What exactly is the mafia win condition? Eliminate all town or gain 50% majority on town, something like that? Even if it says ''gain 50% of total votes out of all factions'' they both win a full one since they ended up with 50%. IMO.
Kudos to the scum for dodging the prisoners dilemma fallacy...
Oh and i thought mina might appreciate this Herodotus quote; "Far better it is to have a stout heart always and suffer one's share of evils, than to be ever fearing what may happen."