SMBM II: Defense of Yoshi's Island (Final! MVPs announced!)

[Ranmaru]

Catching up in short bursts. (To avoid being replaced xD)

I feel that there can't be two townies who ask the same exact anti-town question in a row. We can PoE through them if need be, but there's so much scum motivation between the two of them that I feel one of them need to die.

I don't see any scum motivation.

VOTE: WLC HOPPSTER TOWNCRED IS WORTH EVERYTHING.

>> Hoppster: SHEEP ME FOR TOWN-CRED <votes: Wrathchild>
>> Hiplop: OKAY HOPPSTER <vote:WLC>

wat

one moar chance for town-cred hiplop

don't blow it


UNVOTE:
VOTE: Isa

So much scum motivation I can't even see it
UNVOTE:
VOTE: DemonHybrid

This looks like a vote that is deliberately vague so that it could equally be defended in retrospect as either a serious vote or a non-serious vote.


DH's derp is null, I think. But if he's scum projectmatt is town (assuming non-multi-scum).

I chuckled at Hoppster's town cred vote mess up thing. I think he confused DH's post with yours. (DH was the one who voted WLC)

I covered this, Hoppster.

Not to a satisfactory degree...

With one person, you were happy to write it off as 'ok maybe newb' (you say yourself there is only "that little bit of scum motivation", but with two people (both who have joined within the last 2 months and are thusly new to the site) you weren't? That seems like a jump to me.

I think it was ok for DH to pressure the newbs. Can't let them get away.

Vote: Isa

.

That last reply was fishy and deflective.

Fishy, how?

and also i do read the thread, i just quote things of interest.

Vote: DemonHybrid

I'll do the same.

That's delightfully annoying and if you're going to do that EVERY catch up we are going to have a problem.

Problem?

[Ranmaru]

Just in case you didn't know, the vote on David wasn't a "joke". It was a pressure builder and an attempt to get the discussion out of RVS.

I'm not going to jot down a list of my reads because I would be lying if I told you I had a specific scum read.

With that being said..

Unvote

Bunnylover

for this post:

@Sunset: I do not do catch-up post. Kinda useless to make a stand on something that has already ended imo.

How exactly is that scum motivation? Is it possible for town to say that?

VOTE: WLC HOPPSTER TOWNCRED IS WORTH EVERYTHING.

>> Hoppster: SHEEP ME FOR TOWN-CRED <votes: Wrathchild>
>> Hiplop: OKAY HOPPSTER <vote:WLC>

wat

one moar chance for town-cred hiplop

don't blow it


UNVOTE:
VOTE: Isa

So much scum motivation I can't even see it
UNVOTE:
VOTE: DemonHybrid

This looks like a vote that is deliberately vague so that it could equally be defended in retrospect as either a serious vote or a non-serious vote.


DH's derp is null, I think. But if he's scum projectmatt is town (assuming non-multi-scum).

Vote: Hoppster

I don't see how applying your own meta to him would make him scum. I also see you being hypocritical in critisizing DH for not considering Vifam and that other dude as new, but you yourself don't even consider that Isa may be doing that because he is new. That's also not a scum tactic because I did the same myself in Into Africa as town, so essentially it's null to me. I don't like your push. What have you thought of Isa's recent play?

Reads:

Town:

Soup, Kcd, DH.

Scum: Hoppster

[Ranmaru]

I'm keeping my eye on Ranmaru.

Why? Address me. What is your issue with me?

[Ranmaru]

Mod: I'm going to be Limited Access from tommorow until the hurricane calms down. So if I'm out for too long, you can replace me if needed but don't blacklist me ; - ;

[Ranmaru]

Yes it was indeed a speed catch up.

Here are some opinions:

Soup's push on you was wrong. But he's town to me because he was pressuring you.

Dh's accusation early in RVS was wrong. Like Soup said, it was null.

You sort of sheeeped Hoppster I think. I didn't like that DH. I'd rather you push on your own suspects. What do you think of Isa's recent play?

KCD is town town townnn. I like that guy alot.

Rice's vote was bad. Didn't think anything of it though. Wonder why people are on him.

That's about it.

I find Isa to be a good tenative vote. Don't want to potentially quicklynch or allow for it.

FoS:Isa

no. no fence sitting.

I really like this quote.

[Ranmaru]

Soup = Parabollocks. Sorry lol, mixed it up. xD

[Ranmaru]

I don't see how that warrants your suspicion?

[Ranmaru]

Soup = Parabollocks. In this game. Parabollocks, is Soup.

I play with him offsite. He invited me to join this game.

[Ranmaru]

You can just check my wiki. Some of my games from offsite are linked and include Soup, or rather, Soupamario. I don't think this is a problem because I'd always refer to him as soup. (Such as when I played with him in the marathon games)

But like Soup says, it's a null tell. Focus else where.

If anyone else feels like bringing it up, they can. But there is nothing else to be drawn from this for now.

[Ranmaru]

Ran talk about people you didn't talk about, by the way.

They are nulls to me. Reads are still developing.

Sunset is slightly suspicious for trying to scumhun on a 'slip' because people have brought it up earlier. It seems like false concern.

Anyone else you have in mind?

[Ranmaru]

I think it personally doesn't matter unless you're trying to give reasons to meta me.

back on topic...

Nah, I'm not. It seems Sunset doesn't really 'believe' my explanation.

[Ranmaru]

loolll.

I mean since you saw people ragging on Vifam for 'slipping', you took the idea to fake concern about me addressing Parabollocks as Soup. That was my point.

I can confirm it. Gurren Lagen. I looked at the scum qt, and I couldn't tell which poster was Soup haha. (I was in that game too)

But I don't really see how that helps you believe me tho.

[Ranmaru]

I don't know. I find it as a null tell, but he was accused of slipping. That is a possibility.

[Ranmaru]

Back got electricity. : D

I'll be catching up tonite.

[Ranmaru]

#619

Good catch Hoppster. I'm starting to like you.

Vote: Sunset

I don't think your defense really explains the contradiction, Sunny. I mean, it appears like you did intend on letting BL go with the meta, and it seems like a fake scum read.

---

Vote: stormer

explaix?

once he pops his head up i will

Where you at soup? He did pop his head, when you voted him.

Stormer, why haven't you said anything?

---

GUYS DONT GET DISTRACTED.

LYNCH BUNNYLOVER FOR BEING WEIRD AROUND THE RBT WAGON.

RBT's flip looks more like an independent flip, since he's in the island, and not with others, meaning he's solo. (possibly) How does this look like to you from this pov? (wrt to Bunny)

Don't like Bunnylover, probScum, but Jakalope seems worse to me.

VOTE: Jaka

Analysis when my stomach stops churning.

How's that analysis coming

Everyone

: KCda is still town to me. IF you think he's scum, state your reason as to why.

[Ranmaru]

Mod: I need to be replaced. I'm sorry, but school just started, and i'm in too many games. Some are finishing so I'll let them finish and won't play as much, but here I have to replace. Sorry everyone. I have tried playing multiple games before and it has ended in bad class grades because I have procrastinated and such.

unvote

I don't usually replace out, but sometimes in life I have to do the right thing. Which is keep up with school. Take it easy guys.

[Ranmaru]

GG's. Good job Warrior for fulfilling your condition! That makes me happy.

Sorry about replacing out... this was the first time I have ever done such a thing, I felt it was nessesary because I was getting over loaded, and I had to focus on school. It was fun. :3

[Ranmaru]

that was a big AtE post but dammit his ISo is better by fuckin miles.

I'm just hoping that this is right.

I don't think it matters if a town read ATE's or not... : P I mean I think you know anyone can, you just have to spot if the person is ATE'ing on purpose to seem legit.

Anyways, you were pretty towny to me even tho I was scum.

[Ranmaru]

or do you want to move this discussion over to the scummy thread where you can join the other idiots in orgasming over warrior mode doing jack shit while vifam sets him up even though he should have been lynched the second after town noticed that he was "left alive"?

Vifam's setup was the best play of this game and it wasn't even DONE at the right time. the mafia deserved the win. they got it. they do NOT deserve scummies.

Why doesn't Vifam or Warrior deserve a scummy?

[Ranmaru]

I see. Don't get the whatever though, I was just curious.

[Ranmaru]

PINK LEMONADE IN THE SCUM QT

Lol damn it. No one will see that name again.