And here we are going for the play by play of pages 1-11. I am going to try and do this in the most logical way possible, but it probably won’t turn out that way to anyone else.
First things first, I am familiar with SXTLH, Cabd head, Lush Life in its separate parts, zMuffin and Action Dan. Familiar meaning that I have played with them at least once. The rest of this group are new to me.
First RVS vote was in #11 with Gaiden selfvoting, which I hate as much as anything, not indicative of anything just personally don’t like it. Kaze also votes Gaiden, calling it a serious vote? Is it a serious vote, do you find self voting in RVS to be scummy? I think that there is a time where self voting is scum motivated, like when being pressured and “cracking” but RVS is nothing.
There is a lot of fluff about drinking, nothing that would be evidence either way.
Lots of meta talking as well. I don’t mind using meta to help form reads but I think that people on this site put too much stock in meta sometimes. Desperado and I just got done playing a game, Song of Ice & Fire, where the Alfred Borden hydra of Empire and Llmarble used their known meta to appear to be town to Tammy, Tierce and Nacho to the point where they rode that first 2 day town read to the end and won the game as scum. Even in the face of evidence and compelling arguments from a scum member attempting to bus AB continued to be town read. Good players are able to use their meta against town to put off suspicions.
It seems like people got a little bogged down in Kaze saying that he already read the games that Gaiden provided for scum meta. He points out that the only posts he was interested in were the opening ones to see if scumGaiden opens up the same way as Gaiden does in this game. I do not see what the issue people are having with this line of thought. How long would it take you guys to read the first 3 posts of 3-4 games that could easily be looked up?
UFO gets a lot of attention from a few people. I wish you guys had cared that much about me when I first came onsite. Did you guys get what you wanted out of UFO? Looks like I get my answer a few posts later. Cabd, what exactly are you looking for when diving into his past games?
I agree with pieguyn in post #111 in response to Kaze saying that there is stuff to talk about in the game so far. I don’t see it either. What was serious in the first 4-5 pages of this game? He claims that his clearing of Gaiden should be something to talk about, but he would only point to the meta diving he did of his scum games to show where his read came from. Kaze talks about pie being stuck in RVS, I didn’t realize that we were out of RVS at this point in the game.
Lush Life is weak reading Kaze as scum, why?
Not a fan of Remmy talking about how his “town role pm” failed to cheer him up. As town I don’t think I have ever talked about myself receiving a town role pm. Maybe that’s just me though. And I am with morph his questions sucked dick.
zMuffin comes out of nowhere voting, then throwing down 2 town reads. Want to give a basis for any of those reads? We played together in the fruit bowl game correct? I remember not liking you much after that game, are you going to be playing the same way?
^5 Townblock of Morph/Lush/MC, I feel like we could all hang out at a bar or coffee shop and have a sitcom taped of our lives and we would be funny and interesting and have all the sex. I think we will support either of these slot in most things they attempt to do. If I had any doubts about morph their interactions with Kise would have removed them.
@Kise
- are you trying to slander my cat friend foor any particular reason or just feel like nitpicking? I was kind of intimidated looking at the player activity and seeing morph and lush at 150+ posts, knowing most will be fluff, but there are hints of genius mixed amongst them, all you have to do is look and you will find them.
What is a Rule 12 infraction, and does that have anything to do with your pie vote Kagami?
Bubba, did you just RVS vote during your read through on page 1, when the rest of the game was on page 8? What the fuck are you doing? What would have happened if a flash wagon was going on Kase at the time you did that and you hammered without even knowing it?
Yukari I think I love you a little for taking the time to find pictures of Spanish Needles and including it with a VC.
Tsukasa I don’t like the fact that you mudsling Remmys way (not that I have a town read or anything) citing his meta and then when pressured to produce evidence of stated meta you backpeddle. Then you say “why don’t we just wait for him to come in and we can watch him play?” If you have something to say back the statement up with whatever facts you have, let the group decide its relevance.
Ok, that is all I can do in one sitting for the moment.
So far I am liking Gaiden, the slot that used to house morph (didn’t realize until now that they’d been replaced), lush, and kaze has come around for me. Those are in no particular order.
Not liking- Bubba, Kisa, Tsukasa, muffinman, and the slot that used to house Remmy. Also in no particular order.
Null on everyone else.
Desperado should be coming in at some point to go over the next 10 or so pages.
