But it's not a negative thing. I still love playing it and love the social aspect a lot but I am relatively bad at scum.
Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2018 3:45 pm
by Mathdino
your game history shows otherwise
the problem is you can't defend yourself against town players using good townhunting/PoE (cough derpy hooves)
not to like
encourage this
but you'd be in a winning position had you killed someone other than the IC
because my being alive at all created 2 or 3 MORE ICs just by good townhunting
Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2018 3:54 pm
by the worst
Better I discuss this in more detail postgame.
Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2018 3:56 pm
by Judge Joseph Dredd
@Dino: What makes you think he had a say in it? I'd be surprised if he actually flipped main scum at this point.
1- He said he wasn't touching UD, signaling he knows UD is scum. Main scum don't know their traitor.
2- UD offered himself to be lynched over TW, and if UD is he traitor it doesn't help because he knows his partners. If he is the main scum though it could be WIFOME'd that he "thought" it was the case but he couldn't have known.
But I'm really arguing for the sake of arguing to pass the time until we get a flip.
Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2018 3:59 pm
by the worst
#stilltown
Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2018 4:00 pm
by the worst
I prolly picked a bad day to drunkpost I've committed myself to shitposting
Posted: Fri Apr 13, 2018 4:01 pm
by Mathdino
meh i'm probably wrong on the 3rd partner but w/e
just don't be idiots tomorrow
neverlynchpool goes, in order
Nauci - if you lynch this i'll bite your head off
JJD - solidly outside his scumrange, no way he plays traitor like this
brassherald - his meta solidly excludes bussing, and his whole "wait TW you fullclaimed your role on page 1?" does not read like buddy interactions
Wisdom - he townslipped not knowing whether scum could allocate their modifications. could theoretically still be traitor i guess. have seen him bus twice in a row before, just be wary
In post 978, Judge Joseph Dredd wrote:@Dino: What makes you think he had a say in it? I'd be surprised if he actually flipped main scum at this point.
1- He said he wasn't touching UD, signaling he knows UD is scum. Main scum don't know their traitor.
2- UD offered himself to be lynched over TW, and if UD is he traitor it doesn't help because he knows his partners. If he is the main scum though it could be WIFOME'd that he "thought" it was the case but he couldn't have known.
But I'm really arguing for the sake of arguing to pass the time until we get a flip.
the fuck?
UD offering himself up makes more sense if he knows his partner than if he doesn't
when town is tunneling town, you fucking let them, you don't draw alllll the attention to yourself
tbh TW could've just picked recruit traitor or some shit, it's a common addition to rolecop
Nauci, sorry about townreading you that hard, but you also made it super super obvious you were a PR, and I legit thought JJD was vig before you lowkey claimed it.
Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 1:13 am
by Mathdino
In post 993, brassherald wrote:MariaR stayed on Beef the entirety of day 1, pretty much. Is it in her meta to hard bus someone?
it's in her meta to be good at scum
basically the only confirmed townies are you, me, and JJD
you because it's NOT in your meta to hardbus (although i fully expect you to next time you roll scum because of this conversation )
JJD because way out of his scumrange
me because while i do bus, i don't bus everyone as a traitor when that runs a very real risk of fucking everyone over
Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 2:48 am
by Judge Joseph Dredd
@Dino: We don't
know
RW was main scum still. He could've been the recruited traitor and the main Mafia is JOAT, BP or even Goon.
That said I think the massclaim is a good idea. If we do have another PR (or two of them) the game is likely solves.
We either have a Roleblocker, a Tracker, both or neither. Obviously if neither then we're all VTs. If we have a RB then they blocked someone yesterday, and that someone is clear (with a very small chance of being a lucky b#$%@# JOAT who precisely used his shot last night). The same goes for the Tracker (they have an inno unless the JOAT Mafia used the Ninja kill last night). If BOTH then at least one of them has a clear, but the point is they'd be confirmed townies themselves.
Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 2:49 am
by brassherald
Can we just not spew claiming patterns for the scum before we mass claim?
Posted: Mon Apr 16, 2018 2:52 am
by Mathdino
In post 998, brassherald wrote:Can we just not spew claiming patterns for the scum before we mass claim?
