A Clash of Kings - A Divided Kingdom

[Faraday]

wrong account

[Faraday]

See below.

[Faraday]

MOD I was wondering all game: Was I supposed to be a miller character of sorts?

Yeah, given the watcher is probably more 'townie' we felt the hound would add a bit of LOL LANNISTER to the game, especialy with the namecop. Littlefinger was also supposed to look dodgy as a namecop and as a townie, but that never panned out as it happens.


COMMENTS? I DON'T HAVE ANY.

[Faraday]

Okay so for reals :

Stuff I'd do different, write the win conditions slightly better. I still think 1/1's a draw no matter what the win conditions are though, maybe that's just me, a lot of people in the dead qt disagreed but I really couldn't award the game any other way. I mean I guess I could have a draw condition in role pm's too, but that seems unneeded, I guess I just assumed everyone thought like me. Your fault for not (this is a joke, calm the fuck down)

Set-up was p okay. I'd probably take out the doctor if ran again, or maybe give the scumteams a 1-shot ninja/1-shot strongman each (Lannisters/Greyjoys) to counteract the opposing teams and the towns powers.

Hope you enjoyed the flavour, a fair bit of effort was put in to that to make sure it was fine.

Maclock deserves a title - his fakeclaims are brillaint, even the ones discussed in the qt were amazing, the gendry hider in particular was great I thought.

This whole not playing to win thing is being overblown, I can completely see where the scum were coming from here. Also all that stuff with the win cons...I guess I think that point cow brought up was irrelevant to the draw, it was overblow unneccessarily, Seacore was right the first time as far as I'm concerned. Lesson learned to make it fully clear in the future.

Thanks to SpyreX for modding, he made the set-up less...killy death die, yes SPYREX made it less bloddthirsty. I know rit?

Town had too many players who played bad. That's what lost it for them really. I mean, without naming any names I think there's a few townies who could have done way way way way more.

LMP for best new player.

MINA BE MORE CONFIDENT OKAY?

Uh this is all stream of conciousness. I think prods and all that sort of shit went well, night deadlines were always on time, apart from one night or so when it was a few hours late (sue me).

[Faraday]

SpyreX for reviewing/giving us a votecount! not modding! lol.

[Faraday]

Also Lannisters/Greyjoy's get first preference for Pre-in's to A Storm of Swords (the best book fwiw). It'll probably be around same number of players, maybe 1 less. Not 100% sure so that's 13 pre-in slots I guess.

Seacore: it's only based on book 3, it's just book 3 was split in certain areas.


Um, yeah. I'll think of more stuff later.

[Faraday]

oh yeah the modding quicktopic has a fair few posts too, prob won't be linking that due to our mod bitching about certain things

As for the 'Lol grew new win con' argument in the graveyard, well, that's not really through, grew a draw con maybe? And in fairness most of the dead in the graveyard are town too, so yeh. There really was no other way to end the game as far as I'm concerned, I know seacore considered a 3-way draw, but that just seems weird to me. So yeah.

I'm really happy with the game, I felt it was complicated without being completely overblown ala a tar/kinetic game.

A Storm of Swords with a little fine tuning will be better, don't miss out yo!

[Faraday]

"OOOOOO, don't you think so-and-so could be a such-and-such!"
"Idk, why don't we lynch who is acting scummy?"
"No effing way, I'm voting because the name they claim doesn't match what I think their role would be based on the book"
"..."

Now THAT I understand. I mean Raivann claimed vig day 1, I get that it matched his character but he was pretty scummy and probably should have been lynched (it was a bad claim anyway, vig generally is for scum). I think most mods intentionally put in stuff to make things tricky, Sandor Clegane being town was one of those too as was Littlefinger. So yeah, that's fair enough I guess.

[Faraday]

Oh and thanks to all the players who stuck with the game and also the replacements who helped out. We were pretty good for the most part on flakes, especially for a large game.

[Faraday]

I think watcher's more powerful yeah, on the other hand Lannisters probably got slightly stronger fake claimn characters (Caetlyn;s a POV character) and there's at least the posibillity of Tyrion being town in a flavour bastard game, whereas the Greyjoys are all pretty close apart from Theon (but um, he's a prick so). In hindsight I probably would have given scum a tracker instead of a watcher, and given the town a weak info role (reporter) and taken out the doc. Still eh, there's always room to improve for next time. Appreciate all the feedback too.

And Mellisandre's cool though Percy...that's gotta be taken into consideration (plus the fact she helps kill a Greyjoy and Lannister means she's obviously not one of them)

[Faraday]

Also Pre-ins for ASOS can be PM'd now if ya want, I know seacore said we're not taking them yet but shhh he'll never know Also thanks to seacore for co-modding this thing, thank fuck for him or the game could have suffered a lack of mod attention or never got off the ground, there were a few times it was hard to keep up with everything but we managed really well.

[Faraday]

Mikujin's softclaim would have been great...in a 1 scumteam game, it just came across as a new player playing a power role and unsure how to approach it. But in multi scum, ya.

[Faraday]

This sounds like it was a pretty epic game, with a pretty epic ending.

I feel very sorry that I have no knowledge of the flavor.

But I liked how Magna and Macavitar played the final night.

<3 all around.

READ THE BOOKS REALLY QUICK?

[Faraday]

CSL is ridiculous. He doesn't seem to think like a normal human being.

That's because I'm autistic. You have a problem with that?

ftr this was THE MOST uncomfortable moment ever. It also made me laugh , just because of the 'Do you have a problem with that?' line, I mean there's not really a lot you can say in response is there? Note I'm not laughing at autism. Got it?

[Faraday]

Yeah more than likely.

Lol @ no one saying Dany (b/c she's uninteresting!)