Mafiascum.net

In post 948, Gamma Emerald wrote:

In post 925, Save The Dragons wrote:in my head canon FMFT just went for it

Looking back I honestly think this contradicts the events in-thread

In post 711, Free Money Free Tea wrote:Also I activated my informed ability and learned 2 things. The first thing is that there is another player with the activated informed ability in the setup. The second thing I don't know if I want to share right now.

In post 716, Free Money Free Tea wrote:I learned that x is a negative utility, y. I also learned that someone is role a. I knoe x y and a but not alignment of either.

In post 741, Free Money Free Tea wrote:It should be fine to claim. I was informed that part of gamma emeralds role is cop enabler. I was also infomed there is some role a in the setup but not the player or alignment. A is an unflippedrole.

Does this look like he “just went for it”?

kinda yeah

Well you’re fucking reaching atp

In post 949, Save The Dragons wrote:i mean you also later said this

In post 787, Gamma Emerald wrote:Yeah I don’t think FMFT is scum atp
This radio silence makes no sense otherwise

That was me responding to the fact the thread had stalled while FMFT was at E-2
That doesn’t change the fact his TR on me seemed questionable

Which while I’m at it, let me do this
VOTE: VFP
They’re D2 progression was absolute nonsense.

i don't think that i am

VOTE: gamma

Nah you definitely are
If FMFT wanted to claim something in thread like that without consulting anyone, he wouldn’t have slowrolled it like that. As such there was some rationale behind the play, meaning there was definitely a chance to talk him down. So why didn’t it happen? Can you explain THAT little issue?

i don't know why you don't seem to get if FMFT is crazy or noob scum or just a rogue soul that you maybe couldn't talk him down regardless of whether you wanted to or not

If he was a rogue soul, why pussyfoot the claim at all??? That’s the contradiction in your initial thought process!

i don't see why he wouldn't have slow rolled like that? he's trying to build up town cred by offering information but he's pretending it'll be bad for scum to know

i'm presenting options my dude i'm not trying to claim full knowledge of what happened

like i legit don't see how him slow rolling like that makes him any less of anything really if he just ignored you

you could have encouraged it at the time for all i know

Not without a proper plan
Which if you’ll look at my posting here, do you think that’s what happened?

no

hence why i think my theory of him going rogue and spilling state secrets is more likely

am i wrong? was he not ignoring you?

I think we’ve probably reached the end of our discussion of this for now
What do you think of my assertion that kyouko is conftown?

In post 962, Save The Dragons wrote:am i wrong? was he not ignoring you?

Oh so you think you’re clever, huh? Or are you just that full of yourself, despite previously asserting you’re “just presenting options”?
I know a loaded question when I see one, pal.

just having fun is all

why is kyouko conftown

does kyouko ask questions like he did while already knowing the answers? I don't think so

Also, I don't think "having fun" thoroughly explains such a putrid tactic

I think fenny is being pretty obvtown here.
Like doubling down on a caught scum is a suuuuuuper scummy thing to do that only town does because they're proud cuz they think they caught scum :O

The issue is that im not SRing gamma's replies toooooo much. its not a level of obvtown where I'd flag down the wagon and be like no lets not but it worries me. I still think gamma is prolly scum. The number of things that have to have happened for gamma to be town is just too many and im not really willing to believe that its exactly that one very specific scenario where town gamma just got totally screwed over by scum.

Like I think the game state requires a scum gamma here but my heart strings are being pulled around.

lets just wagon max instead XD
the perfect solution

i mean i was kind of hoping you'd fall for it but didn't expect you to = having fun mostly

i'd have to look at it closely but it could be theatre

I dont really care tbh. I think Dunn cracked the game open and we've caught all three scum.

I dont think theres another explanation. Like yeah I feel bad that Dunn totally fucked up the scum team. but it is what it is and its a fair scum loss here. Town prs played well. Er .... just Dunn.

Yeah I think we just wagon max and gamma. game over.

In post 967, Noraa wrote:I think fenny is being pretty obvtown here.
Like doubling down on a caught scum is a suuuuuuper scummy thing to do that only town does because they're proud cuz they think they caught scum :O

The issue is that im not SRing gamma's replies toooooo much. its not a level of obvtown where I'd flag down the wagon and be like no lets not but it worries me. I still think gamma is prolly scum. The number of things that have to have happened for gamma to be town is just too many and im not really willing to believe that its exactly that one very specific scenario where town gamma just got totally screwed over by scum.

yeah that might be the case on fenrir
while I hate to accept such a thing, the loaded question probably does come from town rather than scum