There's a significant difference between sustained lurking and lurking in bursts.In post 937, Aegor wrote:FU, sangres. SMP was at 5 votes way earlier in the game. Where were you on that bandwagon then?
We have one day left. Please explain to us why HS should be kept alive.
How often do you think newbie scum forget their reads?In post 950, Mac wrote:You can explain why if you want, meanwhile here's why my townread was decimated. Shroomish agreed with sangres townread of me a few pages back, preceded to never mention me again until the vote and, despite two people asking,In post 948, BROseidon wrote:Mac, did you get scum this game? This post is bad :/In post 922, Mac wrote:Vote: Shroomish
I'm going back here. My lean-townread has been utterly obliterated over the course of this page.is still yet to explain his vote.This is a characteristic I'd associate with newish scum who forget how they faked their reads and I think it ties in here - since he hasn't given a direct read on me, he's forgotten that he agreed with sangres townread of me. The "shit, 24 hours" comment followed by starting a brand, shiny new wagon felt extremely fake and the lack of explanation & follow up to it has left me feeling rather uneasy with the whole thing.
Vote: Shroomish
I see no reason why he would do as much intentionally as scum unless he were scum with SMP.In post 976, Jake from State Farm wrote:what about the fact that he was going after for SMP early on but once SMP got votes on him he started defending smp, to the point where he (hold on to your hats here guys) LIED about smp's play on another site.
What is the town motivation behind that?
I don't think either of us expected a good explanation.In post 951, Mac wrote:I'm a bit mystified as to why you haven't called out Shroomish for the lack of following up to your request for an explanation to be honest.In post 943, sangres wrote:You explain why he shouldn't.In post 937, Aegor wrote:FU, sangres. SMP was at 5 votes way earlier in the game. Where were you on that bandwagon then?
We have one day left. Please explain to us why HS should be kept alive.
His vote on Mac was bad, but it doesn't look scummy to us.
We're generally not in favor of lynching townreads. I know, it's a radical idea, but it might just catch on.In post 938, Aegor wrote:And why you are not willing to vote for him now.
I'm also curious as to how you see the vote as not scummy, because I'm seeing the total opposite here.
bingoIn post 978, sangres wrote:I see no reason why he would do as much intentionally as scum unless he were scum with SMP.In post 976, Jake from State Farm wrote:what about the fact that he was going after for SMP early on but once SMP got votes on him he started defending smp, to the point where he (hold on to your hats here guys) LIED about smp's play on another site.
What is the town motivation behind that?
I decided to pressure one of the low posters, so I believe SMP was the lowest at the time. I looked through his 2 completed games and noticed that he was playing differently this game (I had done the same in another game of mine that ended recently and was able to correctly identify scum so i felt this was reliable enough for pressure at the least)In post 986, Antihero wrote:so how would you know if shroom lied or not?
That's a fine reason to ask Jake for a claim if you are town, butIn post 964, sangres wrote:My initial thought was also to ask for a claim so that Jake would be forced into claiming a specific role: I think town motivation behind asking for someone to expand upon a PR claim is pretty fucking obvious and not completely and totally scum motivated like you're pretending it must be.
I also think you know that, but have decided to take this line of attack because it sounds awkward and you think you have a decent line of attack as scum.
you should be a lot more leery of wagon company like kdub, who belabors the same tired, awkward "rolefish" angle to push the shroom lynch.In post 989, Jake from State Farm wrote:I have no problem with an SMP lynch, I am just very leery that a last minute scramble is taking place to save shroom. Both of them are on my scum list so i'm really confused by Sangres's scramble
you're confusing "optimal play" and "town play"In post 991, Jake from State Farm wrote:I explained how meta got involved already, I used it as a way to pressure smp and shroom's defense of smp despite attacking him earlier was strange.
not to mention i don't see any obviously pro-town motives from him
alrightIn post 993, Jake from State Farm wrote:yeah I am but I already said I will just take a long shower if shroom does flip town.
you haven't done a good job convincing me why kdub was scum anyway, i am more leery with smp/mac being on the wagon than I am with kdub
you just confused me with this postIn post 994, Antihero wrote:you're confusing "optimal play" and "town play"In post 991, Jake from State Farm wrote:I explained how meta got involved already, I used it as a way to pressure smp and shroom's defense of smp despite attacking him earlier was strange.
not to mention i don't see any obviously pro-town motives from him
smart =/= town
dumb =/= scum
i'm confused about your whole caseIn post 997, Jake from State Farm wrote:you just confused me with this post