Mafiascum.net

Like, that gets missed once, then okay, whatever, everyone makes mistakes. But continuing to ignore it while pushing this false idea about why I started changing my mind is not appreciated.

(The "false idea" being that I changed my mind because of outside influence)

In post 974, Kilgamayan wrote:@N3R:

In post 965, Kilgamayan wrote:I think it bears repeating that I myself was starting to doubt my Tuxedo case. It's not like the decision was

only

"oh other people aren't buying it so it must be wrong", that's merely the only part of my 951 that people have focused on today. In that same post, I state that I myself was having doubts about the validity of the case, independent of how others were engaging (or not engaging) with it. The two things together were enough to convince me to look elsewhere. I'm starting to think this got missed.

Granted I missed that part, but it doesn't really alter my point.

Changing your opinion about a slot is fine, but it's the reasons why that matter.

So I should have kept the opinion I was starting to doubt on my own, then?

What's your solve right now, if Tux is being reconsidered in your head?

In post 978, Kilgamayan wrote:So I should have kept the opinion I was starting to doubt on my own, then?

You are reconsidering Tux now at a time when it's becoming clear that he probably won't be lynched and that feels like ur backing off. And then you use reasoning that smells fishy, while still leaving the door open to get back to him later if opinions change.

Who would you like to see lynched and who gets the hammer, Kilga?

My best guess at this juncture is PP + Hoctac. See my 962 for my current opinion on PP. I looked through a Hoctac + clidd/PP Day 1 iso yesterday and their interactions were somewhat limited and fairly casual when they happened, and some of PP's stated suspicion of me is based on things Hoctac has done, which I have no control over.

Fake edit: Why are you asking me who I want lynched when I already posted 962? If you're going to gun for me this hard, shouldn't you be reading all of my posts? (RE: Hammer, either of them can hammer the other, but I'd prefer Hoctac hammer PP.)

We haven't played (a lot?) with each other I think. This is all Ico btw. I read but I tend to miss stuff sometimes.
I don't agree that I'm gunning for you hard here.

And I asked for lynch and hammer, i don't recall that being said by you so far.

maybe i am actually

i don't think there's a lot of teams that actually make a ton of sense rn

Well, odds are good we haven't played with each other at all, unless either of you are an alt/remake of someone that was in one of FakeGod's Touhou UPicks from 2015.

My preferred lynch is PP, which is why my vote/vote was there in 962. I figured this was clear, but possibly not, given what is likely different approaches to the game. My apologies for losing my cool over it.

*my vote/unvote

In post 987, Kilgamayan wrote:Well, odds are good we haven't played with each other at all, unless either of you are an alt/remake of someone that was in one of FakeGod's Touhou UPicks from 2015.

My preferred lynch is PP, which is why my vote/vote was there in 962. I figured this was clear, but possibly not, given what is likely different approaches to the game. My apologies for losing my cool over it.

We are def not in agreement with PP.
And it was clear you want PP, but given the setup determing the hammer can be critical.

What makes you say PP town, then? Perhaps we can start there.

i dunno if it's gonna be of much use to you

basically i played with scum!PP in the last run of this setup, and then a bit after i played with town!PP in furret's bizzare adventure 2 where he was feeling very very different which let me townread him pretty early on

granted he got shot on night 1 there so i don't know his lategame but nothing he's said so far is making me ping onto scum!PP

also ico's too got a town!PP gutfeel

have you given reasons for why you think he's scum (or whatever your stance is)? sorry if you have, i haven't exactly read since the last time i posted

-D

Primarily it's that he's held things that aren't NAI again Koba and then myself. Like, nothing he has accused either of us ogf has been scummy behavior as opposed to derptown or simply a different playstyle. I also figured he would have changed tack after Koba flipped town but the approach to me has been largely similar even if the specific details are different.

*that are NAI

God I can't type this morning.

ok, can you link me to what you see as that?

-D

Sure, but it might be a bit, since I'm back on the clock. Sorry for the delay.

Lol kilga. There is absolutely no scum motivation for anything that I have done this game. I mean - if I was scum, I have been taking the path of most resistance.

I don’t believe you believe that I am really scum. That transition from Tuxedo is gross. I will gladly hammer you.

Saves me the trouble of asking you, at least!

@N3R: Sorry again for the delay. I'll start putting that list together now.

Sigh, I have no idea who scum is in this game. Kilga, I was townreading your tone for most this game but suddenly you feel a lot more apologetic.

Roses, could you give some reasons for why Penpow is playing like his townself, and how his scum game is different to this?