[REVIEW] Open Setup Reviews

davesaz · Post Post #875 (isolation #0) » Sat Feb 08, 2020 6:46 pm

TSE, how many players in that game? Is that meant to be a bunch of options that are chosen from randomly?

davesaz · Post Post #879 (isolation #1) » Sun Feb 09, 2020 12:00 pm

On top of pops' comment, TSE's setup looks solvable with a massclaim. I think the SK/Guardian Angel/Witch trio would have a better chance of being viable in a larger game alongside more VTs and a regular mafia team.

davesaz · Post Post #882 (isolation #2) » Sun Feb 09, 2020 12:16 pm

For the Donnie Brasco setup, day kill ends the day right? Daytalk, or no?
Can mafia break it by figuring out which of those 4 the town are unwilling to lynch? Does town have to lynch Donnie to prevent mafia from winning via lucky shot?
Does Donnie get to make a N0 prevent? If not, scum have a chance to win with 1st post, if they yolo daykill. Of course choosing poorly messes up their chances pretty badly.
Questions aside I'm intrigued by the idea. It would take more than a few minutes of thought to come up with the optimum way to play each role and that's a good sign.

Pedit: agree that predicting the daykill submitter seems hard, which means it's really swingy.