Goofbash Invitational (Game Over)

[chamber]

wait wait wait wait wait. Mina you are confirming that Fate is the last member of your neighbourhood?

Goddamnit Fate this is what happens when you have no credability.

[chamber]

Ok so you can't qoute it, but can you at least explain the exchange that happened in detail, especially what Katsuki had been talking about in the QT before fate showed up. Thanks.

[chamber]

Actually scratch that, it will just detract more from the thread, Fate is clearly still full of it.

[chamber]

About Fate/Mina:

Let me direct you to this :

I guess she didn't get the fake claim PM Patrick promised her!

About split role/alignment:

As far as we understand roles were determined and then alignments were determined randomly making the presumption that there has to be a scum in the neighbourhood completely false.

[chamber]

Not going to address the mods answer?

[chamber]

Patrick was less uncertain when mentioning telling you in scumchat (which would be like 24h + of lurking not 7) when talking to us privately, I can see now that he's probably just covering his own ass cause he isn't certain, which is fine. You completely ignoring his response however bothers me. Even if only to deny seeing it in scumchat 24h+ before.

[chamber]

Yeaaaah.... what exactly haven't we commented on? I've been happy with our contribution. You singling us out here looks like a bad attempt to deflect attention.

[chamber]

Better attempt to deflect attention.

[chamber]

If you're one of my top suspects why would I let you direct the flow of things away from yourself?

[chamber]

Yeaaaah.... what exactly haven't we commented on? I've been happy with our contribution. You singling us out here looks like a bad attempt to deflect attention.

You pointed out that Fate had lost all credibility while he was arguing with Mina, but I don't remember you revising your stance on the whole Fate/Mina thing after I specifically replied to your post saying that Fate's version was correct.

Mina even more obvious town,

Fate even more obvious idiot

, TBM still scum.

We speak for each other i.e. I still think Fate is full of it. You haven't actually confirmed what he's using as damning evidence (the role pm difference) and based on what he's said I'm to assume your pm had something to the effect of 'any scum in the neighbourhood got a copy of the town pm' which would make the entire thing completely ridiculous.

[chamber]

Presumably you had a reason to attack Mina before she misreped the QT, if not the role PM difference what exactly is the reason you were voting her at the start of the day?

[chamber]

@TBM

You say you don't think fate is gambiting several times, but then directly oppose his 'its me or mina' statement, which is the only thing anyone's claimed he's gambiting about, care to explain what the fuck you actually think? (especially now that Fates outed that he was full of it[post has been in draft format for most of the day])

@Nikanor

In this post you attack fate, and then 1 later you ask him if he'll vote TBM with you?? and then when you actually vote tbm you say its for something that happened after the previous post. Please explain all of that.

[chamber]

I meta'd TBM pretty extensively before our unvote, not going to call him guaranteed town, but his play here, at least superficially, looks nothing like his previous scum play that I came across.

More Nikanor votes!

[chamber]

Something kind of bugs me about the dram posts, like he knew faraday wasn't lying about being a vengeful.

@Albert

When did your opinion of TBM completely flip? You were voting him before faraday, then faraday stuff happened, now you are defending him?

[chamber]

Don't spam the thread please guys. Reck and Fate do enough of that.

[chamber]

Where the fuck is this fate wagon comming from?

[chamber]

CES what do you currently think of vitamin?

[chamber]

Did someone just do a fucking pbpa? Excuse me while I go throw up.

[chamber]

Those things don't seem like typical sens to you? Do you have much experience with him?

[chamber]

My experience with sens is limited, but from what I saw at goofbash I can say 2 things, he's always very sure of himself, and he sometimes does things I view as being completely irrational. With that in mind all the things you've mentioned just seem like him being himself. Not meta town, meta null.

[chamber]

CokeDeity was registered over 2 weeks ago, still inactive. Mith has been PMed.

[chamber]

This game was aggrovating to read along with after day 1

[chamber]

RECK AND DRAM, wtf @ out of thread communication if thats real, at both of you.

[chamber]

RECK AND DRAM, wtf @ out of thread communication if thats real, at both of you.

yeah no, miscommunication error that was misconstrued, carry on

Please be far more explicit in explaining.

[chamber]

I'm sorry for being a stick in the mud but I'm still not over this entire out of thread communication thing. Can one of you come in here and explain step by step what exactly went on and where the misunderstandings occured?

[chamber]

I'm trying to be objective here. As Reck put it I think both players should be modkilled to be honest. Specifically asking about a game you're in with someone else, and then hiding that fact untill you've lost is clearly just as bad (if not more bad) than answering. Dram, if you thought this was a big offence (I'll accept that reck didn't perhaps) Why didn't you bring this up earlier?

[chamber]

PS our neighbour QT is awesome.

[chamber]

w/e dropping this, I don't care enough to deal with the headache, but I think you guys should probably avoid playing together in the future.

[chamber]

I think the 2 things that really won the game for the mafia here were the traitor playing amazingly well, even if I didn't think so at the time. By doing what he did he basically got 3 competent town killed, thats a lot, it really enabled your strategy of killing everyone that was on to you. The other thing was mini never succesfully bodyguarding. Had he gotten it off at any point it would've been a very different game.

[chamber]

too*