I see nothing particularly interesting except for notscience being scum.
Marquis begins the game by trying to start a wagon on NS. While this was the beginning of the game, and reads/wagons are not going to have a lot of evidence backing them, what makes this note worthy is how little effort Marquis puts into her read. She basically calls NS scum for no listed reason, and wants a wagon on him. Well, ok, right? It is the beginning of the game after all, early wagons without much backing are pretty common. So what happens when the wagon gets going?
Total 180 on her previous scum read of NS. Again, nothing substantial is given to why Marquis changed her position like that. She asked for a wagon on NS, got a wagon on NS, and proceeded to disband the wagon on NS. Given that this was only a couple pages into the game, and a quick lynch was very unlikely, this seems like an overreaction.
Since notscience and InflatablePie are town, and I'm feeling better about Bins, Malakittens, and Dr Pants, this will be a great lynch for today.
Throughout day 1, Marquis never had strong reads. She flipped from NS to me, then to mala, then to BBT on pretty flimsy reasons. While Marquis was the first vote on the BBT wagon, BBT was so antagonistic towards town that this would make for an easy lynch. It seems like Marquis had to give herself an "excuse" to vote BBT.
For the record, I was convinced yesterday that there was scum between the two of them.
↑InflatablePie wrote:also it should go without saying that I
would
like a response from BBT before we lynch him even though I think he's scum.
to be safe.
maybe we should just lynch me and I can go be all stumpy and shit; get it out of the way now because if BBT does flip town I'm pretty much the d2 lynch.
This was a horrible post.
Marquis hedges on Pie, essentially saying that she hedged on pie/bbt day 1. This vote is also highly convenient given BBT's stance towards Pie.
↑tree wrote:I like Pie's response a bit, but I also don't like his attempts to explain away certain parts of his ISO that were, in fact, hedging. Just because you admit to it for one post doesn't mean other just as bad instances of it aren't the same thing- hedging.
VOTE: notscience
Mala is a very strong townread here. I can see notscience as scum and I trust her ability to read him.
Once the wagon on NS starts up again, Marquis instantly joins.
This makes no sense in the context that Marquis was just scum reading NS.
↑Marquis wrote:but that's what i've been doing this whole game and i'm town
VOTE: ns
And then back to voting NS.
Essentially, Marquis has had highly convenient reads the entire game. Her reads move around quite a bit, and seem to always align with whichever way the majority happens to be thinking. She needed to post fluff before voting BBT and Majiffy, and pushed both of those lynches despite not doing much actual scum hunting. There are also inconsistencies within Marquis's line of thinking. For example, scum reading NS/sheeping mala, then asking NS to join her on a majiffy wagon.
VOTE: Marquis
Posted: Mon Sep 15, 2014 4:49 pm
by Bins
I'm tempted just to sheep the effort. Will look closely at this game tomorrow when I don't have a test.
Posted: Mon Sep 15, 2014 4:56 pm
by Marquis
yeah, i think i'm town
Posted: Mon Sep 15, 2014 4:58 pm
by Bins
Can I ask for everyone's reads in a nice and orderly fashion?
Posted: Mon Sep 15, 2014 5:00 pm
by Marquis
sure give me until tomorrow to figure out which mislynches i can get on which days
Posted: Mon Sep 15, 2014 5:01 pm
by Marquis
sorry that was uncalled for. i'm in a fuck-everything-especially-complex-roots-and-mislynches mood tonight
i'm going to try and do a full iso reread and give reads by tomorrow night / wednesday morning
Posted: Mon Sep 15, 2014 5:13 pm
by Dr Pants
↑Bins wrote:Can I ask for everyone's reads in a nice and orderly fashion?
Pie
Bins
Mala
Bulge
-------
NS
Marquis
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:11 pm
by The Bulge
↑Bins wrote:Can I ask for everyone's reads in a nice and orderly fashion?
Town
Bins
Pants
Pie
Mala
notsci
Marquis
Scum
Or something like that
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:11 pm
by The Bulge
↑Dr Pants wrote:K guys, so I reread the first couple of days and I'm pretty sure Marquis is scum. Here's a wall of text for you:
I see nothing particularly interesting except for notscience being scum.
Marquis begins the game by trying to start a wagon on NS. While this was the beginning of the game, and reads/wagons are not going to have a lot of evidence backing them, what makes this note worthy is how little effort Marquis puts into her read. She basically calls NS scum for no listed reason, and wants a wagon on him. Well, ok, right? It is the beginning of the game after all, early wagons without much backing are pretty common. So what happens when the wagon gets going?
Total 180 on her previous scum read of NS. Again, nothing substantial is given to why Marquis changed her position like that. She asked for a wagon on NS, got a wagon on NS, and proceeded to disband the wagon on NS. Given that this was only a couple pages into the game, and a quick lynch was very unlikely, this seems like an overreaction.
Since notscience and InflatablePie are town, and I'm feeling better about Bins, Malakittens, and Dr Pants, this will be a great lynch for today.
Throughout day 1, Marquis never had strong reads. She flipped from NS to me, then to mala, then to BBT on pretty flimsy reasons. While Marquis was the first vote on the BBT wagon, BBT was so antagonistic towards town that this would make for an easy lynch. It seems like Marquis had to give herself an "excuse" to vote BBT.
For the record, I was convinced yesterday that there was scum between the two of them.
↑InflatablePie wrote:also it should go without saying that I
would
like a response from BBT before we lynch him even though I think he's scum.
to be safe.
maybe we should just lynch me and I can go be all stumpy and shit; get it out of the way now because if BBT does flip town I'm pretty much the d2 lynch.
This was a horrible post.
Marquis hedges on Pie, essentially saying that she hedged on pie/bbt day 1. This vote is also highly convenient given BBT's stance towards Pie.
↑tree wrote:I like Pie's response a bit, but I also don't like his attempts to explain away certain parts of his ISO that were, in fact, hedging. Just because you admit to it for one post doesn't mean other just as bad instances of it aren't the same thing- hedging.
VOTE: notscience
Mala is a very strong townread here. I can see notscience as scum and I trust her ability to read him.
Once the wagon on NS starts up again, Marquis instantly joins.
This makes no sense in the context that Marquis was just scum reading NS.
↑Marquis wrote:but that's what i've been doing this whole game and i'm town
VOTE: ns
And then back to voting NS.
Essentially, Marquis has had highly convenient reads the entire game. Her reads move around quite a bit, and seem to always align with whichever way the majority happens to be thinking. She needed to post fluff before voting BBT and Majiffy, and pushed both of those lynches despite not doing much actual scum hunting. There are also inconsistencies within Marquis's line of thinking. For example, scum reading NS/sheeping mala, then asking NS to join her on a majiffy wagon.
VOTE: Marquis
dis what I say
I feel like I was the only person scumreading tree on Day 1
VOTE: Marquis
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:15 pm
by Bins
town
The Bulge
InflatablePie
Dr Pants
{notscience
Marquis
Malakittens}
scum
i see dis
but i can see pants scum as well like honestly the only two people i dont see as scum are bulge and pie
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:41 pm
by InflatablePie
town
Bins/Bulge
Pants
ns
mala/marquis
scum
I'll at least wait to L-1 marquis til tomorrow evening, in case of ~shenanigans~
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:50 pm
by Marquis
watch out guys i have a nasty habit of selfhammering as town
ill bbl but in the meantime! dont vote me if you dont want a town selfhammer ;]]
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 3:58 pm
by InflatablePie
well in that case
VOTE: marquis
Posted: Tue Sep 16, 2014 4:59 pm
by Malakittens
I don't even right now.
lolnope.
I wish bins would actually place her vote on me rather than sidelining her read on me and keep waffling on it.