousLemons wrote: the reverse-catchup is an interesting play from bug because it makes it substantially harder to track their process. i don't know if i like it

I'd agree, almost feels like a reason to misrepresent what is being read, even if corrected later.

this isn't a bad point, but i can't find anyplace where bugspray misrepped. they posted a fairly shallow analysis (bordering iioa) but didn't actually misrep anything too badly as far as i can tell

wtf is iioa

thought i replied to this but apparently not - iioa = information instead of analysis

In post 931, VFP wrote:

In post 929, humaneatingmonkey wrote:

In post 726, VFP wrote:I feel like T3 is trying to avoid me.

VOTE: T3
Talk to me about who's scum!
Are you scum reading Ivy or Anya?

Have you revisited T3?

T3 is town.
I was more than satisfied.

Scum T3 would have just ignored me rather than answering.

why do you say scum t3 would have ignored you? town t3 ignored everyone last game

In post 934, humaneatingmonkey wrote:is this a game where the mod is our enemy?

i dont know if this is a joke, but in case it isnt: a lying mod makes the game bastard, so no - the mod is impartial and you can completely trust what is said because this is a normal game.

i much prefer hem over dunnstral, but i'll settle for dunn if there's no other viable wagon

Dunn we all want to lynch you. I've counted. You'll be eliminated. I think it's better to claim now and leave some time for discussing your flip.

discussing your claim

In post 942, VFP wrote:

In post 940, humaneatingmonkey wrote:Just do Dunn with me

VOTE: Dunn
Okay.

@Ivy

- what's your thoughts on the Osuka claim and where do you think is a better option now?
Do you still think that Osuka slipped?

I still don't like the claim really, but I understand that town is not willing to exec there today. I still really don't see many of their posts from a towny perspective tbh, even the recent posts which just kinda feel like they're there and just to redirect attention. That being Said, Dunn is also in my scum pile for now so I'd also go there.

perspective shift?

you were confident they slipped before and now it's just that you "don't see many of their posts from a towny perspective"? you were directly questioned about the supposed slip and you still didn't even mention it

In post 971, InsidiousLemons wrote:perspective shift?

you were confident they slipped before and now it's just that you "don't see many of their posts from a towny perspective"? you were directly questioned about the supposed slip and you still didn't even mention it

Appologies, let me be more clear then.
I only can read their posts from the PoV of a scum, which woul essientally be a perspective "slip." Ig I was using hte term more liberally to describe a post that only made sense if read as if he were mafia. He went out of his way to clarify that "I never said you had to be town" whilst his posts *sure do read like it.* Their content mostly has a PoV assumed that doesn't really lead to much.

what about osuka's posts only make sense if he's mafia? see my 843. maybe osuka's posts read like he's assuming monkey to be town to , but i have yet to see a non-subjective case made for this slip/perspective shift/whatever you want to call it.

In post 973, InsidiousLemons wrote:what about osuka's posts only make sense if he's mafia? see my 843. maybe osuka's posts read like he's assuming monkey to be town to

you

, but i have yet to see a non-subjective case made for this slip/perspective shift/whatever you want to call it.

Sure it's subjective but so is everything in Mafia. His "Hypotheticals" seem to be taking a lot for granted, and they're a majority of his cases. It' like using those ifs as excuses to not have to push from his actual PoV.