Newbie 1992 | Game Over

[Menalque]

like does wu make sense as scum outside of mara!scum?

[Datisi]

i would say yes, but i might be tunnelled on a townie that's not bothering to read, not trying to debunk any arguments, that keeps repeating shit cases like a broken record, and who's probably set the world record at misreps per minute, but... ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[Karnage]

Vote Count 1.20

Marashu (4) ~

Menalque, Datisi, Maduisha, skitter30,

Datisi (2) ~

team rocket queen, GeneralWu,

clidd (1) ~

word321,

skitter30 (1) ~

Marashu,

Not voting (1) ~

clidd,

With 9 alive it's 5 to lynch

Deadline: (expired on 2020-03-27 19:08:54)

V/LA:

• skitter30 - Fridays and Saturdays & mental health vla for a couple of days (beginning 3/23)

[Menalque]

darn it guys you're actually lynching marashu
this case is so bad rn

this is not a post that's meant to farm towncred upon town!mara flip but doesn't actually convince any of us not to lynch mara. not at all.

this is like moderately good scumplay tho imo, do you think that with everything else Wu is doing (per your post after this) that they're also subtle enough to try to farm towncred by defending a mislynch vocally

[Datisi]

isn't Wu like at least a moderately good scum player tho? like i remember seeing him say that the last scumgame that he lost ended his perfect scum winrecord or smt

[Datisi]

also, making that one "omg mara lynch so bad" post and then disappearing back into the void is really not a *vocal* defense of the (mis)lynch. lukewarm at best.

[Menalque]

GW, can you chart the thought process for me that got you from here:

@Marashu do you actually think the mason claim was legit

lmao
so you actually think the mason claim is legit?

oh I thought you meant that it's obviously fake if TRQ were scum

I agree that marashu and TRQ are not w/w but that's mostly because I think TRQ is town.

team rocket queen's tone is pretty towny.
her response to my posts earlier about reading past games seems pretty innocent, too.

to here:

VOTE: marashu

why are you voting marashu

were you voting randomly though
or was it a legitimate vote

i did not choose marashu at random

then why did you vote marashu
you should provide a reason when you vote.

also why are people voting marashu again what did he do

[Menalque]

isn't Wu like at least a moderately good scum player tho? like i remember seeing him say that the last scumgame that he lost ended his perfect scum winrecord or smt

I couldn't find this anywhere in his iso, only him talking about the number of past games he has and that he randed scum a lot

[Menalque]

UNVOTE:

[Datisi]

isn't Wu like at least a moderately good scum player tho? like i remember seeing him say that the last scumgame that he lost ended his perfect scum winrecord or smt

I couldn't find this anywhere in his iso, only him talking about the number of past games he has and that he randed scum a lot

I see we have a few newly-registered players in this game.

What is everyone's prior experience in playing mafia (forum mafia or otherwise)?
Do you prefer playing as town or scum?

This is my 3rd game of forum mafia. I have also previously played browser-based mafia (epicmafia) and enjoy hidden identity board games
I prefer to play as town. I enjoy solving/deducing who is who in the zoo. I find being mafia can be stressful.

I've played like 12 games on mafiauniverse and artofproblemsolving.com and I have a

100% win rate as mafia

:O

DAMN IT I LOST MY STREAK

[Maduisha]

I'm also okay with pressuring GWu, because as I said before, I find him the scummiest, despite all the stuff Marashu did. Although I thought only Datisi was with me on that.

[Datisi]

Madu, you just played with scum!Wu. how does he compare in this game and in the other one?

[Maduisha]

In that game, he replied to people more than generate discussion himself. In part because he was scum, and also in part because another player was tunneling him hard almost from the moment he appeared. He posted stuff without substance (like redundant information about the setup), also constantly promised to come back later, or look at X person's ISO, and never delivered.

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to quote myself from that thread, but before I voted him and ended the game, I made a post about the things I found scummy or towny out of the two players in lylo with me, which I think summarizes it.

[Maduisha]

I feel like as scum in that game, he posted more wall-like posts than he is doing right now. But he's keeping those "I'll come back later" kind of posts now and I'm not sure anymore.

[Datisi]

The game is over, I'm pretty sure you're allowed. (since i self-quoted from 2 different games that are over and i don't think i've been banned yet so)

[Maduisha]

before I get called out again for "not reading the thread" i'm only replying to this post right now since I just saw it and it looks interesting. I'll post more later.

if someone refuses to hammer once we have 4 votes on and i'm confident it's an all town wagon then I'm going to start calling refusal to declare intent a scumclaim

isn't this the equivalent of saying "if you don't agree with me you're mafia"?

Like, in this post he does it again. Promise about coming back, as if he needs to justify absence. And I find it funny that he's mocking the thing that is causing scumreads on him, but still does the thing anyway.

[Maduisha]

Okay, here it is:

Spoiler:

As I see it...

Positive/things that I think are

townie

from GW:

- Relatively high post rate.

- Did not participate in any mislynch (or any lynching at all, I actually don't know how to read this, but I'll put it in here).

- Focused me (with reasons) when people were concentrating on 72, and didn't give in to JV's attempts to manipulate his vote during that day. I consider this a townie thing because it indicates authenticity of thought, but it could also just be agreement with Ceejay to go in different directions for safety reasons.

Negative/things that I believe to be

scummy

:

- Early interaction with Ceejay feels weird. The question "why do you think I'm townie" makes me think there's some intent to establish self as townie quickly if his other read was correct too.

- Some fluff posts here and there that I kind of feel are thought to pad the conversation and feel like he's still there (like the two talking about the mafia roles in the layout, the agreement posts...), although he does have more substancial posts as well.

- A couple of posts in the vein of "I was going to do x, but I'm busy now/I'll do x tomorrow" that were not fulfilled. Everyone has a life an I can't expect them to prioritize this over real world stuff, but it also sort of feels like fluff posts... (I'll quote those if necessary, I'm just lazy to do so now).

- I kind of feel like Ceejay wanted to bus his partner because he had no other choice because of multiple people claiming SR on GWu, as I said before.

The first point refers to him asking his scum partner for reads on himself during RVS. The second point is that he posted a lot by quoting someone and saying "I agree" and nothing else, and also that he made 2 useless posts about the role layout (that I can find later if you want), and the third is what he's doing right now on this game as well.

[Maduisha]

Note that as scum, he didn't ride any wagon that ended in lynch, that's there too... not sure if it's useful.

[Datisi]

Now I'm thinking of the post he made earlier in this game saying "Meta isn't useful in reading me pls don't read me by meta"

[Menalque]

isn't Wu like at least a moderately good scum player tho? like i remember seeing him say that the last scumgame that he lost ended his perfect scum winrecord or smt

I couldn't find this anywhere in his iso, only him talking about the number of past games he has and that he randed scum a lot

I see we have a few newly-registered players in this game.

What is everyone's prior experience in playing mafia (forum mafia or otherwise)?
Do you prefer playing as town or scum?

This is my 3rd game of forum mafia. I have also previously played browser-based mafia (epicmafia) and enjoy hidden identity board games
I prefer to play as town. I enjoy solving/deducing who is who in the zoo. I find being mafia can be stressful.

I've played like 12 games on mafiauniverse and artofproblemsolving.com and I have a

100% win rate as mafia

:O

DAMN IT I LOST MY STREAK

oh, I ctrl+f'd "scum" not "mafia"

[Menalque]

I'm not sure if I'm allowed to quote myself from that thread, but before I voted him and ended the game

if the game is over you can quote from it

[Menalque]

you know what I'm thinking

[Menalque]

VOTE: generalwu

[Menalque]

Choo Choo goes the wagon train

[Menalque]

ALLLLLLLL ABOAAAAAARD